Killer MacBook
Discussion
Burned by a MacBook
Slightly worrying the fact that the cable managed to melt and short out, i didn't realise such a low amperage could provide such spectacular results
Slightly worrying the fact that the cable managed to melt and short out, i didn't realise such a low amperage could provide such spectacular results
I agree with some of the comments.
She brought a "business critical" machine but didn't get a "business critical" level of warranty. The laptop was charging under the sofa on the carpet, that's just dumb; I'm stupid and I don't leave my laptop on the floor to charge. She got a lemon, it happens, they're all [manufacturers] the same in that respect; sometimes a 'friday afternooner' lands on your doorstep.
I agree the cable shorting out and melting seems odd, but much like the Daily Wail article on the MOD house purchase; I smell something else happening here.
However, the title doesn't fit the article. It would be more accurate to say "I skimped on the warranty and it bit me on the ass hard." or "I did something funky with it and look what happened" or "Apple's known grumpy power bricks bite again".
She brought a "business critical" machine but didn't get a "business critical" level of warranty. The laptop was charging under the sofa on the carpet, that's just dumb; I'm stupid and I don't leave my laptop on the floor to charge. She got a lemon, it happens, they're all [manufacturers] the same in that respect; sometimes a 'friday afternooner' lands on your doorstep.
I agree the cable shorting out and melting seems odd, but much like the Daily Wail article on the MOD house purchase; I smell something else happening here.
However, the title doesn't fit the article. It would be more accurate to say "I skimped on the warranty and it bit me on the ass hard." or "I did something funky with it and look what happened" or "Apple's known grumpy power bricks bite again".
I sent back by mag-safe adaptor as soon as it started to 'go' in that area. You won't find my story on-line as it's an old problem with apple power bricks and you learn to recognise it after the first instance and then avoid bein burnt or electrocuted! It is bad though I would agree and very frustrating. I would suggest however that this person used that adaptor long after they should have done to get a result like that.
As for leaving it charging under the sofa, well thats just not very clever at all is it especially as he/she seems so wise on health and safety issues.

Edited to add:
The problem with Apple's power supplies is all around the way they secure the plug to the cable. Almost everybody uses this kind of bonding
sorry about the quality of the pick but you can see waht I mean. A bond that has tapered seamingly heat bonded reinforced sleeve that extend onto the cable about half an inch. Apple refuse to use this for some weird reason and instead continue with the crappy solution you see in the picture in that story which is a loose 3-4mm sleeve that provides little in the way of reinforcement and allows with cable to break out of the plug over time.
As for leaving it charging under the sofa, well thats just not very clever at all is it especially as he/she seems so wise on health and safety issues.

Edited to add:
The problem with Apple's power supplies is all around the way they secure the plug to the cable. Almost everybody uses this kind of bonding
sorry about the quality of the pick but you can see waht I mean. A bond that has tapered seamingly heat bonded reinforced sleeve that extend onto the cable about half an inch. Apple refuse to use this for some weird reason and instead continue with the crappy solution you see in the picture in that story which is a loose 3-4mm sleeve that provides little in the way of reinforcement and allows with cable to break out of the plug over time.Edited by Olf on Thursday 19th July 08:54
The flip out arms on the power bricks are there for a reason, and you can comfortably coil up the power lead without ripping out the cable. Equally the Magsafe is easy to remove by doing what it says in the manual, i.e. not pulling along the line of magnetic force but flipping it out. You can break any manufacturer's power leads if you're a clumsy gorilla who just yanks at things. 
I run a Macbook as my business critical device and it performs perfectly. If I'd had two warranty repairs then I'd already have bought a new one or asked for a fresh replacement.
Sorry, but to compound this with charging the laptop under the sofa on carpet is also foolish. You can see perfectly clearly if the power cable is internally compromised near the Magsafe plug. Continuing in these circumstances is stupidity.
Random comment that they're not 'business critical' machines? FFS this is an idiot who did all the wrong things with a lemon machine.

I run a Macbook as my business critical device and it performs perfectly. If I'd had two warranty repairs then I'd already have bought a new one or asked for a fresh replacement.
Sorry, but to compound this with charging the laptop under the sofa on carpet is also foolish. You can see perfectly clearly if the power cable is internally compromised near the Magsafe plug. Continuing in these circumstances is stupidity.
Random comment that they're not 'business critical' machines? FFS this is an idiot who did all the wrong things with a lemon machine.

Edited by cyberface on Thursday 19th July 09:17
I'm sure that can't just happen overnight. I reckon the connector was showing sign of wear/cable fray but she just kept using it instead of doing the sensible thing and returning it BEFORE the inevitable happened. Commonsense that would apply to any electrical appliance - don't use it if the power cable is damaged!
Used mine every day (and every night, overnight, unattended!) since I bought it nearly a year ago and it's still going strong. So much for her warning at the end of the article.
Never let the truth spoil a good headline etc. etc
Used mine every day (and every night, overnight, unattended!) since I bought it nearly a year ago and it's still going strong. So much for her warning at the end of the article.
Never let the truth spoil a good headline etc. etc
The whole "boo hoo, I'm losing work I have no computer" is a total crock of shit. She's a journo who relies entirely on a computer to work and she has no backup in place for when her computer fails?
In the article she mentions charging her laptop under the sofa, then a complaint about the apple charger being a fire risk in the same sentence. Please.
Two pieces of evidence there of her level of intelligence, the whole article is rubbish.
speeeling ediit.
In the article she mentions charging her laptop under the sofa, then a complaint about the apple charger being a fire risk in the same sentence. Please.

Two pieces of evidence there of her level of intelligence, the whole article is rubbish.
speeeling ediit.
Edited by _dobbo_ on Friday 20th July 09:04
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




