Upgrade, suggestions!
Discussion
Looking into upgrading soon (proabably within the next 2/3 months) CPU/mobo/RAM/Video/PSU etc.
Currently running Athlon64 3700+, 1gb RAM, 6800GS 256mb (which is still not bad
) and a couple of HD's.
Looking at a 6000+, not sure on mobo, 2/3gb RAM and probably an 8800GTS (don't think I'll quite stretch to a GTX) and a Silverstone (probably) 700w ish PSU.
Just wondered if there is anything you'd recommend instead?
I'll probably end up buying it all from Scan as a friend of mine can get free delivery
That and the seem teh cheapest for the stuff I've looked at!
Oh and another thing does any one run an Athlon FX?
Had a quick look at the FX's (didn't realise they were socket F only) but for the money is there a real advantage?
I mean the mobos are serious money and the processors are £80 more than a 6000+....
Thanks!
ETA The machine is only really for gaming. At the moment just have a pair of seagate drives, an 80gb to boot windows and a 300gb for everything else
Currently running Athlon64 3700+, 1gb RAM, 6800GS 256mb (which is still not bad
) and a couple of HD's.Looking at a 6000+, not sure on mobo, 2/3gb RAM and probably an 8800GTS (don't think I'll quite stretch to a GTX) and a Silverstone (probably) 700w ish PSU.
Just wondered if there is anything you'd recommend instead?
I'll probably end up buying it all from Scan as a friend of mine can get free delivery

That and the seem teh cheapest for the stuff I've looked at!
Oh and another thing does any one run an Athlon FX?
Had a quick look at the FX's (didn't realise they were socket F only) but for the money is there a real advantage?
I mean the mobos are serious money and the processors are £80 more than a 6000+....
Thanks!
ETA The machine is only really for gaming. At the moment just have a pair of seagate drives, an 80gb to boot windows and a 300gb for everything else

Edited by LukeBird on Sunday 29th July 00:45
If gaming be the machines bread and butter, drop a nasty nasty PCI-E 8000 series on to your current rig (I'm assuming that 6000 is a PCI-E unit), latest Nvidia drivers and bam.
If you do want a new uber gaming machine, you might want to take a look at Intel's offerings rather than AMD's. That 2MB cache in the full on vindaloo Core 2 Duo's packs a meatier punch than the itsy bitsy 512KB cache in the current crop of AMD X2's and it shows. Couldn't honestly justify a Core 2 Quad for games, it's a workstation/low end server chip to my mind and their are still a great many board that, whilst support it, don't do it justice.
Going to run Windows? That'll be XP-SP2 and you might as well go to 2GB of RAM and enter a holding pattern. Vista has shown some 'oddities' in certain popular games and large memory spaces (SupCom, CoH and Battlefield 2 were the ones tested by Ars Technica) and until Microsoft and Nvidia finish their argy bargy of Vista's virtual machine graphics system (as I've heard it described)... you'll take a performance hit and get weirdness in the memory allocation/falling over department. And no, Halo 2 (one of the very few DX10 games) doesn't justify the cost of Vista IMHO.
Drop in a nice Creative sound card and either some nice speakers or headphones and you're away. I hear good things about the X-Fi range.
If you do want a new uber gaming machine, you might want to take a look at Intel's offerings rather than AMD's. That 2MB cache in the full on vindaloo Core 2 Duo's packs a meatier punch than the itsy bitsy 512KB cache in the current crop of AMD X2's and it shows. Couldn't honestly justify a Core 2 Quad for games, it's a workstation/low end server chip to my mind and their are still a great many board that, whilst support it, don't do it justice.
Going to run Windows? That'll be XP-SP2 and you might as well go to 2GB of RAM and enter a holding pattern. Vista has shown some 'oddities' in certain popular games and large memory spaces (SupCom, CoH and Battlefield 2 were the ones tested by Ars Technica) and until Microsoft and Nvidia finish their argy bargy of Vista's virtual machine graphics system (as I've heard it described)... you'll take a performance hit and get weirdness in the memory allocation/falling over department. And no, Halo 2 (one of the very few DX10 games) doesn't justify the cost of Vista IMHO.
Drop in a nice Creative sound card and either some nice speakers or headphones and you're away. I hear good things about the X-Fi range.
LukeBird said:
Oh and another thing does any one run an Athlon FX?
Cock it. Just wrote you a nice long reply, and the computer (or more accurately, my cackhandedness) ate it.Socket F? Socket 939 and AM2 both support Athlon FX's - Ive got an A8N-Sli with an FX-60, and it was a good step up from the 4200+ I had previously. A couple of 7800GTX's in SLI run FEAR nicely.
Your upgrade path depends on how much you want to spend now, and how you see yourself upgrading in a year to 18 months.
An alternative suggestion to The passengers would be to go for an FX-60 (check to see your mobo will take it), another Gb of RAM, (and possibly the PSU) and use the savings from not having to buy the extra memory and mobo on an 8800GTX.
That'll run anything current pretty nicely, and is probably the cheapest worthwhile upgrade you can make.
When it comes time to upgrade again, the 8800 and PSU will be the only things reusable; buy another off of ebay for a damn sight less than they are now, and run them in SLI on whatever motherboard you get then to get similar performance to whatever the hot card is then (make sure the new mobo supports SLI!)
Alternatively, MSI do a nice Core 2 motherboard with 4 PCIe 16x slots and built in creative audigy X-Fi; buy one of these, 2GB RAM, the best processor you can afford and reuse the 6800 until you can afford a nice new 8800 or two...
edited to get quoting right...
And to reiterate the above advice that Intel is the way to go instead of AMD if you want shiny new hardware at the moment.Edited by jimmyjimjim on Sunday 29th July 07:25
LukeBird said:
Had a quick look at the FX's (didn't realise they were socket F only) but for the money is there a real advantage?
I see there is a Socket F...goes to show how poorly AMD is doing (in marketing, at least)in comparison to Intel at the high end at the moment.Not mentioned in Toms hardware charts, either. http://www.tomshardware.com/cpu.html
Looks like scan have stopped doing the older FX chips, as have everyone else; ebay or go Intel....
Right, the answers 
ThePassenger, yeah the 6800 is PCI-E (glad I went for that
)
Yeah I would be running XP Pro SP2, not interested in any of that Vista nonsense just yet!
I would assume that you wouldn't want to run what I was suggesting, off anything less than 700w?
Yeah the Core2Quad's are IMO not really worth the extra, had pretty much the same view on the new Athlon FX-70's.
The 6000+ has 2x1mb cache.
Plus being an AMD boy I'm more interested in them, especially when the equivalent Core2Duo is at £135 (the E6600) and the 6000+ is £105 retail boxed!
After both suggestions not sure If I want to do PSU and bung a full fat 8 series in it!
Don't know whether I could bring myself to spend £390 on a video card!
Quite like the idea of an EVGA one this time, http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?Web...
Well I'll have to have a tthink about what you guys said!
Depends if this new job comes up quicker and I don't have to waste the bonus I'm going to get on living!
Thanks!

ThePassenger, yeah the 6800 is PCI-E (glad I went for that
)Yeah I would be running XP Pro SP2, not interested in any of that Vista nonsense just yet!
I would assume that you wouldn't want to run what I was suggesting, off anything less than 700w?
Yeah the Core2Quad's are IMO not really worth the extra, had pretty much the same view on the new Athlon FX-70's.
The 6000+ has 2x1mb cache.
Plus being an AMD boy I'm more interested in them, especially when the equivalent Core2Duo is at £135 (the E6600) and the 6000+ is £105 retail boxed! After both suggestions not sure If I want to do PSU and bung a full fat 8 series in it!
Don't know whether I could bring myself to spend £390 on a video card!

Quite like the idea of an EVGA one this time, http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?Web...
Well I'll have to have a tthink about what you guys said!
Depends if this new job comes up quicker and I don't have to waste the bonus I'm going to get on living!
Thanks!
Price is not too much of a problem... (obviously within reason)
But I think I might wait until higher spec 65nm AMD CPU's are available...
I prefer AMD stuff and think that later on this year/early next the AMD stuff is going to be very comparable to Core2Duo, so would like to keep the upgrade for AMD.
But I think I might wait until higher spec 65nm AMD CPU's are available...
I prefer AMD stuff and think that later on this year/early next the AMD stuff is going to be very comparable to Core2Duo, so would like to keep the upgrade for AMD.
jimmyjimjim said:
LukeBird said:
Had a quick look at the FX's (didn't realise they were socket F only) but for the money is there a real advantage?
I see there is a Socket F...goes to show how poorly AMD is doing (in marketing, at least)in comparison to Intel at the high end at the moment.Not mentioned in Toms hardware charts, either. http://www.tomshardware.com/cpu.html
Looks like scan have stopped doing the older FX chips, as have everyone else; ebay or go Intel....

http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/brute-force-quad-cor...
There you are, thats the dual CPU mobo and a pair of FX-74's.
There are more motherboards available but they are min of £200.
Plus £400 for the CPU's, gets expensive....
Especially when I reckon that £250/275 for a mobo, 6000+ and 2gb of DDR2 800 RAM.
Thanks for the help as well!

AMD aren't as far behind as some will have you think, as always with some benchmarks/games AMD loose, with some they win.
Personally I'm running with a pair of Opteron 275 in my current PC, but I don't play huge amounts of games. Problem with SupremeCommander and a few others under Vista is that they end up using more than 2GB of memory.
Socket F - Is more aimed at servers right now, hence why most people haven't heard of it.
Personally I'm running with a pair of Opteron 275 in my current PC, but I don't play huge amounts of games. Problem with SupremeCommander and a few others under Vista is that they end up using more than 2GB of memory.
Socket F - Is more aimed at servers right now, hence why most people haven't heard of it.
Edited by LivinLaVidaLotus on Sunday 29th July 21:14
LivinLaVidaLotus said:
AMD aren't as far behind as some will have you think, as always with some benchmarks/games AMD loose, with some they win.
True and most synthetic benchmarks are just that... synthetic. But I don't know if it's drivers, chipsets, cache usage or what. I've played with AMD X2's of equal grunt to my C2D, they're very fine systems and would do anyone proud; however my C2D just feels 'snappier' and quicker to respond when under load. Didn't get a chance to delve in to the innards of them so couldn't tell you why that was. I'm pretty far from an Intel fan per say, my old old laptop was an AMD64 DTR unit and the current incarnation of the house's media server is running x86_64 on an AMD64. But, it'll probably get a C2D in it at some point.
LukeBird said:
Don't go to the damn American side 
http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/brute-force-quad-cor...
There you are, thats the dual CPU mobo and a pair of FX-74's.
There are more motherboards available but they are min of £200.
Plus £400 for the CPU's, gets expensive....
I remember reading that article as well; it confused me when I couldn't find it. I remembered socket 1207...didn't know it was called socket F as well.
http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/brute-force-quad-cor...
There you are, thats the dual CPU mobo and a pair of FX-74's.
There are more motherboards available but they are min of £200.
Plus £400 for the CPU's, gets expensive....
The intel route does appear to be slightly more sane in terms of your wallet at the moment...
LukeBird said:
I prefer AMD stuff and think that later on this year/early next the AMD stuff is going to be very comparable to Core2Duo, so would like to keep the upgrade for AMD.
I've been using AMD for ten years but I think the time to go to Intel is now. From what I hear, the C2D chips run much cooler than AMD's equivalents(!) making them more overclockable.I have a similar system to yours, with 3GB RAM and 3800+
I put an 8800GTX in it and now I think the CPU is the weak point in the system. Games like FEAR run incredibly smoothly but Stalker struggles with the dynamic lighting indoors. Things get choppy.
If you want an FX, buy an opteron and clock it a bit, even without overclocking the opterons are very good for gaming. Socket 939 as well so you wont have to change anything really, except add the gfx card of course and another gig of ram, or with prices as they are at the moment just buy a nice matched 2 gig pair.
Cheers
Tom
Cheers
Tom
Thanks for all the replies!
Even more to think about now!
Firstly, I'm going to need a mobo upgrade whatever, as I'm currently on Skt 754, not 939.
So I can't really see the point in going to 939, if AM2 is the latest!
I'm really, really torn because I'd like the whole upgrade!
I think I might go for a PSU, G25 (wooo!
), new DVD drive later on this month and see if I'll go for the new mobo, RAM and CPU and then go for new gfx next month.
Is there a massive difference between an 8800GTS 320/640mb and the 8800GTX?
I hadn't really planned to spend much more than £250 on gfx and £390 is a big difference!
Oh and card manufacturer, the EVGA stuff looks very nice, good/bad and does anyone have one?
Just a quick point regarding C2D and Athlon, I have no desire to OC, so the benefits that C2D brings with it regarding OC'ing is of no benefit to me...
I have looked at the C2D stuff but with an E6600 and a 6000+ being seperated by £30 (not massive I know, but more in the favour of the Athlon!) it makes the deal a little sweeter!
Even more to think about now!

Firstly, I'm going to need a mobo upgrade whatever, as I'm currently on Skt 754, not 939.
So I can't really see the point in going to 939, if AM2 is the latest!
I'm really, really torn because I'd like the whole upgrade!
I think I might go for a PSU, G25 (wooo!
), new DVD drive later on this month and see if I'll go for the new mobo, RAM and CPU and then go for new gfx next month.Is there a massive difference between an 8800GTS 320/640mb and the 8800GTX?
I hadn't really planned to spend much more than £250 on gfx and £390 is a big difference!

Oh and card manufacturer, the EVGA stuff looks very nice, good/bad and does anyone have one?
Just a quick point regarding C2D and Athlon, I have no desire to OC, so the benefits that C2D brings with it regarding OC'ing is of no benefit to me...
I have looked at the C2D stuff but with an E6600 and a 6000+ being seperated by £30 (not massive I know, but more in the favour of the Athlon!) it makes the deal a little sweeter!
With regard to the gfx and my above question on 8800GTS vs. 8800GTX, this is the card I had looked at, if I did decide to go all the way and stick in a GTX... http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?Web...
Good/bad?
My this upgrading thing is working out more than I ahd expected!
Good/bad?

My this upgrading thing is working out more than I ahd expected!

LukeBird said:
With regard to the gfx and my above question on 8800GTS vs. 8800GTX, this is the card I had looked at, if I did decide to go all the way and stick in a GTX... http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?Web...
Good/bad?
My this upgrading thing is working out more than I ahd expected!
Good choice, This is the only card I have bought that genuinely allows me to ‘max out’ game options and resolutions without reducing frame rates (to the naked eye!)Good/bad?

My this upgrading thing is working out more than I ahd expected!

Stalker/GTR1&2 looks absolutely stunning, as does Oblivion, and Medieval 2 TW looks almost real in the battles!
And of course, it’s great for my 3-d CAD rendering work….
About four months ago I built this:
- X2 5200+
- Asus M2N32-SLI Dlx
- 2GB HyperX
- 250GB / 250GB / 500GB
- 8800GTX
- X-Fi Fatality
- XP SP2
- Enermax Liberty 600W
- Logitech Z-5500
I think I built the perfect machine for my needs, except for two things. If I could do it all over again, I'd go Intel instead of AMD, and I would have gotten a GTS rather than a GTX (I've probably spent less than 10 hours gaming since I bought it, so it really is a waste of money. It's just the comfort of knowing should I ever want to game, I have all that juice available, but it's like buying an R8 to pootle around town).
I'd go Intel because they clearly have the upper hand in the horsepower wars at the moment, and I would have gone with a cheap Intel 775 CPU so that I have the option of jacking it in for one of the killer ones in future. But the thing is though, the prices of Intel chips reflect their standing relative to AMD's offerings, and how much power do we actually need? I find my 5200+ plenty fast for anything that I throw at it!
The X-Fis are excellent sound cards. And the Logitech Z-5500 speaker set (their top-of-the-range model) is quite phenomenal for what you pay for - by far the best computer-specific surround speaker set I've ever heard, which is critical to general enjoyment of all kinds of entertainment.
- X2 5200+
- Asus M2N32-SLI Dlx
- 2GB HyperX
- 250GB / 250GB / 500GB
- 8800GTX
- X-Fi Fatality
- XP SP2
- Enermax Liberty 600W
- Logitech Z-5500
I think I built the perfect machine for my needs, except for two things. If I could do it all over again, I'd go Intel instead of AMD, and I would have gotten a GTS rather than a GTX (I've probably spent less than 10 hours gaming since I bought it, so it really is a waste of money. It's just the comfort of knowing should I ever want to game, I have all that juice available, but it's like buying an R8 to pootle around town).
I'd go Intel because they clearly have the upper hand in the horsepower wars at the moment, and I would have gone with a cheap Intel 775 CPU so that I have the option of jacking it in for one of the killer ones in future. But the thing is though, the prices of Intel chips reflect their standing relative to AMD's offerings, and how much power do we actually need? I find my 5200+ plenty fast for anything that I throw at it!
The X-Fis are excellent sound cards. And the Logitech Z-5500 speaker set (their top-of-the-range model) is quite phenomenal for what you pay for - by far the best computer-specific surround speaker set I've ever heard, which is critical to general enjoyment of all kinds of entertainment.
Edited by -DeaDLocK- on Friday 3rd August 09:34
I am a hardcore gamer though, but am I really going to get the extra benefit from a £390 GTX over a £240 GTS?
The C2D vs Athlon argument is an intresting one, I know trhe C2D's win more benchtests, but the difference in the real world is surely not as clear cut?
A 6000+ vs an E6600 is surely not a walk in the park for the C2D....
plus as I said above the 6000+ is now £105 vs £135 for the C2D, so price does come into it as well, obviously a marginal bit on the money I'm looking at spending but.....
Anyone?
Have I just poked a bees nest?
The C2D vs Athlon argument is an intresting one, I know trhe C2D's win more benchtests, but the difference in the real world is surely not as clear cut?
A 6000+ vs an E6600 is surely not a walk in the park for the C2D....
plus as I said above the 6000+ is now £105 vs £135 for the C2D, so price does come into it as well, obviously a marginal bit on the money I'm looking at spending but.....
Anyone?

Have I just poked a bees nest?

Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


