Vista x64 worth going for yet?
Discussion
Rednut05 said:
Hi,
I was wondering if Vista x64 is worth the buy?
I was wanting to run 4 gig of RAM and know that the 32 bit operating systems will only detect this at 3.5 Gig max.
My computer is fine to run Vista 32 bit with no driver issues.
Cheers.
David
I run it on a couple of my workstations and it's superb, much faster and more stable than the 32-bit version, and I haven't had any major issues with hardware or software compatability. I'd recommend it.I was wondering if Vista x64 is worth the buy?
I was wanting to run 4 gig of RAM and know that the 32 bit operating systems will only detect this at 3.5 Gig max.
My computer is fine to run Vista 32 bit with no driver issues.
Cheers.
David
Personally, I wouldn't. 64bit is fine if you're running a workstation where hardware doesn't really change and you're 100% certain you can get drivers/work out compatibility issues/oddities, helps to have a few geeks ambling around as well.
For home use; I really can't see the point of 64bit Vista over 32bit other than removing the 4Gb memory limiter it won't bring anything 'wow' to the table. Plus before feeding the disk in I'd make 100% sure all the hardware you're planning on feeding it is a) supported b) has drivers (either vendor made or the rudimentary built-in stuff) and finally c) that the software you are going to run is known to work (i.e. Anti-virus/Firewall vendor).
I'd also add d) that if you do need a 3rd party driver for say your network card or ADSL modem... that you download it and burn it to a CD-ROM BEFORE installing the OS else you'll be kicking yourself
I'm pretty sure that Vista x86_64 will be as well behaved as a modern Linux x86_64 install, but I'm sure it'll also have it's own 'gotchas' and probably the Vista equivalent of: "Why are you linking to those libraries you stupid program?? The 32bit ones are HERE!". But I can't honestly say my Core 2 Duo is any quicker in 64bit mode than 32bit.
For home use; I really can't see the point of 64bit Vista over 32bit other than removing the 4Gb memory limiter it won't bring anything 'wow' to the table. Plus before feeding the disk in I'd make 100% sure all the hardware you're planning on feeding it is a) supported b) has drivers (either vendor made or the rudimentary built-in stuff) and finally c) that the software you are going to run is known to work (i.e. Anti-virus/Firewall vendor).
I'd also add d) that if you do need a 3rd party driver for say your network card or ADSL modem... that you download it and burn it to a CD-ROM BEFORE installing the OS else you'll be kicking yourself

I'm pretty sure that Vista x86_64 will be as well behaved as a modern Linux x86_64 install, but I'm sure it'll also have it's own 'gotchas' and probably the Vista equivalent of: "Why are you linking to those libraries you stupid program?? The 32bit ones are HERE!". But I can't honestly say my Core 2 Duo is any quicker in 64bit mode than 32bit.
I'm running Vista x64 here - overall, I'm pretty pleased with it, but there are still one or two niggles I need to sort out. Some drivers are still very much in their infancy, so performance and reliability can only get better (not looking at anyone in particular... nVidia, Logitech and Creative). I use my system mainly for gaming - I have Tomb Raider Anniversary, STALKER and Colin McRae: DiRT installed and they seem to be running pretty well most of the time, apart from the odd driver-related crash. No noticeable effects running 64-bit, except for performance improvements in native 64-bit games (of which there are very few).
Vista x64 does have some peculiar quirks though - for example, on some hardware configurations (mine included) installation fails if you have more than 3Gb RAM installed. You end up stuck in a reboot loop
[k]
Vista x64 does have some peculiar quirks though - for example, on some hardware configurations (mine included) installation fails if you have more than 3Gb RAM installed. You end up stuck in a reboot loop

[k]
[k]arl said:
I'm running Vista x64 here - overall, I'm pretty pleased with it, but there are still one or two niggles I need to sort out. Some drivers are still very much in their infancy, so performance and reliability can only get better (not looking at anyone in particular... nVidia, Logitech and Creative). I use my system mainly for gaming - I have Tomb Raider Anniversary, STALKER and Colin McRae: DiRT installed and they seem to be running pretty well most of the time, apart from the odd driver-related crash. No noticeable effects running 64-bit, except for performance improvements in native 64-bit games (of which there are very few).
Vista x64 does have some peculiar quirks though - for example, on some hardware configurations (mine included) installation fails if you have more than 3Gb RAM installed. You end up stuck in a reboot loop
[k]
Why do you run 64? and what are your specs?Vista x64 does have some peculiar quirks though - for example, on some hardware configurations (mine included) installation fails if you have more than 3Gb RAM installed. You end up stuck in a reboot loop

[k]
I have a creative xfi and even if the drivers don't work with it, sounds not as good as it was with XP anyway so won't be totally dishearten.
Thepassenger - Thanks for the reply. I kind of knew you would come along with your helpful answers as that's what you do

David
As I think someone pointed out above, Vista x86 won't 'see' all 4Gb RAM in a PC so equipped. Call me an obsessive-compulsive type-A personality, but that simply wouldn't do
. Also, a number of really great upcoming games will be 64-bit optimised, so I imagine that some performance benefit can be derived.
My specs:
watercooled EVGA 680i motherboard
watercooled Intel Core 2 Quad 6700
4Gb OCZ PC-8500 RAM
2 x watercooled 768Mb BFG GeForce 8800GTX OC-WC's in SLI
SoundBlaster 64Mb X-Fi Fatality Pro Gamer
2 x 150Gb WD Raptor HDDs in RAID0, 74Gb WD Raptor & 500GB WD Caviar SE
2 x Samsung DVD writers
850w Etasis PSU
So far as x64 weirdness is concerned, I discovered a few of my favourite apps wouldn't work (eg Winamp, CDburner XP Pro and GIMP), but found suitable alternatives after a quick google.
I also had a few issues actually getting up and running - the main ones being the 4Gb install bug I mentioned in my earlier post, and a pretty serious driver problem with the X-Fi which rendered it entirely useless until I reverted from the 'release' driver to the beta version.
[k]
. Also, a number of really great upcoming games will be 64-bit optimised, so I imagine that some performance benefit can be derived.My specs:
watercooled EVGA 680i motherboard
watercooled Intel Core 2 Quad 6700
4Gb OCZ PC-8500 RAM
2 x watercooled 768Mb BFG GeForce 8800GTX OC-WC's in SLI
SoundBlaster 64Mb X-Fi Fatality Pro Gamer
2 x 150Gb WD Raptor HDDs in RAID0, 74Gb WD Raptor & 500GB WD Caviar SE
2 x Samsung DVD writers
850w Etasis PSU
So far as x64 weirdness is concerned, I discovered a few of my favourite apps wouldn't work (eg Winamp, CDburner XP Pro and GIMP), but found suitable alternatives after a quick google.
I also had a few issues actually getting up and running - the main ones being the 4Gb install bug I mentioned in my earlier post, and a pretty serious driver problem with the X-Fi which rendered it entirely useless until I reverted from the 'release' driver to the beta version.
[k]
[k]arl said:
Also, a number of really great upcoming games will be 64-bit optimised, so I imagine that some performance benefit can be derived.
All fair enough you OCD freak
But, considering some games companies I could mention but won't, have issues dealing with SMP systems and writing thread safe code... I really, really, really, hope they don't start releasing 64bit optimised exes, their programmers just aren't capable of doing it properly. Not just those games companies either who are having trouble with multi-component systems. MS has quietly released a Vista hotfix for a problem which, if I understand correctly, means that Vista won't pass instructions to a second video card in an SLI or Crossfire setup, regardless of what the driver is doing or attempting to do.
Having said that, STALKER really flies, even at 1920*1200 with all the options turned up to 11, regardless of whether it's only using 1 card or 2.
[k]
Having said that, STALKER really flies, even at 1920*1200 with all the options turned up to 11, regardless of whether it's only using 1 card or 2.
[k]
Edited by [k]arl on Wednesday 25th July 00:52
[k]arl said:
Not just those games companies either who are having trouble with multi-component systems. MS has quietly released a Vista hotfix for a problem which, if I understand correctly, means that Vista won't pass instructions to a second video card in an SLI or Crossfire setup, regardless of what the driver is doing or attempting to do.
Having said that, STALKER really flies, even at 1920*1200 with all the options turned up to 11, regardless of whether it's only using 1 card or 2.
[k]
where is this hotfix? I've noticed that I get the same 3DMark06 score with SLI enabled or disabled in Vista64.Having said that, STALKER really flies, even at 1920*1200 with all the options turned up to 11, regardless of whether it's only using 1 card or 2.
[k]
Edited by [k]arl on Wednesday 25th July 00:52
[k]arl said:
I also had a few issues actually getting up and running - the main ones being the 4Gb install bug I mentioned in my earlier post, and a pretty serious driver problem with the X-Fi which rendered it entirely useless until I reverted from the 'release' driver to the beta version.
Any more details of the Xi-Fi fixes pls? Even with Alchemy running I am finding it frustrating, I usually just boot into XP and forget about the Vista partition.One bit of weirdness I found whith Vista installation is that when i installed it for dual boot on my 2nd raid array, for some reason it has installed the boot manager on there too and didnt touch the xp boot block
- if I leave the vista CD in the drive, I get vista booted from the vista partiotion, if I dont have the CD in the drive, I get XP (as per the bios boot settings), how weird is that? Completely baffled me but I cant get any enthusiasm to try to sort it 
Anyway until creative/MS sort some proper sound drivers out, I don't think I will be moving to vista for gaming, even though I know I should just to get used to the damn thing and I have payed for it.
Karl,
Your set-up makes mine look a bit lame...
6600 Dual Core Duo.
4 gig of 800MHZ ram.
1x 8800 320mb GTS.
Creative Xfi Sound.
Raid 0 set-up.
It's all started because I thought I would treat myself to a new monitor. So one 22" later I was happy but decided I'd up the graphics card to improve the situation.
Then thought about going dual core as I'd noticed a slow down lately and well that meant new ram/ mobo/ CPU so bank account took a hit and now I'm wondering if I should go Vista 32 or 64 bit.
I'm on XP but I'm bored of it and thought everything else is new so why not update the operating system?
I brought 4 gig of ram not thinking about the limitations that I did know about at the back of my head. So I'm not taking it back, 4 is the new magic number and it's going to have to work because it's magic.
Drivers wise....
Nvidia for the graphics card is good to go.
Motherboard is good to go and compatible with DDR3 when out as well.
DVD drivers, guessing they're fine. Ones lightscribe!?!?
Creative. Hear it has problems but not much one can do. I'll still have sound.
Printers pretty new, has drivers out, good old Epson.
Now how about my 5 in 1 card reader?
David
Your set-up makes mine look a bit lame...
6600 Dual Core Duo.
4 gig of 800MHZ ram.
1x 8800 320mb GTS.
Creative Xfi Sound.
Raid 0 set-up.
It's all started because I thought I would treat myself to a new monitor. So one 22" later I was happy but decided I'd up the graphics card to improve the situation.
Then thought about going dual core as I'd noticed a slow down lately and well that meant new ram/ mobo/ CPU so bank account took a hit and now I'm wondering if I should go Vista 32 or 64 bit.
I'm on XP but I'm bored of it and thought everything else is new so why not update the operating system?
I brought 4 gig of ram not thinking about the limitations that I did know about at the back of my head. So I'm not taking it back, 4 is the new magic number and it's going to have to work because it's magic.
Drivers wise....
Nvidia for the graphics card is good to go.
Motherboard is good to go and compatible with DDR3 when out as well.
DVD drivers, guessing they're fine. Ones lightscribe!?!?
Creative. Hear it has problems but not much one can do. I'll still have sound.
Printers pretty new, has drivers out, good old Epson.
Now how about my 5 in 1 card reader?
David
Zod - details of the fix are here. Looks like MS is keeping this one close to its chest as you seem to have to contact them for a copy of the patch.
MickC - There seems to be a problem with the "release" version of the Creative X-Fi driver. When installed on my system, as soon as the audio engine fired up (just before the Vista logo on black background appears) I would hear a piercing, solid static sound from all the speakers, and nothing else at all. I simply reverted to the earlier "beta" driver, and that seems to have solved the problem. Apparently it's a known issue that Creative are looking to fix in the next driver revision - it seems to be most prevalent in 680i machines with SLI and/or 4Gb RAM. I must say that I've not looked into Alchemy yet and am just running the basic beta X-Fi driver. As for the RAID array, I noticed that during installation, Vista starting putting bootsector backups all over the place, so I had to disconnect everything apart from my RAID drives (where Vista, games & apps live), then add them back in once Vista was installed.
RedNut05 - Does your 5-in-1 card reader even need a driver? If it's USB, it should be plug and pray... sorry, play. My machine's internal card reader is like that and requires no drivers to work in Vista.
[k]
MickC - There seems to be a problem with the "release" version of the Creative X-Fi driver. When installed on my system, as soon as the audio engine fired up (just before the Vista logo on black background appears) I would hear a piercing, solid static sound from all the speakers, and nothing else at all. I simply reverted to the earlier "beta" driver, and that seems to have solved the problem. Apparently it's a known issue that Creative are looking to fix in the next driver revision - it seems to be most prevalent in 680i machines with SLI and/or 4Gb RAM. I must say that I've not looked into Alchemy yet and am just running the basic beta X-Fi driver. As for the RAID array, I noticed that during installation, Vista starting putting bootsector backups all over the place, so I had to disconnect everything apart from my RAID drives (where Vista, games & apps live), then add them back in once Vista was installed.
RedNut05 - Does your 5-in-1 card reader even need a driver? If it's USB, it should be plug and pray... sorry, play. My machine's internal card reader is like that and requires no drivers to work in Vista.
[k]
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





