Potential amg future classics
Potential amg future classics
Author
Discussion

msb1973

Original Poster:

14 posts

167 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2020
quotequote all
Obviously as most would know Bmw M cars are shooting up very quickly in value, it seems E46 m3’s as well as e39 m5’s are top favourites currently.
My question is will this take effect on same era Amg’s I’m thinking along the lines of clk55, c55,and e55 models, thoughts on this all opinions welcome👍

MercedesClassic

1,108 posts

119 months

Thursday 23rd January 2020
quotequote all
Hopefully the SL55 as I have one. DIdn't buy it as an investment but if it at least went up gradually to offset the expenditure that would be a welcome bonus.

threesixty

2,068 posts

225 months

Thursday 23rd January 2020
quotequote all
msb1973 said:
Obviously as most would know Bmw M cars are shooting up very quickly in value, it seems E46 m3’s as well as e39 m5’s are top favourites currently.
My question is will this take effect on same era Amg’s I’m thinking along the lines of clk55, c55,and e55 models, thoughts on this all opinions welcome??
Those are recognised as great cars. CLK55 and C55 are pretty awful. E55 might be a better shout.

I think anyone buying an AMG as an investment needs their head checked though.

MickyveloceClassic

477 posts

81 months

Thursday 23rd January 2020
quotequote all
Any interesting car will appreciate gently over time, if it’s looked after.

My C36 cost me £5k thirteen years ago, as its market value is probably higher now. But considering I’ve sunk around £8k in maintenance and restoration costs into the car during my ownership, then it’s no investment.

Anything with ABC, SBC and the like will be significantly more bothersome as the years go by, so buy one if you want one, but not to make money.

msb1973

Original Poster:

14 posts

167 months

Thursday 23rd January 2020
quotequote all
threesixty said:
msb1973 said:
Obviously as most would know Bmw M cars are shooting up very quickly in value, it seems E46 m3’s as well as e39 m5’s are top favourites currently.
My question is will this take effect on same era Amg’s I’m thinking along the lines of clk55, c55,and e55 models, thoughts on this all opinions welcome??
Those are recognised as great cars. CLK55 and C55 are pretty awful. E55 might be a better shout.

I think anyone buying an AMG as an investment needs their head checked though.
Don’t get the awful comment especially with regards to the c55 which is more than arguably the rarest of the three?

threesixty

2,068 posts

225 months

Thursday 23rd January 2020
quotequote all
msb1973 said:
Don’t get the awful comment especially with regards to the c55 which is more than arguably the rarest of the three?
Rare doesn't equal good. Its laughable compared to an E46 M3.

GT3ZZZ

1,007 posts

192 months

Thursday 23rd January 2020
quotequote all
W204 C63 Black

Nath911t

643 posts

219 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
W129 55's?

Blacksquid

57 posts

137 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
The CLK63 black is up there with the best in terms of desirability

amokwa

478 posts

219 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
threesixty said:
Rare doesn't equal good. Its laughable compared to an E46 M3.
You have owned both cars I assume ?

ArmaghMan

2,713 posts

202 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
Not as far as I can see.
Have my absolutely mint 2 owner rust free E55 up at the minute for sensible money.
Nothing doing.

leef44

5,147 posts

175 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
msb1973 said:
threesixty said:
msb1973 said:
Obviously as most would know Bmw M cars are shooting up very quickly in value, it seems E46 m3’s as well as e39 m5’s are top favourites currently.
My question is will this take effect on same era Amg’s I’m thinking along the lines of clk55, c55,and e55 models, thoughts on this all opinions welcome??
Those are recognised as great cars. CLK55 and C55 are pretty awful. E55 might be a better shout.

I think anyone buying an AMG as an investment needs their head checked though.
Don’t get the awful comment especially with regards to the c55 which is more than arguably the rarest of the three?
It's more a case of certain cars become classics and appreciate in value because they are looked back and considered "drivers' cars".

E46 M3 and E39 M5 are two of those.

Other examples are Honda NSX, Integra DC2, Lancia Integrale.

My SLK55 is unlikely to ever reach that category: although it's a fun car with an oversized engine for the size of the car, it does not have the driver focused characteristics of the above.

The SLS AMG is probably the only one that meets those criteria in AMG terms.

Paddymcc

1,233 posts

213 months

Saturday 25th January 2020
quotequote all
ArmaghMan said:
Not as far as I can see.
Have my absolutely mint 2 owner rust free E55 up at the minute for sensible money.
Nothing doing.
Any links to them?

Ari

19,752 posts

237 months

Saturday 25th January 2020
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Did anyone ever buy one? It was about the most pointless car ever. A stripped out GT3 type racer with a slow witted slushmatic autobox as Mercedes didn't have a manual transmission capable of handling the power.

ArmaghMan

2,713 posts

202 months

Saturday 25th January 2020
quotequote all
Paddymcc said:
ArmaghMan said:
Not as far as I can see.
Have my absolutely mint 2 owner rust free E55 up at the minute for sensible money.
Nothing doing.
Any links to them?
Here you go

https://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/...

edc

9,482 posts

273 months

Friday 31st January 2020
quotequote all
threesixty said:
msb1973 said:
Don’t get the awful comment especially with regards to the c55 which is more than arguably the rarest of the three?
Rare doesn't equal good. Its laughable compared to an E46 M3.
I had a C55. Chose it over a later C63 and M3.

I see it more comparable to the Alpina B3S. If you want the pendulum swung towards outright handling get the M3. If more towards comfort and refinement then the AMG.

anonymous-user

76 months

Thursday 6th February 2020
quotequote all
threesixty said:
msb1973 said:
Don’t get the awful comment especially with regards to the c55 which is more than arguably the rarest of the three?
Rare doesn't equal good. Its laughable compared to an E46 M3.
E46 M3 could be had with a manual, its also not a saloon or estate. It didn't come with a V8. The BMW also didn't have very conservative power figures which were understated not to embarrass the rest of the AMG lineup. Hardly 'laughable'.

The M3 is a great car no doubt, but the C55 appealed to a different type of driver and you could argue the two aren't really rivals. Obviously the later ones were.

ArmaghMan

2,713 posts

202 months

Friday 7th February 2020
quotequote all
Oppo said:
threesixty said:
msb1973 said:
Don’t get the awful comment especially with regards to the c55 which is more than arguably the rarest of the three?
Rare doesn't equal good. Its laughable compared to an E46 M3.
E46 M3 could be had with a manual, its also not a saloon or estate. It didn't come with a V8. The BMW also didn't have very conservative power figures which were understated not to embarrass the rest of the AMG lineup. Hardly 'laughable'.

The M3 is a great car no doubt, but the C55 appealed to a different type of driver and you could argue the two aren't really rivals. Obviously the later ones were.
All good points but, the E46 was a gutless wonder. Tried one before i bought my first E39 M5. Absolutely nothing below 4500rpm, Had a C36 back in the day. Way more grunt yet only 286 bhp, and as for the E55, different league.

rog007

5,816 posts

246 months

Friday 7th February 2020
quotequote all
ArmaghMan said:
Not as far as I can see.
Have my absolutely mint 2 owner rust free E55 up at the minute for sensible money.
Nothing doing.
With the (accelerating) transition from the internal combustion engine to electric, will the future classic car world still be the same, or will this scenario start to become more common?

Murderer_For_Hire

2 posts

63 months

Thursday 26th November 2020
quotequote all
threesixty said:
Rare doesn't equal good. Its laughable compared to an E46 M3.
C55 doesn't care about a weaker, rainbow striped E46. The C55 is an AMG Frankenstein, an abomination of a car that is brute force. You're laughable.

Edited by Murderer_For_Hire on Thursday 26th November 19:33