Slooooow BT Broadband in the evenings
Discussion
I am at my wits end with BT....
I have 8mb broadband with them, live about 1 mile from the exchange. Symptoms are - incredibly fast access during the mornings / day - circa 6mb throughput downstream, which is excellent. Come the evening say circa 7pm onwards, this slows to an absolute crawl, closer to 512k throughput downstread, and very laggy.
Trying to get BT to do something about it - not a chance. Its everything but them - PC hardware at home, my router etc etc. Even though this problem is consistent day in and day out. They do ping tests, no loss of packets, latency good. So cleary the problem is my end. Yeah really...
Now, I manage IT infrastructure for our company across Europe, Middle East, Africa and South America, including our WAN connectivity. Still, they insist on talking to me as if I have never seen a piece of IT equipment in my life, and completely dismiss any suggestions I may have for things they could be looking at.
Think its time to boot BT out and find a new supplier...
I have 8mb broadband with them, live about 1 mile from the exchange. Symptoms are - incredibly fast access during the mornings / day - circa 6mb throughput downstream, which is excellent. Come the evening say circa 7pm onwards, this slows to an absolute crawl, closer to 512k throughput downstread, and very laggy.
Trying to get BT to do something about it - not a chance. Its everything but them - PC hardware at home, my router etc etc. Even though this problem is consistent day in and day out. They do ping tests, no loss of packets, latency good. So cleary the problem is my end. Yeah really...

Now, I manage IT infrastructure for our company across Europe, Middle East, Africa and South America, including our WAN connectivity. Still, they insist on talking to me as if I have never seen a piece of IT equipment in my life, and completely dismiss any suggestions I may have for things they could be looking at.
Think its time to boot BT out and find a new supplier...
Unfortunately this is an issue I hear a lot (I work for a small ISP, mainly business based but we manage a few home connections as well and am on first line so deal with the brunt of the connection issues). If the slow speed in the evenings is being caused by the traffic on the network (and sounds like it is) and is happening at an exchange level then unfortunately moving supplier won't change much as any 3rd party ISP (read: most ISPs) will be using the BT hardware in the exchange.
This will all change with the release of 21st century networks which was supposed to be late this year but has been pushed back to next.
But if the issue is not occuring at an exchange level then maybe an ISP switch would fix the issue as it could be their homegateway that is being clogged with network traffic.
I can only suggest trying to esculate the fault with BT, keep asking for the person's manager and see how high up you can get. I did this the other day and was on the phone for 6 hours for one of our customers.
This will all change with the release of 21st century networks which was supposed to be late this year but has been pushed back to next.
But if the issue is not occuring at an exchange level then maybe an ISP switch would fix the issue as it could be their homegateway that is being clogged with network traffic.
I can only suggest trying to esculate the fault with BT, keep asking for the person's manager and see how high up you can get. I did this the other day and was on the phone for 6 hours for one of our customers.
Some of this may be due to contention.
I'm guessing that most people use their broadband during the time you suggest, so if you have a 50:1 contention that is normal for home broadband packages, that is a lot of people sharing the same bandwidth.
It's also likely that they throttle the bandwidth too to keep total data transfer within reasonable limits. Most of the big carriers charge by the amount of data transferred, with limits on peak bandwidth, so it's only realistic that they need to limit the end users throughput occasionally.
Changing supplier may have little affect as most simply resell BT's service. Unless your local exchange is unbundled, in which case you may be in luck.
I'm guessing that most people use their broadband during the time you suggest, so if you have a 50:1 contention that is normal for home broadband packages, that is a lot of people sharing the same bandwidth.
It's also likely that they throttle the bandwidth too to keep total data transfer within reasonable limits. Most of the big carriers charge by the amount of data transferred, with limits on peak bandwidth, so it's only realistic that they need to limit the end users throughput occasionally.
Changing supplier may have little affect as most simply resell BT's service. Unless your local exchange is unbundled, in which case you may be in luck.
bobthemonkey said:
Yep, BT throttle connections in the evenings, from 5pm till midnight.
As do NTL/Telewest/Virgin or whatever they're calling themselves. It's the only explanation I've got for the odd bod happenings. I think you'd be better off moving to a business plan for you're home connection. Yes, it'll pretty much triple the costs but you get a lower contention ratio and less of the fiddling that you see when travelling cattle class.
sp60 said:
Changing supplier may have little affect as most simply resell BT's service.
Depends. If the bottleneck is on the DSLAM from the exchange to the BT IP network then it wont have any effect as everyone at your exchange will suffer the same irrespective of the ISP they use. If it is on the pipe from the BT IP network to the ISP then swapping ISP will sort it.I use A&A at home. They are everything an ISP should be IMO. Plus being mainly targetted at business users, their peak times are office hours.
ThePassenger said:
I think you'd be better off moving to a business plan for you're home connection. Yes, it'll pretty much triple the costs but you get a lower contention ratio and less of the fiddling that you see when travelling cattle class.
And as an added bonus, the call centres for BT Business Broadband are all in the UK...onomatopoeia said:
If it is on the pipe from the BT IP network to the ISP then swapping ISP will sort it.
As his ISP is BT, I kinda assumed that this wouldn't be an issue. I guess if BT has a seperate division for their ISP services, this could be a problem, but surely they wouldn't starve their own offshoot of bandwidth.sp60 said:
onomatopoeia said:
If it is on the pipe from the BT IP network to the ISP then swapping ISP will sort it.
As his ISP is BT, I kinda assumed that this wouldn't be an issue. I guess if BT has a seperate division for their ISP services, this could be a problem, but surely they wouldn't starve their own offshoot of bandwidth.It sounds like a contention issue to me. The only way around it is to use an unbundled provider who install their own bandwidth to the exchange. Even so, it is no guarantee against bandwidth degradation.
Another possibility is that the line is noisy, and LW/MW radio signals (which increase in strength at night due to various atmospheric effects) are being picked up by the phone line, increasing the noise. To diagnose that would need a comparison of modem stats and monitoring of if/when the modem re-syncs the line.
Another possibility is that the line is noisy, and LW/MW radio signals (which increase in strength at night due to various atmospheric effects) are being picked up by the phone line, increasing the noise. To diagnose that would need a comparison of modem stats and monitoring of if/when the modem re-syncs the line.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


