Budget aluminium trolley jacks: Clarke vs Arcan
Budget aluminium trolley jacks: Clarke vs Arcan
Author
Discussion

carl0s

Original Poster:

577 posts

258 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Before I took the two broken Clarke's to the tip, I thought a few side-by-side photos might be worthwhile.

Price is about the same for each (£90). I hear Costco is best for the Arcan. I paid ~£110 through eBay.

I'll let the pictures do the talking. Photos will go bigger if you right-click and "View picture" or similar.
























Edited by carl0s on Saturday 4th June 19:11

McSam

6,753 posts

205 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Well! That looks pretty conclusive to me hehe

Thanks for sharing these, always good to know what to look for.

LuS1fer

43,517 posts

275 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
They're the worst lawnmowers I've ever seen.

OllieC

3,816 posts

244 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
They're the worst lawnmowers I've ever seen.
haha that made me laugh smile

carl0s

Original Poster:

577 posts

258 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
McSam said:
Well! That looks pretty conclusive to me hehe

Thanks for sharing these, always good to know what to look for.
Yup, no worries smile

From looking at pictures of them individually, you wouldn't appreciate how much bigger the Arcan is.
It is the CEALJ2T / ALJ2T, which is labeled as 2 ton, but that's 2 American tons, which is 1.85 of our tons or 1,850kgs. The Clarke is 1.25t/1,250kgs.

The larger one is 10KGs heavier mind you. 22KGs vs 12KGs.

Edited by carl0s on Saturday 4th June 19:37

JM

3,170 posts

236 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
I was using my Costco bought Arcan today.

Great piece of kit!

Hitler Hadrump

1,750 posts

203 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all


This is my favourite of the series. I think the shoes represent how invisible the individual feels in our consumer culture.

The tiger on the van dashboard is representative of the grip oil has on our society, and how helpless we are without it. The tiger has parked the van in front of the red hoist, blocking it from us, but allows us our trolley jacks - it is as if he is saying that we may be rise up a few inches, but we will never be properly high.

Finally, the van's numberplate being carefully removed and placed on the floor is symbolic of the kind of person who would spend a beautiful sunny afternoon exhaustively photographing two broken trolley jacks next to their new one.

Ian Geary

5,617 posts

222 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Well, I'm certainly glad he took the time!

I've been waiting ages for a snap of a broken CTJ1250A to add to my picture album of knackered trolley jacks.


The search continues...

Ian

carl0s

Original Poster:

577 posts

258 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Hitler Hadrump said:


This is my favourite of the series. I think the shoes represent how invisible the individual feels in our consumer culture.

The tiger on the van dashboard is representative of the grip oil has on our society, and how helpless we are without it. The tiger has parked the van in front of the red hoist, blocking it from us, but allows us our trolley jacks - it is as if he is saying that we may be rise up a few inches, but we will never be properly high.

Finally, the van's numberplate being carefully removed and placed on the floor is symbolic of the kind of person who would spend a beautiful sunny afternoon exhaustively photographing two broken trolley jacks next to their new one.
Lol. Very creative :-)
I change into an old pair of shoes that I keep outside when working on car.
It's my uncle's van, as is the covered half-a Ford pop. He has some sort of mental issue with regard to getting rid of scrap cars..

carl0s

Original Poster:

577 posts

258 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Hitler Hadrump said:


This is my favourite of the series. I think the shoes represent how invisible the individual feels in our consumer culture.

The tiger on the van dashboard is representative of the grip oil has on our society, and how helpless we are without it. The tiger has parked the van in front of the red hoist, blocking it from us, but allows us our trolley jacks - it is as if he is saying that we may be rise up a few inches, but we will never be properly high.

Finally, the van's numberplate being carefully removed and placed on the floor is symbolic of the kind of person who would spend a beautiful sunny afternoon exhaustively photographing two broken trolley jacks next to their new one.
Lol. Very creative :-)
I change into an old pair of shoes that I keep outside when working on car.
It's my uncle's van, as is the covered half-a Ford pop. He has some sort of mental issue with regard to getting rid of scrap cars..

carl0s

Original Poster:

577 posts

258 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Hitler Hadrump said:
Finally, the van's numberplate being carefully removed and placed on the floor is symbolic of the kind of person who would spend a beautiful sunny afternoon exhaustively photographing two broken trolley jacks next to their new one.
P.S. it's a car enthusiast's website. I spent the beautiful sunny afternoon outside in the sun, spannering on my pride and joy. How much more right could that be?

(and spent 5 minutes of that afternoon taking 12 photos for the benefit of other genuine enthusiasts).