Are you all like this?
Author
Discussion

k15tox

Original Poster:

1,680 posts

203 months

Thursday 15th March 2012
quotequote all
i mean got the blinkers on..

i use Alfaowner for tech help and i feel its a valuble forum.

however how do you try to educate some people?

http://www.alfaowner.com/Forum/alfa-147-156-and-gt...

i understand it should be expected from a single marque owners club but come on!

i just cant be arsed replying to the last reply. I would have expected this from CORSAC but not and alfa forum!

(note copy and pasted PH explanation of Power and Torque couldnt be arsed explaining it)


Edited by k15tox on Thursday 15th March 10:40

V6GTA

2,014 posts

219 months

Thursday 15th March 2012
quotequote all
k15tox said:
i mean got the blinkers on..

i use Alfaowner for tech help and i feel its a valuble forum.

however how do you try to educate some people?

http://www.alfaowner.com/Forum/alfa-147-156-and-gt...

i understand it should be expected from a single marque owners club but come on!

i just cant be arsed replying to the last reply. I would have expected this from CORSAC but not and alfa forum!

(note copy and pasted PH explanation of Power and Torque couldnt be arsed explaining it)


Edited by k15tox on Thursday 15th March 10:40
There will always be people who disagree and think silly things... Water off a ducks back and all that lark.. smile

k15tox

Original Poster:

1,680 posts

203 months

Thursday 15th March 2012
quotequote all
V6GTA said:
There will always be people who disagree and think silly things... Water off a ducks back and all that lark.. smile
yeah.

just makes you want to headbutt a wall.

at least there was no aggression like the usual PH responses! smile

velocemitch

4,019 posts

242 months

Thursday 15th March 2012
quotequote all
AO has gone down the pan in the last few years..... it's slide probably directly related to the price of 156's wink

That said, having had a 250BHP 'petrol' 156GTA and compared it's real world performance with 170BHP and umpteen torque diesel (The BMW I owned afterwards) I sort of know what he means. It's very difficult to get the Petrol engines on 'cam' in order to catch the initial shove that the Diesels give with the torque. By the time you get there you are into licence loosing territory and sensible people would back off.... didn't seem like this bloke did!.

Back in the day when the 20v and the GTA were current models, it was fairly well accepted that the diesel wasn't a million miles behind in the performance stakes and a GTA would be comparable to a VXR so I'm not shocked the VXR struggled a bit.

k15tox

Original Poster:

1,680 posts

203 months

Thursday 15th March 2012
quotequote all
velocemitch said:
AO has gone down the pan in the last few years..... it's slide probably directly related to the price of 156's wink

That said, having had a 250BHP 'petrol' 156GTA and compared it's real world performance with 170BHP and umpteen torque diesel (The BMW I owned afterwards) I sort of know what he means. It's very difficult to get the Petrol engines on 'cam' in order to catch the initial shove that the Diesels give with the torque. By the time you get there you are into licence loosing territory and sensible people would back off.... didn't seem like this bloke did!.

Back in the day when the 20v and the GTA were current models, it was fairly well accepted that the diesel wasn't a million miles behind in the performance stakes and a GTA would be comparable to a VXR so I'm not shocked the VXR struggled a bit.
maybe so, still even with a 150kg weight advantage the vxr is 75hp up 105 if a later model, plus think it has the same torque output, they are certainly what id call 'quick'.

but youve had experience with the said model so i do respect your opinion,

the most funny thing which really got me out of the whole debate is the guy who thinks alfa concentrate on making lightweight drivers cars all these years ago. And other marques are behind! Does he know cars have generally got heavier over time?


velocemitch

4,019 posts

242 months

Thursday 15th March 2012
quotequote all
Must admit I got a bit bored so didn't read it all, but said guy mustn't have driven a 159 or a Brera if he thinks Alfa always make light cars! biggrin

JimmyJam

2,422 posts

241 months

Friday 16th March 2012
quotequote all
I also got bored reading but maybe the guy in VXR just wasn't a very good driver or wasn't pushing it?

V6GTA

2,014 posts

219 months

Friday 16th March 2012
quotequote all
JimmyJam said:
I also got bored reading but maybe the guy in VXR just wasn't a very good driver or wasn't pushing it?
off boost init!

omniflow

3,555 posts

173 months

Sunday 25th March 2012
quotequote all
velocemitch said:
AO has gone down the pan in the last few years..... it's slide probably directly related to the price of 156's wink
Agree with the first bit, but not the 2nd. Some of the worst offenders on there drive things like 159s and Breras.

Esseesse

9,027 posts

230 months

Thursday 29th March 2012
quotequote all
There are exceptions, but AO is largely full of damp squibs.

Chaz9950

1,133 posts

166 months

Saturday 28th April 2012
quotequote all
Haha, quite a read on the AO forum.. LOL!

Basically, to sum it up - power = torque x revs.

Diesels produce more torque, but at less revs. You can easily drive a diesel at 2,500 - 3,000 rpms and have 'instant torque' available, as that's where they make peak torque.

In a petrol, you'd probably not be driving at 5,000 - 6,000 rpms where a lot make peak torque. Even if the figure is lower, it's x2, as the engine is doing twice the revs of the diesel. Comparable.

It's easier to drive a diseasel quick, as there are no downshifts to worry about. Petrols are more involving.

End. LOL!


Oh, and if you want to go REALLY quick (other than buying an Alfa 20v diesel) buy a Veyron engine, and put it in a 4wd shopping trolley. 10,000hp / tonne...? HAHA!

herbialfa

1,489 posts

224 months

Sunday 29th April 2012
quotequote all
AO is fill of cardigans!!!

Gave up on it years ago.

Try alfa156.net

Good bunch of people and some are very knowledgeable/ helpful

HeatonNorris

1,649 posts

170 months

Sunday 29th April 2012
quotequote all
I had to read that original post in the Clarkson anorak voice. Then it made sense...