Help! new computer time
Author
Discussion

Jaguar steve

Original Poster:

9,232 posts

241 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
JS Towers needs a new computer. Me and Mrs JS know censored all about them and have wasted loads of cash on unreliable gear packed with loads of stuff we don't understand or need in the past.

All we need is Broadband internet access, a bit of word processing, and ability to copy CDs and manage digital photos.

It's got to be simple. No, its got to be idiot proof really, and reliable. I can't be arsed with complex programmes or spending hours trying to understand and load software, or even get the bloody printer to work, so ideally it will come ready to plug in and go, and have a excellent back up just in case the numpty in me takes over. Again.

Any suggestions where to start?
confused

nickjm

361 posts

261 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
Jaguar steve said:
All we need is Broadband internet access
PC with a wired/wireless network card in....(just in case you get a networked router rather than a USB BroadBand modem.)

Jaguar steve said:
a bit of word processing
Any PC will do that these days

Jaguar steve said:
and ability to copy CDs and manage digital photos.
Decent sized hard disk required, probably 120GB upwards to be on the safe side, it's not exactly expensive these days anyway.

ETA: Apart from that you can't really get a slow PC these days. If you're looking for reliability I'm sure some people on here have views on that, personally I choose HP for my company, but they might not be suited for home use.

Edited by nickjm on Tuesday 31st July 17:17

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
nickjm said:
ETA: Apart from that you can't really get a slow PC these days. If you're looking for reliability I'm sure some people on here have views on that, personally I choose HP for my company, but they might not be suited for home use.
^^^^^^ yes Wot he said ^^^^^^

Even a cheap n' nasty Dell £399 jobbie will be blisteringly quick. Drive space should start around the 100Gb mark and keeps climbing up to 750Gb (per drive) on a desktop, laptops max out around the 120Gb mark for the time being.

Reliability is going to be the thing here. A percentage of HP's, Dell's, IBM's, Apple's will fail that's a given; the more you sell the more voices screaming but in all honesty I'd say percentage wise Dell are no worse than the others. When it does fail, the amount of cash you spent will depend on if you talk to 'Bob' in Bangalore or Aaron in Ireland; keep that in mind when mulling over companies business class warranties and their business class prices.

That being said, you're after a computer that's simple to use and doesn't come with mountains of 'value add' crap all over it? That'll talk to your camera and with a few simple questions 'just work' and manage the photos? Good support (for the most part)? Built in wifi & ethernet for bolting to your broadband modem/router?

Apple. Go get yourself an iMac, if in doubt figure out where your nearest Apple store is and go play. Costs more, kinda, but the support and software it'll be preloaded with is astoundingly simple to use.

driverrob

4,847 posts

234 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Even a cheap n' nasty Dell £399 jobbie will be blisteringly quick. Drive space should start around the 100Gb mark and keeps climbing up to 750Gb (per drive) on a desktop, laptops max out around the 120Gb mark for the time being.

Reliability is going to be the thing here. A percentage of HP's, Dell's, IBM's, Apple's will fail that's a given; the more you sell the more voices screaming but in all honesty I'd say percentage wise Dell are no worse than the others.
I'm on my second Dell desktop PC. When it became uneconomic to upgrade the first one I just replaced the system unit. The rest of it kept going for years.
My current one developed a fault with the DVD drive. I was sure it was dead. They took me through some checks online and agreed with me. I took it out. Next day a guy arrives with my new drive and takes away the old one. I know some owners have had bad experiences with Dell - they're well publicised - but I bet most owners are as satisfied as I am.
As an IT manager, my wife purchased about 100 PCs a year; always Dell.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
Get a Mac. Seriously.

In terms of reliability the Macbook Pros seem to be the worst (for Apple, who traditionally were one of the best in terms of quality). If you're after a desktop computer then get yourself an iMac and be done with it.

cjs

11,723 posts

282 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
A Mac, or if you want to stick with a PC, a Dell, I have had both and neither has let me down.

sparkythecat

8,111 posts

286 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
I got a Medion PC from Aldi a couple of years ago. It's been faultless.
There's a similar PC on offer there from Thursday of this week which looks good value.
Check it out http://www.aldi-stores.co.uk/

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
cyberface said:
Get a Mac. Seriously.
Just thought I'd reply to this again, having read your original post again.

Everything on your list shouts Mac as loud as possible but there's one question I have for you - Word Processing requirement...

If you need Microsoft Word because you want absolute compatibility with documents being sent from work, or you need to edit work documents and not have any aggro when you send them back, then you'll have to buy the Mac version of MS Office. The full Pro version is expensive but everyone else buys the student/teacher version at around £149.

Alternatively there are easy-to-install packaged versions of NeoOffice (free software replacement, can work with MS Word files) for the Mac.

Any cheap Windows PC won't have full MS Office as it's one of their most profitable products, so unless you are willing to pirate it, you'll have the same issue with Windows.

For everything else, most store-bought PCs will come with a load of random software that you don't need, and you WILL need anti-virus / firewall / etc. software for Windows or you'll get screwed very quickly.

The Mac wins in all these other situations unless you've already paid big money for Windows licenses of software packages you absolutely need. I'd still recommend a Mac and tell you to run the essential Windows software in a virtual machine but it doesn't sound like you're that advanced.

If your word processing requirements don't depend on other people's documents, then go with a Mac and NeoOffice (or buy MS Office if you aren't that price sensitive).