Software Inventory Packages?
Author
Discussion

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,647 posts

241 months

Sunday 2nd May 2010
quotequote all
Does anyone have any experience with any packages that will audit PC's for all installed software?

I've been trialling a few products and many have the limitation that they only really give you a list of what's in the Add/Remove Programs list when we want something that will log all executable and give us a list of what's recognized and what isn't.

I think the key thing is something that has some kind of database that is updates by the vendor rather than simply relying on the executable containing vendor/version info.

I'm aware of things such as Centennial and LanDesk but they're a bit pricey for several hundred machines.

Thanks.

darkmark07

702 posts

229 months

Sunday 2nd May 2010
quotequote all
We use a package called Empirum by a German company called Matrix42, I think.

We're not using the Inventory side at the moment, but I think it will do what you need.

It's also great a bare-metal installs & software installation...

duff-man

634 posts

237 months

Sunday 2nd May 2010
quotequote all
So you are wanting to pick up any EXE's running on machines which may not be installed such as portable applications etc..?

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,647 posts

241 months

Sunday 2nd May 2010
quotequote all
duff-man said:
So you are wanting to pick up any EXE's running on machines which may not be installed such as portable applications etc..?
Yes. Think of things such as Putty that are just an exe, it's not listed as being installed anywhere, but it's software, it has a license agreement, so we want/need to know who's using it.

GnuBee

1,339 posts

246 months

Sunday 2nd May 2010
quotequote all
How many machines? Is this a one shot audit or an ongoing requirement? Do you only want software inventory or do you need hardware as well?


paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,647 posts

241 months

Sunday 2nd May 2010
quotequote all
GnuBee said:
How many machines? Is this a one shot audit or an ongoing requirement? Do you only want software inventory or do you need hardware as well?
Most of the apps I've seen cover hardware anyway, though it's not as much of a requirement as software.

The need is ongoing, we currently use something called VisualAudit X4 but they went into liquidation, so whilst it still works there are no recognition updates being released.

rdhawkins

322 posts

314 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
We develop a product called NetSupport DNA that would do what you want, it will do a software (and hardware) inventory of PC's based on certain rules (not just the Add/Remove program list though you can view that too). Everything is stored in a database for reporting/querying. If used in collaboration with our Application Metering module new programs that are run are picked up and added to the inventory automatically.

NetSupport DNA

Rob

rednotdead

1,259 posts

257 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
we had great success with Sassafras KeyAuditor http://www.sassafras.com/. Audit tool and software licensing control, don't know whether it will be overkill for what you need though...

LordGrover

34,191 posts

243 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
Spiceworks will probably do what you need, and maybe a bit more: click.

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,647 posts

241 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
rdhawkins said:
We develop a product called NetSupport DNA that would do what you want, it will do a software (and hardware) inventory of PC's based on certain rules (not just the Add/Remove program list though you can view that too). Everything is stored in a database for reporting/querying. If used in collaboration with our Application Metering module new programs that are run are picked up and added to the inventory automatically.

NetSupport DNA

Rob
Thanks Rob, just taken a brief look at the website. So to save messing about with a demo if it won't do it, let's say someone has putty.exe on their desktop - will it identify it or will I just get some huge list of .exe's with that one buried somewhere on it?

We've found in our environment that the Add/Remove Programs list isn't always accurate as we have a lot of custom software, now fair enough we may have to teach a system about that, but different systems let you do it more or less painfully than others.

Ballpark pricing would be good too - feel free to PM me.

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,647 posts

241 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
Spiceworks will probably do what you need, and maybe a bit more: click.
I tried that and uninstalled it after about 10 minutes. Seemed thoroughly ad-laden and hateful quite frankly.

Shame as lots of people rave about it so maybe I was being a bit impatient but first impressions were poor.

LordGrover

34,191 posts

243 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
paddyhasneeds said:
LordGrover said:
Spiceworks will probably do what you need, and maybe a bit more: click.
I tried that and uninstalled it after about 10 minutes. Seemed thoroughly ad-laden and hateful quite frankly.

Shame as lots of people rave about it so maybe I was being a bit impatient but first impressions were poor.
Understandable. I use an adblocker as a matter of course so don't get them. It's quite comprehensive and for free it's pretty good. I'm sure there are better products out there though.

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

295 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
paddyhasneeds said:
LordGrover said:
Spiceworks will probably do what you need, and maybe a bit more: click.
I tried that and uninstalled it after about 10 minutes. Seemed thoroughly ad-laden and hateful quite frankly.

Shame as lots of people rave about it so maybe I was being a bit impatient but first impressions were poor.
Understandable. I use an adblocker as a matter of course so don't get them. It's quite comprehensive and for free it's pretty good. I'm sure there are better products out there though.
yes

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,647 posts

241 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
paddyhasneeds said:
LordGrover said:
Spiceworks will probably do what you need, and maybe a bit more: click.
I tried that and uninstalled it after about 10 minutes. Seemed thoroughly ad-laden and hateful quite frankly.

Shame as lots of people rave about it so maybe I was being a bit impatient but first impressions were poor.
Understandable. I use an adblocker as a matter of course so don't get them. It's quite comprehensive and for free it's pretty good. I'm sure there are better products out there though.
Free isn't a necessity, though of course there are a multitude of products in between free and Landesk/Centennial.

The way I see it having a good database that will recognize software by looking at the file rather than the Add/Remove list costs money, of course we have other things such as Help Desk and Patch Management (non- WSUS stuff) that we're not desperate to replace or add but if a suite works out an economical way of doing so it's an option.

lestag

4,614 posts

307 months

Thursday 6th May 2010
quotequote all

XJSJohn

16,152 posts

250 months

Thursday 6th May 2010
quotequote all
As long as you have a good and clear understanding of your physical estate then tideway might fit the bill

LordGrover

34,191 posts

243 months

Thursday 6th May 2010
quotequote all
XJSJohn said:
As long as you have a good and clear understanding of your physical estate then tideway might fit the bill
Had a quick shufty at their site, but disappointed to note no prices published - application only. irked Really annoys me that does.

Sushi

858 posts

231 months

Thursday 6th May 2010
quotequote all
Config Manager 2007 will do the job, you can configure it to detect certain file types so specifying .exe would show all .exe files on a machine. I use it to find mp3s and avis on users machines.
It may be a bit overkill though as it's a fairly hefty bit of software and inventory is only one tiny part of what it does.

XJSJohn

16,152 posts

250 months

Thursday 6th May 2010
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
XJSJohn said:
As long as you have a good and clear understanding of your physical estate then tideway might fit the bill
Had a quick shufty at their site, but disappointed to note no prices published - application only. irked Really annoys me that does.
BMC for ya wink

rdhawkins

322 posts

314 months

Thursday 6th May 2010
quotequote all
paddyhasneeds said:
rdhawkins said:
We develop a product called NetSupport DNA that would do what you want, it will do a software (and hardware) inventory of PC's based on certain rules (not just the Add/Remove program list though you can view that too). Everything is stored in a database for reporting/querying. If used in collaboration with our Application Metering module new programs that are run are picked up and added to the inventory automatically.

NetSupport DNA

Rob
Thanks Rob, just taken a brief look at the website. So to save messing about with a demo if it won't do it, let's say someone has putty.exe on their desktop - will it identify it or will I just get some huge list of .exe's with that one buried somewhere on it?

We've found in our environment that the Add/Remove Programs list isn't always accurate as we have a lot of custom software, now fair enough we may have to teach a system about that, but different systems let you do it more or less painfully than others.

Ballpark pricing would be good too - feel free to PM me.
DNA uses a number of techniques to produce an inventory of software on a PC, the default mode is to do an intelligent scan of the PC and extract product information. It can be configured to scan folders for executables but as you say that can often return too much information.

So in your example yes it would defiantly pick up an application which was just copied to the desktop, if it was copied to a more obscure folder then we would also pick it up as soon as the user executed it.

Detecting applications is one thing though, often organisations want to inventory packages. For example you may have several versions of Internet Explorer installed across your PC's. You would want to treat these different versions as a single 'package' for inventory purposes. DNA allows you to do this by grouping applications together.

Pricing is dependant on how many PC's you want to use it on so its hard to say, ballpark for a 100 user edition is £2000 which includes maintenance (free upgrades). We have an evaluation version that can be installed on 50 PC's and runs for 30 days. It's is very quick and easy to get going which is something we pride ourselves on - install on a spare PC (it will install MSDE or point you to SQL Express if you don't have a database), deploy out the client to your desktops and that's it. You should start to see results immediately.

Rob