Client/Server Antivirus?
Author
Discussion

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,630 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Trend seem to have had a few goofs lately.

Whilst I don't want to do a knee-jerk, I'd like to get pricing on alternatives so I can look at budgeting for a change next year should there be any further issues.

Sophos always seem to come highly recommended?

Who else are people using that they're happy with?

I'm afraid because of past experiences I'm horribly biased against anything McAfee/NAI or CA.

We have around 400-500 PC's (depending what is active at any given time as some stay off for long periods) and around 20 Windows based File Servers.

Main requirements would be:

Central management of clients.
Roaming clients to update from manufacturer when away from our site.
The usual small/unobtrusive/reliable stuff.
Common sense things like "don't scan network drives".

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
AVG do a good client/server one... Not scaled it up that far but it has all the features you're looking for.

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,630 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Tbh I haven't really investigated AVG - I guess I still think of them as the "free home antivirus" people.

One thing I am quite keen on is decent support, the issues we've had with Trend has highlighted how useful it might be to be able to pick up the phone and talk to knowledgeable people in the UK.

bholleran

361 posts

244 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
I havent done so for a while, but we used Sophos and it worked like a treat

David Godfrey

3,857 posts

255 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
I'm afraid because of past experiences I'm horribly biased against anything McAfee/NAI or CA.
hm, would have said nai/mcafee, been using here for ever the management products for it depend on client count really but either EPO or protection pilot, both work and mcafee have a fairly comprehensive protection suite. exchange, servers, workstations, pocketpc's etc.

I'm have been looking at using MS's own Forefront client security products recently, the exchange protection is fantastic and something I was looking forward to (multi engine scanning). It is lacking one overall management product at the moment but that is being addressed. If your environment uses wsus do deploy updates to clients then your already part the way there, fcs uses wsus to deploy updates and the installers (client and management agent).

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,630 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
We're a bit of an oddity regards user/computer count.

Around 450 headcount, approx the same PC's in use but out of a pool of around 600 (last time I checked with the Help Desk) physical PC's on site.

Many PC's are Rig/Control PC's and as such can be switched off for several weeks at a time.

Naturally I'd prefer licensing to be based on "bums on seats".

I'll have another look at NAI/CA but once bitten etc.

I'd be interested to know how people have got on with NOD/Kaspersky in the enterprise as they always seemed to have an excellent reputation on the standalone side of things.

One thing I do like about Trend is the real-time nature of their software i.e. change a setting and it's rolled out the the client there and then.

For Exchange we currently use Scanmail and that has been near faultless in the six or so years we have used it, so of course we could stick with that but would undoubtedly end up paying more than moving to a "one stop shop" vendor.

As I said I'm not determined to move from Trend, just the latest issues(s) have made me think it pays to know what's out there.

David Godfrey

3,857 posts

255 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
We're a bit of an oddity regards user/computer count.

Around 450 headcount, approx the same PC's in use but out of a pool of around 600 (last time I checked with the Help Desk) physical PC's on site.

Many PC's are Rig/Control PC's and as such can be switched off for several weeks at a time.

Naturally I'd prefer licensing to be based on "bums on seats".

I'll have another look at NAI/CA but once bitten etc.

I'd be interested to know how people have got on with NOD/Kaspersky in the enterprise as they always seemed to have an excellent reputation on the standalone side of things.

One thing I do like about Trend is the real-time nature of their software i.e. change a setting and it's rolled out the the client there and then.

For Exchange we currently use Scanmail and that has been near faultless in the six or so years we have used it, so of course we could stick with that but would undoubtedly end up paying more than moving to a "one stop shop" vendor.

As I said I'm not determined to move from Trend, just the latest issues(s) have made me think it pays to know what's out there.
Would like to know how you got bitten, PM me if you can share rather than post it here.

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
I've always got on well with Sophos. I can't say I'm a big fan of McAfee - the ePO is very clunky.

A current client are rolling out Kapersky. It has the usual deployment tools to do hands-off installation to workstations and seems to work OK. No real problems to report.

SneakyNeil

9,297 posts

268 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
+1 for Sophos, very good central management, supports all manner of OS's, different policies for different groups of machines, push installs, reporting all the usual stuff etc. etc. etc.

If you talk to them they often have automated removal tools for some other products as well to make the transition easier.

roadsweeper

3,790 posts

305 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
A vote for Kaspersky here. Simple installation, powerful anti-virus. We're now a Kaspersky partner but exclusively ran Trend Micro PC-cillin until about a year ago when it went from being a great piece of software to, sadly, bloatware.

If you want pricing information please feel free to email me through my profile or through www.cantarus.com.

LordGrover

34,191 posts

243 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
We're not on the same scale, but use a belt and braces approach which has not let me down yet.
Netpilots running sophos on the gateways and nav corprate (yes ... I know rolleyes) on the servers & clients. TBH, I can't remember the last time anything got as far as nav corporate though - sophos is doing a great job.

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,630 posts

241 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
Is anyone using NOD32?

SneakyNeil

9,297 posts

268 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
Is anyone using NOD32?
We're resellers for NOD32 so yes! We tend to use NOD on odd 'loose' machines in smaller places, bigger places we use Sophos as we're sophos partners too. Home machines get AVG free.

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,630 posts

241 months

Tuesday 7th August 2007
quotequote all
Anyone got any direct experience of Kaspersky vs. NOD32 then?

So far from the trialling I'm doing and the general feedback I'm getting from forums/reviews etc. it seems it's between these two if we do make the jump from Trend.

Xenocide

4,286 posts

239 months

Wednesday 8th August 2007
quotequote all
Didn't both with Kapersky but I trialled NOD32 and found it to be excellent both server + client side. I did find the Reporting on the server really quite lacking though which means that we couldn't provide all the informaiton needed for our audits. As such we went for Symantec AV.

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,630 posts

241 months

Wednesday 8th August 2007
quotequote all
Xenocide said:
Didn't both with Kapersky but I trialled NOD32 and found it to be excellent both server + client side. I did find the Reporting on the server really quite lacking though which means that we couldn't provide all the informaiton needed for our audits. As such we went for Symantec AV.
Yes so far I really like NOD32 for its footprint and seeming lack of overhead.

The problem is that I'm finding it very difficult to actually test its virus/spyware detection rates because in true sods law style it's bloody difficult to get at dodgy stuff when you want to actually find some.

SneakyNeil

9,297 posts

268 months

Wednesday 8th August 2007
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
Xenocide said:
Didn't both with Kapersky but I trialled NOD32 and found it to be excellent both server + client side. I did find the Reporting on the server really quite lacking though which means that we couldn't provide all the informaiton needed for our audits. As such we went for Symantec AV.
Yes so far I really like NOD32 for its footprint and seeming lack of overhead.

The problem is that I'm finding it very difficult to actually test its virus/spyware detection rates because in true sods law style it's bloody difficult to get at dodgy stuff when you want to actually find some.
Well I'm guessing the EICAR test isn't quite going to cut it hehe

We use NOD to scan infected desktop machines that come in in the first instance, we just take the disk out, stick it in a machine with nod already on it and it does very well vs. AVG - I haven't done any back to backs with Kapersky though unfortunately.

Neil

SneakyNeil

9,297 posts

268 months

Friday 10th August 2007
quotequote all
Apparently Kapersky is quite good -

http://www.darkreading.com/document.asp?doc_id=131...


roadsweeper

3,790 posts

305 months

Friday 10th August 2007
quotequote all
SneakyNeil said:
Apparently Kapersky is quite good -

http://www.darkreading.com/document.asp?doc_id=131...
What a great way to test anti-virus software. I was reading an article recently which was questioning the impartiality of the varios anti-virus review sites and also questioning the veracity and reliability of the setups they were using to perform the tests.

ClamAV sounds very interesting. We have some Linux kit here and I'm going to be taking that product for a test drive. smile

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,630 posts

241 months

Friday 10th August 2007
quotequote all
roadsweeper said:
ClamAV sounds very interesting. We have some Linux kit here and I'm going to be taking that product for a test drive. smile
ClamAV is a very nice bit of software. I run it on our mail gateway and virtually nothing makes it so far as the Exchange server.

It's almost to the point where I don't have Antivirus on Exchange to stop incoming viruses, it's simply to cover my back for the "what if" scenario where something gets infected on the LAN and tries to spew.