Fiat 500 Convertible.. thoughts?
Fiat 500 Convertible.. thoughts?
Author
Discussion

renmure

Original Poster:

4,786 posts

246 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
Any ownership experience? Anything to avoid? Any must-have options?

Probably looking at a 1.2 version. Both SWMBO and I think it looks cute, chirpy and fairly distinctive for a fun runabout. I appreciate it is not going to win any drag races at the lights but would appreciate any real world feedback if there are any owners kicking about.

More generally, it would probably replace a MINI Cooper, which has also been fun, fab, solid and totally reliable and as a bonus also cheap(ish) to run with the tlc package.

How do Fiats compare these days in terms of reliability and servicing? Unfortunately my only experience of 'real' Fiats has been 3 Fiat X1/9's which were fantastic little cars but weren't exactly reliable.

isuk

1,522 posts

238 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
The 1.2 is incredibly lethargic and I'd avoid it at all costs. My mother made the mistake of an impulse trade in of her 1.3 diesel Lounge for a 1.2 petrol By Diesel special edition and hated it. She kept it for 3 weeks and has now traded it back in to the dealer and is waiting on a new 1.3 desel 500 C.

I drove the 1.2 on the day she took it back to the dealer and it is truly woeful. I had a 1.4 Lounge for a year before getting my Abarth and the difference in power between the 1.2 and 1.4 is astonishing on the road. The 1.3 diesel is a much better bet IMHO as it qualifies for the low RFL band of £35 per annum and has plenty of torque to allow overtaking to be achieved if there is more than one person in the car.... something I wouldn't recommend in the 1.2 unless you are going down a very steep hill that has at least half a mile of clear traffic in the opposite direction and you are overtaking a very old tractor that can't achieve 30mph biggrin

Pooh

3,692 posts

275 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
Regarding servicing, I have a Grande Punto Sporting 1.9 multijet that I bought from the Fiat dealer in Perth, I have found the servicing to be very cheap and the service from the dealer to be very good. As an example I managed to break the cigarette lighter socket, the dealer fixed it for £6.00 and washed the car while they were at it.
I have only driven a 1.4 500 and it went well enough for a runabout but I needed 3 rear seats so I bought the Punto.

pixelpimp

674 posts

219 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
Why do you need a 500C rather than a 500?
The C is just rubbish, unless you do a couple of miles a day in a city.
On the open roads with the roof "down" the buffeting is unacceptable, the instruments are hard to read and even the 1.4 is gutless.
The normal 500 or even Panda is a much better bet.

Exoticaholic

1,075 posts

234 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
isuk said:
The 1.2 is incredibly lethargic and I'd avoid it at all costs. My mother made the mistake of an impulse trade in of her 1.3 diesel Lounge for a 1.2 petrol By Diesel special edition and hated it. She kept it for 3 weeks and has now traded it back in to the dealer and is waiting on a new 1.3 desel 500 C.

I drove the 1.2 on the day she took it back to the dealer and it is truly woeful. I had a 1.4 Lounge for a year before getting my Abarth and the difference in power between the 1.2 and 1.4 is astonishing on the road. The 1.3 diesel is a much better bet IMHO as it qualifies for the low RFL band of £35 per annum and has plenty of torque to allow overtaking to be achieved if there is more than one person in the car.... something I wouldn't recommend in the 1.2 unless you are going down a very steep hill that has at least half a mile of clear traffic in the opposite direction and you are overtaking a very old tractor that can't achieve 30mph biggrin
'allo 'allo what have we got here?

OK, but at least it gets me from A to B with a smile all times. I haven't endeavoured any prospect of overtaking a tractor - yet.

Let's face it, the state of the roads is dire!

renmure

Original Poster:

4,786 posts

246 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
pixelpimp said:
Why do you need a 500C rather than a 500?
The C is just rubbish, unless you do a couple of miles a day in a city.
On the open roads with the roof "down" the buffeting is unacceptable, the instruments are hard to read and even the 1.4 is gutless.
The normal 500 or even Panda is a much better bet.
Thanks for the feedback smile

I had a test drive a few weeks ago in a normal 500 (think it was a 1.3) and, whilst it was fine and perfectly fit for purpose as a chirpy cheery little MINI replacement, I didn't think it quite hit the spot enough to want to change. Once I started looking further up the range at the more sporty models it began to become more of financial decision as to what else you could get for the money rather than a "what the hell" decision. The Convertible throws things back in the mixer.

Why a 500C? Hmmm, I guess if I need to get anywhere quickly then like isuk, I probably have something more suitable to do it in. It's the ability to pootle around with the roof down that actually appeals ... including the buffeting I guess, although I take on board the views so far about a lack of oooomph.

Living out in the countryside at least I will have a lot of tractors to joust with smile

pixelpimp

674 posts

219 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
Also you'll need to live with the awful rear visibility when the roof is down, it's very bad and the steering wheel is the size of a space saver!!
Apart from that topless fun woo hoo.

isuk

1,522 posts

238 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
Exoticaholic said:
'allo 'allo what have we got here?

OK, but at least it gets me from A to B with a smile all times. I haven't endeavoured any prospect of overtaking a tractor - yet.

Let's face it, the state of the roads is dire!
Oops..... sorry Ed. Forgot you have a 1.2 biggrin To be fair I am comparing it to some zippier toys wink I still would recommend a 1.3 diesel or 1.4 petrol though if the car is going to regularly have multiple occupants or be used mainly out of town where speed and overtaking ability become more relevant.

Edited by isuk on Monday 24th August 15:59

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

277 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
isuk said:
I still would recommend a 1.3 diesel
Surely you'd want a petrol for a convertible?

isuk

1,522 posts

238 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
isuk said:
I still would recommend a 1.3 diesel
Surely you'd want a petrol for a convertible?
Not really. The 1.3 multijet diesel has lower emissions than both petrol units - 110g vs 119 for the 1.2 and 140 for the 1.4 thus qualifying it for £35 a year RFL, much better fuel economy, and much higher torque. It's not a noisy unit either. Until the new generation of multiair petrol engines find their way into the 500 range next year it's probably the pick of the range IMHO. Lets face it none of these engines are exactly race car material so better torque and significantly higher MPG are worthy of serious consideration I'd say.

pixelpimp

674 posts

219 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
Agree with the 1.3 I have one in my Punto now with 10,000 effort free miles it's a good torquey motor.
Will cruise all day at 90.

renmure

Original Poster:

4,786 posts

246 months

Saturday 29th August 2009
quotequote all
Hogging my own thread here but....
Collected a test-drive car today after arranging a 3 day test drive with a local Fiat Dealer (Arnold Clark, Kirkaldy) which I thought was a fantastic and generous offer.

Initial impressions: SWMBO and I like it!! However,
Sluggish?.. err.. yes. Managed to get up to 70mph fairly easily so kept up with the flow of traffic ok, but probably not the car do do swift B-road overtakes.
Rear vision?.. wow, definatlely compromised (ie zero) with the roof down, although having owned enough Exiges and Esprits it's nothing that bothers me too much.
Wind buffeting?.. Although it was a really windy day, the buffeting was far more than either of us were expecting. Don't think it will be a deal breaker but it's a good reason for having an extended test drive to see if today was as good as it gets.
Apart from that... all cool so far. 2 days to go smile