Most Fuel Efficient Car on a LOW budget
Most Fuel Efficient Car on a LOW budget
Author
Discussion

TigraPete

Original Poster:

55 posts

186 months

Wednesday 11th May 2011
quotequote all
So PH, I just changed my job, this job requires me to drive 150 miles or more a day, I am looking for any car on a budget of £1500 that is going to be the most economic for me. IDEAS PLEASE! (baring in mind, im also 21, and my insurance is fairly high)

autofox

49 posts

212 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
306\xsara hdi, fiesta\focus tdci, the latter may be a bit leggy at that price though.

vit4

3,507 posts

200 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

In a similar situation, as it goes nothing's changed yet so haven't taken the plunge but got some really good suggestions on that thread smile In summary a 106/Metro diesel would be cheapest but could lead to side effects such as suicide/chronic depression etc.

Efbe

9,251 posts

196 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
daihatsu charade td

can net 100mpg for a careful driver ( http://www.fuelacademy.com/world_record_drives.htm...)

WeirdNeville

6,049 posts

245 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
Pug 306 HDi or 406 Hdi.

Or, if you're a sadist, a 105 1.5 Diesel (non turbo)... 75Mpg possible, suicide likely.

Autotrader shows a few Diesel Fabia's for around £1,500, they're leggy at around 120k miles but other examples are puching 180k miles wo who knows? They're a surprisingly decent place to be for long journeys. Expect 55-60Mpg.

Or, from leftfield, a Rover 75 2.0 TDi can be had for £1,500-£1,600 and people say they're surprisingly good with BMW diesel engines and drivetrain.

Slightly over budget at £1,700 are Vovlvo V40's or S40's with a 1.9 Tdi and around 100k miles on a V plate. My parents have had one for 5 years and it's been good and returned 55mpg.


Fret not, someone will be around shortly to tell you this ideal MX-5 territory and you;ll get 50mpg out them no problem!

Locke

1,279 posts

214 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
I've just picked up a mint condition Toyota Yaris D4-D - 24k, FSH, 1 former keeper, 5 door on a 52 plate for £1400. They're supposed to return 68mpg combined and built very well so should last a while. Only £30 a year road tax too.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

220 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
TigraPete said:
So PH, I just changed my job, this job requires me to drive 150 miles or more a day, I am looking for any car on a budget of £1500 that is going to be the most economic for me. IDEAS PLEASE! (baring in mind, im also 21, and my insurance is fairly high)
Most small diesels. Or look for a small petrol running LPG.

I'd also say range is important here or else you'll be filling up everyday.

I used to do 110 miles a day. I used a £650 Peugeot 106 diesel 1.5d. Not the most relaxing but it did the job. A bit flakey round the edges but it was good on fuel.

But you had to drive it right. Drive with economy in mind and it'd do 62-66mpg with ease. Drive just a little harder or faster though and it'd be down to 48mpg. I never once clocked it in the 50's.

Not long before I got shot of it I started running it on Shell V Power diesel. It ran smoother and more quieter. But best of all even better on fuel. The highest I clocked was 77mpg!!! Although I beleive on one of the last long journeys I used it for it, it may have been returning 80mpg.

Not too bad to drive, heavy steering but it actually went and handled ok. Best of all it'd normally do 400-450 miles between fill ups and sometimes well over 500.

Tonberry

2,296 posts

222 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
You want a 306 HDI like the one in my profile. 800 miles on a single tank.

andy-xr

13,204 posts

234 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
Are we talking about a 75 mile+ commute each way here, or company sending you out and about? Former I'd def be thinking about a 306, if the latter, maybe throw it at something awful like a new C1 (I think your budget would buy a quarter of one as a deposit) and get the company to pay your exes? Flog after 2 years before the miles get too silly

I've done that sort of travel before for a job, it's sustainable for 12 months, soul destroying thereafter, so be careful if you get tied into something

eltax91

10,763 posts

236 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
Octavia TDi. I have the old 110 bhp version. Service it every 10k with good oil and it just will not fail. I paid £2k over 3 years ago and have done 105k in it since. I have to submit receipts in a spreadsheet for work, so I have beenable to keep accurate mpg figures. Over 105k of mainly motorway miles (car now on 170k), it is running at 50.7mpg. That is simply unbelievable for the low cost and reliability you get. smile

lescombes

968 posts

240 months

Thursday 12th May 2011
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Most small diesels. Or look for a small petrol running LPG.

I'd also say range is important here or else you'll be filling up everyday.

I used to do 110 miles a day. I used a £650 Peugeot 106 diesel 1.5d. Not the most relaxing but it did the job. A bit flakey round the edges but it was good on fuel.

But you had to drive it right. Drive with economy in mind and it'd do 62-66mpg with ease. Drive just a little harder or faster though and it'd be down to 48mpg. I never once clocked it in the 50's.

Not long before I got shot of it I started running it on Shell V Power diesel. It ran smoother and more quieter. But best of all even better on fuel. The highest I clocked was 77mpg!!! Although I beleive on one of the last long journeys I used it for it, it may have been returning 80mpg.

Not too bad to drive, heavy steering but it actually went and handled ok. Best of all it'd normally do 400-450 miles between fill ups and sometimes well over 500.
+1 for the 106 diesel....wont set the tarmac alight but will go on forever plus if it has a Bosch diesel pump....you can mix veg oil in the tank at an up to 50% ratio....at 94p litre for Veg off the shelf...worth the few mins pouring it in.... My neighbour has been using veg in hers for the last 2 yrs and the MOT test last week it passed with flying colours with a veg mix....in fact the tester thought is emmissions kit was faulty as the reading was so low

TigraPete

Original Poster:

55 posts

186 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
cheers guys, i might go with the xsara as i have alot of gear to carry for work aswell so an estate might help!

christofmccracke

881 posts

230 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
I have a 1.2 Clio as a runabout and it does 40mpg easy

SSBB

698 posts

186 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
I would avoid the 306. It has most unsupportive seats. After about 100 miles or so of motorway cruising I used to get a back ache. Never had that in any other car before or since.

dangerousB

1,701 posts

220 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
You can't go wrong with any VW with the 1.9TDi engine.
My girlfriend's selling her Golf at the mo' - under your budget and 55mpg is easily achievable (even with me behind the wheel!), low 60's if you're careful.
Not sure what the insurance is like, but I can't imagine it'd be too horrendous.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

285 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
If you are on a tight budget then the last thing you want is a common rail diesel engine (e.g. HDi, TDCi, DCi). When the injectors or DMF fail, repairs are likely to be considerably more than the value of the car.

If you must have a diesel then the Rover 200/400/25/45 turbo diesels are virtually bullet proof, as are the VAG 1.9TDi or the lower powered 1.9PD and the 1.9XUD Peugeot/Citroen engine (older 306, 406 etc). Unrefined and noisy, but simple and reliable.

WeirdNeville

6,049 posts

245 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
dangerousB said:
You can't go wrong with any VW with the 1.9TDi engine.
Ohhhh, you can.
I had an Audi 80 with that engine, it was a we of a thing. It had some intermittent problem that meant a total loss of power, and juddering and shaking on the motorway. It went to several diesel specialists for the throttle position sensor, 3GR, injectors and fuel pump to be looked at and it was never diagnosed leaving the car unpleasant and occasionally dangerous to drive.

That's the problem with diesel. Fine when they work, and by and large they work for a very long time, but if they go wrong you're screwed.

seagrey

385 posts

195 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
one of these;

Locke

1,279 posts

214 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
seagrey said:
one of these;

rolleyes

LuS1fer

43,517 posts

275 months

Friday 13th May 2011
quotequote all
Saxo/106 diesel? I did 1500km in 3 days in Spain and it coped very well indeed though of course it was new then....