What phone ?
Author
Discussion

Gadgeroonie

Original Poster:

5,362 posts

265 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
I am in the market for a new mobile phone and am considering a contract

there are so many deals out there it is almost impossible to choose

I thought i would ask what you have and if its a good deal

so which provider do i use ?
which phone do i choose ?

thanks in advance

Greenwich Ross

1,219 posts

202 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
If you love endlessly fiddling with gadgets whilst your mates look on despairingly then it absolutely has to be the iPhone rolleyes

edo

16,699 posts

294 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
Either an iPhone, or something running Android.

yazza54

20,329 posts

210 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
iPhone4

Always avoided iPhones mainly because of the poor camera and lack of flash. Plus every touch screen I've ever used has proved me to be too ham fisted. However the 4 is so easy to use, so fast, hours of fun, brilliant battery life, fantastic screen. I was very impressed and still am. Only thing is you pay for what you get so it isn't the cheapest.

It was a toss up between that and a HTC, was advised not to get a HTC from the I.T bloke at work who has both. iPhone 4 is better hands down - His knowledgeable words, not mine.

Edited by yazza54 on Wednesday 18th August 10:31

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

226 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
yazza54 said:
Was advised not to get a HTC from the I.T bloke at work who has both. iPhone 4 is better hands down - His knowledgeable words, not mine.
An IT literate friend of mine has both and has said the HTC is the better phone - it boils down to use, battery life, requirements and testing.

Me. I've got a Palm Pre smile

LordGrover

34,164 posts

241 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
Provider and contract will very much depend on your usage. How many minutes, any texts, interweb?
If you're not in a major city provider may well be determined by coverage - Orange is a no-goer at home for me.

yazza54

20,329 posts

210 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
james_tigerwoods said:
yazza54 said:
Was advised not to get a HTC from the I.T bloke at work who has both. iPhone 4 is better hands down - His knowledgeable words, not mine.
An IT literate friend of mine has both and has said the HTC is the better phone - it boils down to use, battery life, requirements and testing.

Me. I've got a Palm Pre smile
Mmn the main thing our techie didn't like about the HTC was battery life, and that when it did drop it took longer to actually re-charge too.

I've since had a go one 2 different HTCs that are works phones in my office, not sure which exact model but I don't find myself longing for one.

All the directors in my office are on iPhones, people further down the hierarchy are on HTC wink

I bought mine myself haha.

Gadgeroonie

Original Poster:

5,362 posts

265 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
what is an HTC and what is android ?

cheers for the replys

yazza54

20,329 posts

210 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
Gadgeroonie said:
what is an HTC and what is android ?
Exactly



Get an iPhone tongue out



Edited by yazza54 on Wednesday 18th August 10:48

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

226 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
What it boils down to is what you want to use it for, what contract term you what, where you are and whether you can try phones out.

My mate can afford to buy both on PAYG and spend time pissing about with them - most can't do this - but it's the only way to test these things properly.

Me, I like the iPhone 4 as it's clear and looks smart, but it's a real fashion item and it is, to be honest, a big phone. The Palm Pre fits in my pocket nicely whereas the iPhone is a little bulky.

On the other hand, I have an HTC TYTN II for work (http://www.htc.com/www/product/tytnii/overview.html) and it is, without a shadow of doubt, the biggest shower of st I've ever had the misfortune to use. iPhones are not available as they don't work with our Exchange environment properly - they're not secure enough.

ETA - My Palm Pre has the same sort of battery life as an iPhone and I have a rather nifty Touchstone base that I can sit the phone on and it charges - I've not had to plug it in to a charger for ages.

I'm on O2 and my signal is ok - Orange is, where I live, laughable (which makes using the work phone entertaining at best).

Edited by james_tigerwoods on Wednesday 18th August 10:51

yazza54

20,329 posts

210 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
Oh and I've always used o2, been faultless.

I wouldn't touch T-mobile, just, well, because it's T-mobile. Though I'm up north, I hear they're more popular in the south.

Also wouldn't touch Orange simply because many colleagues have had issues with loss of signal and bad cooperation from customer service, and that's on a high value business contract!!

pikey

7,704 posts

313 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
You do realise HTC make various different types of phone? It's like saying "An Astra 1.6 GL is better than a Ford". A Ford *what*?

HTC's best offering is the 'Desire'. As for comparing it to the iPhone 4, yes it's excellent and is directly comparable.

Is it better for you? Who knows, that depends on the owner and what he/she likes.

I've had both, prefer the HTC Desire. So does the missus who's changed to one.


PS. Battery life is only ste if you turn so much on it could land a space shuttle. Battery life goes between 8 hours and 3 days dependent on what you do with it.

pikey

7,704 posts

313 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
yazza54 said:
Oh and I've always used o2, been faultless.
Just to balance that out, been on O2 for 3 years and live/work in London. The network has good days and bad days. Earlier this year it had about a month of bad days.

Generally it's ok, but I would be a long way from calling it faultless.

cmackay81

9,251 posts

195 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
yazza54 said:
iPhone4

Always avoided iPhones mainly because of the poor camera and lack of flash. Plus every touch screen I've ever used has proved me to be too ham fisted. However the 4 is so easy to use, so fast, hours of fun, brilliant battery life, fantastic screen. I was very impressed and still am. Only thing is you pay for what you get so it isn't the cheapest.

It was a toss up between that and a HTC, was advised not to get a HTC from the I.T bloke at work who has both. iPhone 4 is better hands down - His knowledgeable words, not mine.

Edited by yazza54 on Wednesday 18th August 10:31
battery life on the iphone4 is tragic!

I charge mine up when i'm sleeping and when i'm at work. seems to last about 8 hours with average use. Thing is, the more gadgets it has on it, the more you will use it. No-one buys an iphone to leave in their pocket and not play with.

other than that, it is very cool. (excepting no bluetooth or photo or address book transfer)

cmackay81

9,251 posts

195 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
oh and price wise for an iphone 4, on the network '3' phone was £100 and £30 a month for 24 months.


james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

226 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
cmackay81 said:
iPhone4 - No bluetooth.
Really?

yazza54

20,329 posts

210 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
cmackay81 said:
yazza54 said:
iPhone4

Always avoided iPhones mainly because of the poor camera and lack of flash. Plus every touch screen I've ever used has proved me to be too ham fisted. However the 4 is so easy to use, so fast, hours of fun, brilliant battery life, fantastic screen. I was very impressed and still am. Only thing is you pay for what you get so it isn't the cheapest.

It was a toss up between that and a HTC, was advised not to get a HTC from the I.T bloke at work who has both. iPhone 4 is better hands down - His knowledgeable words, not mine.

Edited by yazza54 on Wednesday 18th August 10:31
battery life on the iphone4 is tragic!

I charge mine up when i'm sleeping and when i'm at work. seems to last about 8 hours with average use. Thing is, the more gadgets it has on it, the more you will use it. No-one buys an iphone to leave in their pocket and not play with.

other than that, it is very cool. (excepting no bluetooth or photo or address book transfer)
What are you on about!!?

I hammer my iPhone and the battery just takes it like a bh.

You must be constantly watching those videos I don't watch on those sites I don't visit. I hear they drain the battery.

I charge it every night just out of habit but don't really need to.


Oh and the HTC doesn't have Anrgy Birds tongue out For those moments when you need something to waste your life on that game is essential.

yazza54

20,329 posts

210 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
pikey said:
yazza54 said:
Oh and I've always used o2, been faultless.
Just to balance that out, been on O2 for 3 years and live/work in London. The network has good days and bad days. Earlier this year it had about a month of bad days.

Generally it's ok, but I would be a long way from calling it faultless.
Exact same problem with Orange in our office, mast was down and they didn't fix it for 3 months!!!!!

Swings and roundabouts but in my personal experience I wouldn't defect from o2.

Fletch79

1,643 posts

226 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
What phone do you have now ... what do you want to be able to do with your phone?

Do you want a 'smartphone'?
Do you mind a touchscreen with no physical keyboard
Camera??
MMS??
Videos??
Memory cards or internal storage?

Is there any point in getting into the iphone V desire argument if he only wants a nokia 3210

Edited by Fletch79 on Wednesday 18th August 11:03

yazza54

20,329 posts

210 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
P.s.. who uses bluetooth nowadays? Really? It's so slow it's not worth the bother for data transfer. If you mean for hands free I'm pretty sure there is a hands free for the iphone.


P.s #2 ... Wouldn't touch 3 mobile with a barge pole either, mate was with them and their way of billing on units caught him out a few times, could say his fault but they don't make it simple. Plus his reception was wk on 3 from what I remember.

Edited by yazza54 on Wednesday 18th August 11:02