RAM Testing unit
Author
Discussion

_Deano

Original Poster:

7,414 posts

284 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Hi,

I need to find a store that will sell a RAM testing unit. I have some RAM sticks that are not allowing a PC to boot up, but i don't want to take my machine apart to test them. Is there a unit that i can buy that will allow me to to test the hardware?
thanks
dj

beanbag

7,346 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
_Deano said:
Hi,

I need to find a store that will sell a RAM testing unit. I have some RAM sticks that are not allowing a PC to boot up, but i don't want to take my machine apart to test them. Is there a unit that i can buy that will allow me to to test the hardware?
thanks
dj
Yup, but they are very specialist and cost quite a bit. Can't find any on Google products but I remember they were about £100. You also have to take the computer apart anyway so you might as well do that!

Use http://www.memtest86.com/ to test it....

Good luck! smile

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

_Deano

Original Poster:

7,414 posts

284 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
forgot to mention that my machine is running on DDR2 memory while the memory that isn't working is DDR and SD-RAM.
Do you still have the name of the unit?
Cost is not a problem.

beanbag

7,346 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
_Deano said:
forgot to mention that my machine is running on DDR2 memory while the memory that isn't working is DDR and SD-RAM.
Do you still have the name of the unit?
Cost is not a problem.
I don't remember the name of the unit as this was a while back, however this should do the trick:

http://www.uxd.com/rstpro2.shtml (No price but given that the next unit is £1595, I reckon it's about £1000 at least!)

Just buy some new memory!


GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
_Deano said:
I have some RAM sticks that are not allowing a PC to boot up, but i don't want to take my machine apart to test them.
Don't understand - surely if you test them outside the machine then you will have to remove them anyway?

I would have thought that your best bet was to use a software memory diagnostic (there are plenty of free ones available) either in the current PC, or in a separate PC compatible with the RAM in question.

_Deano

Original Poster:

7,414 posts

284 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
_Deano said:
I have some RAM sticks that are not allowing a PC to boot up, but i don't want to take my machine apart to test them.
Don't understand - surely if you test them outside the machine then you will have to remove them anyway?

I would have thought that your best bet was to use a software memory diagnostic (there are plenty of free ones available) either in the current PC, or in a separate PC compatible with the RAM in question.
I can see where you are coming from.

My machine is fine, but inside there is DDR2 memory. The memory sticks in question are DDR and SD-RAM, these won't fit in my machine and i don't have a PC that is compatible, hence the reason why i am asking for a unit. Had the RAM came from one of my machines then i would be able to use it with a tester from the web.

Simon.

198 posts

252 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Where abouts in the POST stage is it failing? Can you see the memory in the BIOS.
The memtest86 program mentioned earlier doesn't touch the OS, you simply boot up a cd and run the test from that.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
_Deano said:
GreenV8S said:
_Deano said:
I have some RAM sticks that are not allowing a PC to boot up, but i don't want to take my machine apart to test them.
Don't understand - surely if you test them outside the machine then you will have to remove them anyway?

I would have thought that your best bet was to use a software memory diagnostic (there are plenty of free ones available) either in the current PC, or in a separate PC compatible with the RAM in question.
I can see where you are coming from.

My machine is fine, but inside there is DDR2 memory. The memory sticks in question are DDR and SD-RAM, these won't fit in my machine and i don't have a PC that is compatible, hence the reason why i am asking for a unit. Had the RAM came from one of my machines then i would be able to use it with a tester from the web.
Problem is, as others have said, standalone RAM testers are very expensive. I mean £1,500ish to test "a few sticks" is a bit yikes If you had a few pallets full of the stuff then not a problem, you'll recoup during sale.

Gut feeling is that the sticks are working A-ok and other than an AS bag don't need further testing. I know RAM can go bad and I know people have brought bad sticks before, but, number of faults Vs number of units encountered = very small chance of a bad stick these days.

Now if you were talking DRAM/VRAM chips or SIP's we're in to a different ball game IMHO smile

SneakyNeil

9,297 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
You can pick up an onboard VGA DDR motherboard and a celeron CPU for jack shit these days... if your desk is nonconductive you don't even need a case to put them in.

I'd assess the market value of the RAM before making a decision either way!

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

SneakyNeil

9,297 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
I just thought I'd add, it should be bourne in mind that testing in the ways thusfar mentioned is artificial and therefore not a 100% perfect reflection on how the ram will perform in a real working situation. The only 100% test is real work in a 100% real situation. If it worked, it was fine smile

I rate memtest as excellent, a really top tool, use it a lot. But it is still artificial and several times I've seen ram that would run memtest all night with no errors, yet when replaced would cure the machines problem. Although if memtest does say it's bad then you'll never make a stable machine out of it.

_Deano

Original Poster:

7,414 posts

284 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
RAM is failing at the Pre POST, red light flashing on the compaq and losts of bleeping. The unit is not for me, but for the IT dept in a large company so they have an unlimited budget and i the fact that they are going through a stange of upgrading most of the machines here i think that they want to be on the safe side.

Got a few places where i can buy a unit, thanks for all your help and input smile

dj