Windows Vista
Author
Discussion

M-Sport

Original Poster:

541 posts

242 months

Thursday 16th August 2007
quotequote all
Yes I know this would be more appropriate in the computing section but P&P gives a quicker reply ...

Ordered a laptop from Dell with vista and have thouht about the new system. Its home premium we're getting so is there anywhere I can download virus free custom themes rather than the standared ones ?
Also is there any 'must do's' with vista ?

Cheers Folks

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Thursday 16th August 2007
quotequote all
You might get better responses to this question if it's in the Computers And Stuff forum.

I bet one of those nice moderators will shuffle it over there, quick as knife.

The first "must do" is get rid of any bundled antivirus (because it'll be McAfee or Norton, both of which are shite) and get some good stuff on instead. NOD32 seems to be the flavour of the month.

Edited by CommanderJameson on Thursday 16th August 18:30

Kinky

39,947 posts

300 months

Thursday 16th August 2007
quotequote all
Moved to computers forum wink

I'm watching with interest, as I've got to install Vista ultimate onto my laptop next week ..... taking the advice on a thread I started here about 2 weeks ago.

K

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Thursday 16th August 2007
quotequote all

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Thursday 16th August 2007
quotequote all
SS HSV said:
I have noticed that when running custom themes with Dreamscene active, it is not uncommon for Vista to use 900meg just running the desktop without any apps eek
Yes tis a bit hungry for ram. But I think it handles the stuff a bit differently to XP. It pre-loads just about everything you might do into RAM, and then pushes stuff out. Rather than just cacheing what it's seen recently. So things look worse than they are I think.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Thursday 16th August 2007
quotequote all
Ram usage in Vista is always high, if nothing else is using it then I WANT my OS to be caching stuff.

Real world usage IS higher than XP tho by 200-300meg. But it does do a whole lot more too.

Personaly I like it.

dave_s13

14,032 posts

300 months

Thursday 16th August 2007
quotequote all
It's taken me over a week to get my new HTPC running just so with Vista ultimate, but it's been woeth it.

It's really good, once you've got it going right.

I'm sat here typing on a 42" Plasma whilst got 18 odd HD movies, Planet EArth in HD and the entire My name is Earl and all the Heroes to sit and watch...magic.

Rednut05

9,173 posts

244 months

Thursday 16th August 2007
quotequote all
I'm running Vista Ultimate x64. Think of the trouble I'm having!



Not very much actually smile

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
dave_s13 said:
It's taken me over a week to get my new HTPC running just so with Vista ultimate, but it's been woeth it.

It's really good, once you've got it going right.

I'm sat here typing on a 42" Plasma whilst got 18 odd HD movies, Planet EArth in HD and the entire My name is Earl and all the Heroes to sit and watch...magic.
Woohoo! I also bought Planet Earth on bluray last week, well worth it. Out of interest what does it stream at on HDDVD? I am getting about 17mbit/sec compared to 5mbit/second for normal DVD?

Any other movies which look excellent that you can recommend? I would say 5th Element (the latest remaster not the first one) looks fantastic 10 out of 10.

Rednut05 said:
I'm running Vista Ultimate x64. Think of the trouble I'm having!

Not very much actually smile
Hopefully x64 Vista was better than x64 XP which I have two licensed copies for and was unable to get working properly due to driver issues.

Vista could really benefit from 8gig+ of ram smile

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
SS HSV said:
I have noticed that when running custom themes with Dreamscene active, it is not uncommon for Vista to use 900meg just running the desktop without any apps eek
Was in Novatech the other day and spotted one of their Media centre machines (flat panel, bits at the back, use me as your telly thing) running Vista and what appeared to be a GIF as the wall paper (it wasn't an mpeg from the looks of it).

32% CPU useage, 1GB RAM in use.

This was on a Core 2 Duo running at (I think) 1.8Ghz, no other apps open.
My laptop, Core 2 Duo 2.0Ghz, Linux+Beryl and a neat utility to throw a video up on to my desktop chroma'd to be the wallpaper... 5% CPU usage, 200MB RAM used excluding buffers; in fact in day to day non-Virtual machines a go go mode, breaking the 1GB 'barrier' is something of a rarity.

WTF is Vista doing? I'm not bashing it, it looks eXtra eXtra Pretty and quite slick but that's an insane amount of RAM to be using just to show the desktop and 32% CPU usage for a low quality gif/mpeg playing? I thought it was supposed to be using the 3D accelerator for desktop compositing?

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
SS HSV said:
I have noticed that when running custom themes with Dreamscene active, it is not uncommon for Vista to use 900meg just running the desktop without any apps eek
Was in Novatech the other day and spotted one of their Media centre machines (flat panel, bits at the back, use me as your telly thing) running Vista and what appeared to be a GIF as the wall paper (it wasn't an mpeg from the looks of it).

32% CPU useage, 1GB RAM in use.

This was on a Core 2 Duo running at (I think) 1.8Ghz, no other apps open.
My laptop, Core 2 Duo 2.0Ghz, Linux+Beryl and a neat utility to throw a video up on to my desktop chroma'd to be the wallpaper... 5% CPU usage, 200MB RAM used excluding buffers; in fact in day to day non-Virtual machines a go go mode, breaking the 1GB 'barrier' is something of a rarity.

WTF is Vista doing? I'm not bashing it, it looks eXtra eXtra Pretty and quite slick but that's an insane amount of RAM to be using just to show the desktop and 32% CPU usage for a low quality gif/mpeg playing? I thought it was supposed to be using the 3D accelerator for desktop compositing?
It caches aggressively. OS X does something similar.

It's actually a very good use of memory. "Free memory" is wasted memory.

Can't comment on the CPU usage.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
I thought it was supposed to be using the 3D accelerator for desktop compositing?
I doubt it, because Apple haven't managed to pull that off yet for 2d compositing with alpha blending (was meant to be in Tiger as 'quartz 2d extreme' which sounds silly if you say it - but was too buggy and is slated to be in Leopard).

OK so I'm the apple fanboy but they've been doing compositing on the desktop way longer than MS have (part of the reason why OS X feels so damn slow compared to old versions of Windows) - eye candy tricks like Exposé can fall seriously flat on multi-monitor systems with lame graphics cards since each window has to be turned into an OpenGL texture and then thrown at the 3d GPU to move around... if you've got 100s of windows and not enough graphics RAM, it turns into a slideshow (you've seen my rig, Exposé isn't as smooth as Apple would like...). As a result, this sort of every-window-is-a-texture 3d compositing is kept for eye-candy only and currently not pervasive, since it still requires high-end GPUs with large amounts of onboard VRAM - pulling it over the bus from system RAM still doesn't cut it, as demonstrations with integrated graphics Macbooks can show.

Apple are claiming Leopard will have it sorted, and I haven't heard any Windows fans gloating over Vista's compositing capabilities being better than Apple's so I guess Vista isn't doing full-scale window-to-GPU-texture compositing either, yet.

After all, Vista has to run on the same shoddy hardware that OS X has to put up with - hell, Apple never give you a half-decent graphics card, you can at least configure a PC with something decent (plus the noise, the power draw, the screaming fans, etc.)

There's a lot to be gained by using the GPU for some tasks esp. now programmable shaders etc. are the norm but the system has to be able to fall back for older hardware to a limit, and you've also got the core programming model of how to write to a window (this may be easier than imagined if you just translate 'draw' and 'blit' commands to opengl / direct3d equivalents - but Apple tried this and it was too buggy).

As to Vista's memory usage whilst doing nothing... you'll probably find that it's either aggressively caching everything it can or it's keeping a bitmap copy of each open window in memory, so regardless of whether an app locks up, you can't do the WinXP and previous etch-a-sketch across the now unresponsive window. That alone counts for some of the silly memory usage in OS X... I'd expect Vista to be as advanced if not more in that area, MS have some top engineers.

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
This was on a Core 2 Duo running at (I think) 1.8Ghz, no other apps open.
My laptop, Core 2 Duo 2.0Ghz, Linux+Beryl and a neat utility to throw a video up on to my desktop chroma'd to be the wallpaper... 5% CPU usage, 200MB RAM used excluding buffers; in fact in day to day non-Virtual machines a go go mode, breaking the 1GB 'barrier' is something of a rarity.
What plugin do you use for video desktop? I've looked and can't seem to find anything for Beryl.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
CommanderJameson said:
It's actually a very good use of memory. "Free memory" is wasted memory.
Can't comment on the CPU usage.
I'm making an assumption that the widget, much like the Gnome system monitor only shows memory used in userland, 1GB of userspace RAM to draw the desktop and composite in an mpeg/anigif is WAY to much IMHO. Conversely, I'm sat with FF and 20 tabs open (along with Thunderbird) tinkering and I'm at 277MB in userland (yay! FF is leaking... again... bleh, I'm sure it's a plugin).

True when I run top or poke at the SysMon to show everything the whole 2GB is used (near enough, 1.8GB) most of it, for disk cache/buffers, which is as you say a good use of RAM.

The CPU usage, to me, suggests it's doing a lot of software work to composite, rather than just throwing the whole lot at the 3D accelerator and saying 'do it', which is a little odd, as the thing did have a puka 3D unit, not a ram stealer IGP.

Tycho said:
ThePassenger said:
This was on a Core 2 Duo running at (I think) 1.8Ghz, no other apps open.
My laptop, Core 2 Duo 2.0Ghz, Linux+Beryl and a neat utility to throw a video up on to my desktop chroma'd to be the wallpaper... 5% CPU usage, 200MB RAM used excluding buffers; in fact in day to day non-Virtual machines a go go mode, breaking the 1GB 'barrier' is something of a rarity.
What plugin do you use for video desktop? I've looked and can't seem to find anything for Beryl.
Xwinwrap and a GUI I found in the Ubuntu forums. It's not a Beryl plugin per say, but a 3rd party app that makes use of the beryl/CompViz compositing engine. Still being tweaked and beaten with a hammer smile

Edited by ThePassenger on Friday 17th August 07:57

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
M-Sport said:
Yes I know this would be more appropriate in the computing section but P&P gives a quicker reply ...

Ordered a laptop from Dell with vista and have thouht about the new system. Its home premium we're getting so is there anywhere I can download virus free custom themes rather than the standared ones ?
Also is there any 'must do's' with vista ?

Cheers Folks
I forgot. Go here:

http://autopatcher.com

That'll take the pain out of all those patches. Also installs handy 3rd-party bits.

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
CommanderJameson said:
It's actually a very good use of memory. "Free memory" is wasted memory.
Can't comment on the CPU usage.
I'm making an assumption that the widget, much like the Gnome system monitor only shows memory used in userland,
Wrong assumption.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
CommanderJameson said:
ThePassenger said:
CommanderJameson said:
It's actually a very good use of memory. "Free memory" is wasted memory.
Can't comment on the CPU usage.
I'm making an assumption that the widget, much like the Gnome system monitor only shows memory used in userland,
Wrong assumption.
Then a machine with 2GB should be showing near enough 100% RAM usage, assuming it's going flat out to use non-allocated RAM for cache. It wasn't. So just what is it showing? System+Userland? Userland only? System only?

If it is showing all, then either Vista isn't as ruthless about cache as Microsoft have made out or the Widget lies... possibly a combination as you're average punter seeing 100% RAM used will go nuts.

Edited by ThePassenger on Friday 17th August 08:13

wolves_wanderer

12,960 posts

268 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
SS HSV said:
Hopefully x64 Vista was better than x64 XP which I have two licensed copies for and was unable to get working properly due to driver issues.

Vista could really benefit from 8gig+ of ram smile
It is yes

Got Vista Ultimate x64 running on my new machine and it is fantastic. All drivers were picked up automatically during the installation. I have 4gb RAM but it is not significantly better than 2gb just for normal use.

dave_s13

14,032 posts

300 months

Friday 17th August 2007
quotequote all
dave_s13 said:
It's taken me over a week to get my new HTPC running just so with Vista ultimate, but it's been woeth it.

It's really good, once you've got it going right.

I'm sat here typing on a 42" Plasma whilst got 18 odd HD movies, Planet EArth in HD and the entire My name is Earl and all the Heroes to sit and watch...magic.
ss_hsv said:
Woohoo! I also bought Planet Earth on bluray last week, well worth it. Out of interest what does it stream at on HDDVD? I am getting about 17mbit/sec compared to 5mbit/second for normal DVD?.

Any other movies which look excellent that you can recommend? I would say 5th Element (the latest remaster not the first one) looks fantastic 10 out of 10.
Don't know about the bitrate m8. All my stuff is downloaded ( a bit naughty I know) Blu-Ray rips I think?

I will be getting a blu-ray drive in a few months though.

Watched Perfume Story of a murderer last night and that looked nice, good film too.

Planet earth is ace though, especially the jungle one, those birds on the pull look amazing.

And my machine "only" has 2 gig of RAM and it works flawlessly with an Abit AN-M2HD main board and an athlon 5000+ cpu. Mainboard has HDMI and optical out and works very well indeed. I get full 720p/1080i and AC3/DTS.


Edited by dave_s13 on Friday 17th August 08:59