Lightscribe - worth it?
Discussion
I built a new PC for myself a while ago and included 2 lightscribe drives. They were HP and cost about £24 each.
Then I tried to buy some disks
How much?
If you buy them singly, you may as well ask the dealer to push them straight up your bottom, as shafted is a fitting description. Ebay is your friend as I bought 100 HP DVD disks including postage for about £45 (4 cake tins of 25), so that equates to 45p per disk. If you email the large DVD media companies, they can sell you unbranded (but OEM disks like HP) for about 22p per disk if you buy 100 or more. This is what I am going to do next.
Second issue is speed. To burn a full greyscale image on your disk can take upto 40 minutes per disk for high quality graphics. If you just use wrapped text in 36 pica Bold it will still take about 5 minutes if you set high quality mode (better contrast).
Overall the experience for me can be summed up as:
Pro's: Looks superb - I have copied my entire DVD collection and all the disks look the same.
Con's: Its not a cheap way to label but I still think its cheaper than printing high quality labels like Pressit.
The discs take time to burn the top then the bottom. In most cases I can burn DVD data faster than it takes to burn the bloody label.
Just to say it's crap doesn't do the technology justice - it's fairer to say it's expensive, slow and crap would be more accurate
Then I tried to buy some disks
How much?If you buy them singly, you may as well ask the dealer to push them straight up your bottom, as shafted is a fitting description. Ebay is your friend as I bought 100 HP DVD disks including postage for about £45 (4 cake tins of 25), so that equates to 45p per disk. If you email the large DVD media companies, they can sell you unbranded (but OEM disks like HP) for about 22p per disk if you buy 100 or more. This is what I am going to do next.
Second issue is speed. To burn a full greyscale image on your disk can take upto 40 minutes per disk for high quality graphics. If you just use wrapped text in 36 pica Bold it will still take about 5 minutes if you set high quality mode (better contrast).
Overall the experience for me can be summed up as:
Pro's: Looks superb - I have copied my entire DVD collection and all the disks look the same.
Con's: Its not a cheap way to label but I still think its cheaper than printing high quality labels like Pressit.
The discs take time to burn the top then the bottom. In most cases I can burn DVD data faster than it takes to burn the bloody label.
Just to say it's crap doesn't do the technology justice - it's fairer to say it's expensive, slow and crap would be more accurate

Unless you're absolutely counting every last penny of your upgrade, or unless you have absolutely no desire to ever try burning a Lightscribe label, then you might as well go for a drive with the capability - you won't be compromising on the other capabilities of the drive, so it's really just down to whether you want to spend the extra few quid.
Personally I reckon Lightscribed labels look bloody excellent on CDs where the labelling layer is right on the top surface of the disc and you end up with a crisp high-contrast image (allowing you to get away with using a shorter burn time), but not so hot on DVDs where the layer is sandwiched in the middle and the end result looks a bit fuzzy and washed out (even if you opt for the super-extended-all-nighter* labelling speeds) - for DVD labelling I've now started using inkjet-printable discs (having also finally having got around to upgrading my old steam-driven photo-quality inkjet, and gaining disc printing capabilities as a side effect) which look superb and print in seconds.
Of course, as has been mentioned above, you have to factor in the time it takes to burn both sides of the disc, and with data burn times plummeting faster than a rapidly descending thing, you may find the rather pedestrian labelling speeds to be a bit too much like a throwback to the good old days of CD/DVD burning (ah, memories of the days when 4x CD burners were considered cutting-edge, and when multi-tasking during a burn was an absolute no-no unless you wanted to end up with a buffer underrun and another coaster to add to the collection...).
Hmm, I guess what I'm trying to get at here is that Lightscribe isn't a pile of rubbish, but neither is it the dogs doo-dahs. If you don't want to shell out for an inkjet printer with disc printing capabilities, but you do still want to get away from hand-written labels or those damn annoying sticky labels which never quite go on exactly centered or start to scuff around the edges if you're using a slot-loading drive, then Lightscribe is worth considering - and as I said at the start, you might as well get a LS-capable drive anyway just to give you the option of using it.
* only slightly exaggerated...
Personally I reckon Lightscribed labels look bloody excellent on CDs where the labelling layer is right on the top surface of the disc and you end up with a crisp high-contrast image (allowing you to get away with using a shorter burn time), but not so hot on DVDs where the layer is sandwiched in the middle and the end result looks a bit fuzzy and washed out (even if you opt for the super-extended-all-nighter* labelling speeds) - for DVD labelling I've now started using inkjet-printable discs (having also finally having got around to upgrading my old steam-driven photo-quality inkjet, and gaining disc printing capabilities as a side effect) which look superb and print in seconds.
Of course, as has been mentioned above, you have to factor in the time it takes to burn both sides of the disc, and with data burn times plummeting faster than a rapidly descending thing, you may find the rather pedestrian labelling speeds to be a bit too much like a throwback to the good old days of CD/DVD burning (ah, memories of the days when 4x CD burners were considered cutting-edge, and when multi-tasking during a burn was an absolute no-no unless you wanted to end up with a buffer underrun and another coaster to add to the collection...).
Hmm, I guess what I'm trying to get at here is that Lightscribe isn't a pile of rubbish, but neither is it the dogs doo-dahs. If you don't want to shell out for an inkjet printer with disc printing capabilities, but you do still want to get away from hand-written labels or those damn annoying sticky labels which never quite go on exactly centered or start to scuff around the edges if you're using a slot-loading drive, then Lightscribe is worth considering - and as I said at the start, you might as well get a LS-capable drive anyway just to give you the option of using it.
* only slightly exaggerated...
Civpilot said:
Well I got one ages ago and it works pretty well. There is a freely available patch (thats quite old) that enables the drive to make the image darker. All my car CD's look much better imaged than if I just written the album titles in pen.
If they are in the magazine/player or your CD case you can't see the label so who cares?Mattt said:
I was thinking of getting one, but a friend is an IT tech and says they are crap so I didn't bother 
Well, I'm an IT Tech and say there're not ... of course, it's personal opinion 

I have one on my laptop, how do I rate it, excellent.
OK, it's slow on the highest quality, but so what, just let it do it's thing, as I don't use lightscribe media all the time.
Disks - easily available on the net, not massivly expensive compare to "normal" media if you look around.
Labels shouldn't be stuck on disks, they usually come off (eventually), and unbalance the disk - not recommended (and this I gained from a well known media suppliers tech lab).
They look the business, very professional - I need a new burner for work, so will be getting one lightscribe enabled.
Of course, another option is printable media, if your printer is able to take these.
Martin
Edited by mph999 on Tuesday 17th July 23:47
Trooper2 said:
The DVD writer I bought 2 days ago has Lightscribe but I don't plan on using it. Seems like a lot of extra wear and tear on the laser, potentiometers, Etc. Water based CD markers work fine for me.

Trooper are you pissed up?
"A lot of wear and tear on the laser, potentiometers"

It's a beam of light for Christ's sake - how can that wear out? And what about these potentiometers ?
Let's hope that Pigeon doesn't see this post

Trooper2 said:
Civpilot said:
Well I got one ages ago and it works pretty well. There is a freely available patch (thats quite old) that enables the drive to make the image darker. All my car CD's look much better imaged than if I just written the album titles in pen.
If they are in the magazine/player or your CD case you can't see the label so who cares?
.When I create the disc's I usually do other stuff at the same time so its much easier to have a pre-designed label that just needs some text changing each time (for the artist/album title) than it is having to sit and write it all out each time in pen. My car has a single CD with MP3 capability, so each disc has 8 or 9 albums on it. So when I open my CD case I actually get a nice looking easy to read scribed disc, rather than a hand written one.
The only bind of lightscribe is having to turn the disc over when its time to burn the label, but thats hardly a big problem.
FlossyThePig said:
SVP sell a pack of 100 unbranded CD-Rs for £22.49 and an HP dvd writer for £24.49
I got Dabs monthly 'magazine' yesterday and that got Infiniti Lightscribe CDR's for £6.67 (inc VAT) for 25.They also have Samsung Lightscribe drives for £18.19 (inc VAT).
and dabs aren't normally the cheapest.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


