iPOD Alternatives?
Discussion
The wife has suggested that an iPod would be a good Christmas present for her...but I have just looked at the price of a decent iPod Touch and it is probably a stretch (unless I can get a contribution from her parents).
Are there any alternatives to the iPod that are reasonable and better priced?
Are there any alternatives to the iPod that are reasonable and better priced?
There are plenty of alternatives - better/worse is very subjective, but make sure you involve your wife in this discussion - if she wants an iPod it's because she wants an iPod, not a generic MP3 player (however good it may be!)
edit; apologies if that sounds a little preachy
edit; apologies if that sounds a little preachy

Edited by TonyHetherington on Thursday 11th November 09:30
TonyHetherington said:
There are plenty of alternatives - better/worse is very subjective, but make sure you involve your wife in this discussion - if she wants an iPod it's because she wants an iPod, not a generic MP3 player (however good it may be!)
edit; apologies if that sounds a little preachy
Know exactly what you are saying Tony. edit; apologies if that sounds a little preachy

Edited by TonyHetherington on Thursday 11th November 09:30
My wife is the sort to assume that the only MP3 player is an iPod.
ewenm said:
Is all the functionality of a iPod Touch required? I like the look of the new Nanos. As said above, if she wants something with the look and feel of an iPod then alternatives are thinner on the ground than if she just wants a MP3 player.
An iPod classic would suffice.Can you get a docking station for a Nano?
The idea is less for portable reasons, more for storing music and using in the house.
You can get a docking station for every iPod (the connections are the same). The new Touch is essentially an iPhone with no phone - so you can do wireless, apps etc. etc. If she doesn't need any of that, a classic is a good choice.
If you're only going ot use it in the house though - do you have a home PC that you could stream music from?
If you're only going ot use it in the house though - do you have a home PC that you could stream music from?
Legend83 said:
ewenm said:
Is all the functionality of a iPod Touch required? I like the look of the new Nanos. As said above, if she wants something with the look and feel of an iPod then alternatives are thinner on the ground than if she just wants a MP3 player.
An iPod classic would suffice.Can you get a docking station for a Nano?
The idea is less for portable reasons, more for storing music and using in the house.
TonyHetherington said:
You can get a docking station for every iPod (the connections are the same). The new Touch is essentially an iPhone with no phone - so you can do wireless, apps etc. etc. If she doesn't need any of that, a classic is a good choice.
If you're only going ot use it in the house though - do you have a home PC that you could stream music from?
I do, we can also use the PS3 in the lounge.If you're only going ot use it in the house though - do you have a home PC that you could stream music from?
The other main reason for an iPod is that she is a teacher (and dance teacher) so uses a lot of music which she ends up burning to hundreds of CDs! A portable storage system would help her with this and avoide spending £££ on CDs each year.
Legend83 said:
TonyHetherington said:
There are plenty of alternatives - better/worse is very subjective, but make sure you involve your wife in this discussion - if she wants an iPod it's because she wants an iPod, not a generic MP3 player (however good it may be!)
edit; apologies if that sounds a little preachy
Know exactly what you are saying Tony. edit; apologies if that sounds a little preachy

Edited by TonyHetherington on Thursday 11th November 09:30
My wife is the sort to assume that the only MP3 player is an iPod.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


