Routers / WLAN / WEP / SSID / MAC etc...
Discussion
Folks, a little help if you please?
Is there something basic that I just don't get with wireless networking?
I know that WEP is crap these days but it's the best my router does. However, I can never get any of my laptops to talk to the router when it is enabled, even playing about with little endian/big endian numbers. Hence I give up.
MAC addressing seems to work and would appear to be the closest thing to security I have.
Why when I hide my SSID can my laptop no longer see the router? I suppose it's pretty obvious really, but why would one expect it still to work? It seems to for most people...
Is it because I just have a crap router? It was supposed to be the dogs danglies when I bought it 4 years ago for about 200 quid (Draytek Vigor 2600) but the wireless bit has never worked.
I am tempted to throw it out and buy a new one, or at least a new wireless access point.
Thoughts?
Is there something basic that I just don't get with wireless networking?
I know that WEP is crap these days but it's the best my router does. However, I can never get any of my laptops to talk to the router when it is enabled, even playing about with little endian/big endian numbers. Hence I give up.
MAC addressing seems to work and would appear to be the closest thing to security I have.
Why when I hide my SSID can my laptop no longer see the router? I suppose it's pretty obvious really, but why would one expect it still to work? It seems to for most people...
Is it because I just have a crap router? It was supposed to be the dogs danglies when I bought it 4 years ago for about 200 quid (Draytek Vigor 2600) but the wireless bit has never worked.
I am tempted to throw it out and buy a new one, or at least a new wireless access point.
Thoughts?
Have always thought SSID hiding creates more problems that it solves anyway, so I would just not bother.
With WEP, and MAC address filtering as well, you are going to deter any casual neighbourhood snooping. It won't stand up to an industrial strength attack, but then unless you are MI5 are you really that bothered ? SSID hiding won't make your WLAN any more secure.
Even with a fairly modern router and latop, a hidden SSID has caused me grief, particularly with Vista as it kept adding the newly discovered network each time Noger (1) Noger (2) etc. And as soon as it connected it thought there was ANOTHER WLAN but it was just the old one again.
With WEP, and MAC address filtering as well, you are going to deter any casual neighbourhood snooping. It won't stand up to an industrial strength attack, but then unless you are MI5 are you really that bothered ? SSID hiding won't make your WLAN any more secure.
Even with a fairly modern router and latop, a hidden SSID has caused me grief, particularly with Vista as it kept adding the newly discovered network each time Noger (1) Noger (2) etc. And as soon as it connected it thought there was ANOTHER WLAN but it was just the old one again.
It depends on your operating system, I'm assuming you're running some sort of Windows. Wireless networking support only really got properly functional in XP, in 2000 you were at the mercy of the wireless network card vendor's software. Even then it's shonky compared to the Mac. I have absolutely no idea how Vista does it.
If the SSID is hidden then your laptop won't see it in a browse, obviously (that's the whole point of hiding the SSID). However if your software allows it, you should be able to enter the SSID name *manually* and the connection should be made OK.
MAC address filtering works well, since to hack that really requires a promiscuous sniffer (like Kismet), then some way of changing the MAC address on the hacker's wireless interface (possible in unix-type OSes like Linux and OS X, but not for casual users), then waiting for the other 'real' computer to shut down. Connecting to the router using the same MAC address as your 'real' computer at the same time, depending on the router, can cause chaos since the routing tables will see two IPs with the same MAC and this isn't valid.
Realistically, since duffing around with your own machine's network interface MAC address is dangerous, casual crackers and the odd war-driving loon with a Pringles cantenna will ignore your network if it has MAC address filtering. Only the determined would bother IMO, and a neighbour who would want to use the router at the same time as you, with the same MAC address, would cause problems on the network and be very obvious.
If the SSID is hidden then your laptop won't see it in a browse, obviously (that's the whole point of hiding the SSID). However if your software allows it, you should be able to enter the SSID name *manually* and the connection should be made OK.
MAC address filtering works well, since to hack that really requires a promiscuous sniffer (like Kismet), then some way of changing the MAC address on the hacker's wireless interface (possible in unix-type OSes like Linux and OS X, but not for casual users), then waiting for the other 'real' computer to shut down. Connecting to the router using the same MAC address as your 'real' computer at the same time, depending on the router, can cause chaos since the routing tables will see two IPs with the same MAC and this isn't valid.
Realistically, since duffing around with your own machine's network interface MAC address is dangerous, casual crackers and the odd war-driving loon with a Pringles cantenna will ignore your network if it has MAC address filtering. Only the determined would bother IMO, and a neighbour who would want to use the router at the same time as you, with the same MAC address, would cause problems on the network and be very obvious.
Having to log on to the router to add a MAC address when a mate says "can I check my email" can be pain.
Vista has an option that allows non broadcast SSID networks to appear in your "Find a network" box. It shows up as "Unamed Network". This is different to XP etc. Where, IIRC, you never saw the network, you just told it the name and then it went to look.
It doesn't work that well however, as you connect to "Unamed Network" which then shows up with the real name, but then another "Unamed Network" appears - can make you wonder where the heck this OTHER network suddenly appeared from !
But yes, I would get another router. Pretty cheap and they seem pretty bombproof (I have a Belkin) now compared to being a bit flaky a few years ago.
Vista has an option that allows non broadcast SSID networks to appear in your "Find a network" box. It shows up as "Unamed Network". This is different to XP etc. Where, IIRC, you never saw the network, you just told it the name and then it went to look.
It doesn't work that well however, as you connect to "Unamed Network" which then shows up with the real name, but then another "Unamed Network" appears - can make you wonder where the heck this OTHER network suddenly appeared from !
But yes, I would get another router. Pretty cheap and they seem pretty bombproof (I have a Belkin) now compared to being a bit flaky a few years ago.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


