£30-35,000 to spend, 996 Turbo Manual or GT3 ?
£30-35,000 to spend, 996 Turbo Manual or GT3 ?
Author
Discussion

V9GRT

Original Poster:

88 posts

201 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all
I have been reading for hours and taking in all comments from the Forum.

911 Turbo has been childhood Pin Up and I know is very capeable.

GT3 is more Me, but I will be scrapping all funds to get 30-35k together.

Current cars E46M3, ELISE S1 on TB's. I love Honda VTEC engines for shear grin factor.

Historically I have found Turbo cars un exciting, I have driven the Turbo on test drive and enjoyed it but no hairs on the back of my neck stood up!

Will Very low £30s buy me a dog of a GT3, I have seen the GT3 RS that is on here but its a cat D ?

The word I am looking for is Exhillarating, please help with your valuable knowledge and experience.

Gavin

GT Two

3,070 posts

223 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all
Gavin, I fear you will not find what you want in a turbo.

I owned one or a year, modded it and then decided I may as well buy a GT2 which was a great car.

I then missed NA cars and went back to an NA porsche. If you want exhilerating I think you need a GT3.

turbo964

810 posts

214 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all
If you want something Exhillarating as a weekend toy then an Air-cooled turbo would be the way to go. £35k will buy a nice 964 3.3 turbo or a 930 4 speed.

However if you want the car as a daily drive the 996 turbo is a hell of a car for the same money but at the risk pissing people off here not "that special" to drive.

I think the GT3 is probably the way to go unless you want something old school.

GT03ROB

14,037 posts

252 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all
The GT3 is a very special beast. The turbo is awesome.

From what you say the GT3 is where you want to be. I drove both took my choice.

Buy carefully you will get into a Gt3 for your budget (just)!

jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all
V9GRT said:
Current cars E46M3, ELISE S1 on TB's. I love Honda VTEC engines for shear grin factor.

Gavin
g t 3

davek_964

11,377 posts

206 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all
I'm very happy with my turbo these days. It's a very capable car, extremely happy with the handling since visiting CG and it's insanely quick - especially with the remap, but even before that. However - I would not describe it as exhilarating. Great fun, but not exhilarating - they are just too much of an all rounder to take that accolade.

Try to find a GT3. If you bought a turbo, I think you'd be disappointed once the novelty wore off.

V9GRT

Original Poster:

88 posts

201 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all

I found the following; the first is a write off being re built;

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2869954.htm

The rest, what do you think ? and what do I go for, year, spec, mk, etc PS. I need to put child seats in the rear so I believe no Clubsport ?

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2653372.htm

Why is this one so cheap ?

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1982460.htm

Thanks guys this help is invaluable

BertBert

21,346 posts

242 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all
Ignore the first one of course.

Kids seats in the back of a car with no seats in the back? You'll have to retro-fit seats so a chunk out of your budget.

On so low a budget, I'd buy very carefully indeed and make sure you get a proper professional inspection. You could be ok, but it'll be hard.

You may want to try one of the cheap 911s. Those turbos they can't give away. Jolly fast but so, so boring. biggrin

Bert

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Monday 13th June 2011
quotequote all
GT3 'life on the edge' as much fun as you can handle - thats where the fun REALLY is - you will never get there with a Turbo in the 'real world' (ie NOT the Matrix where most of the Turbo Heads seem to think they live) its just way too much.

Sometimes less IS more (fun anyway) but dare I say it ............ 3 little letters .............. CSL!!!!

My advice DRIVE them, be prepared to walk away whatever your heart/ego tells you until you find the right car, make your own mind up, be prepared for BIG BILLS, keep a contingency fund - they are ALL high maintenance - but most of all GO FOR IT - life is short!!!

Khushy

PS - IMHO GT3's are very special indeed (like CSL's)

Edited by khushy on Monday 13th June 23:58

willmac

2,096 posts

195 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
As the OP has already said , didn't get the WOW factor with the turbo, so you have answered your own question really. Would have to be a GT3.

But I reckon your budget is too tight to get into GT3 territory without running into some problems. Not had a Porsche yet that didn't like spending your money like it was going out of fashion. So if you are stretching the budget to just get the car, you may find you have a pretty miserable time at a later date trying to keep it on the road.

996ttalot

1,931 posts

206 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
I won't comment on the GT3 other than to say that if you get bored with it, then there is not much you can do further with it. It is not my cup of tea but I know it is good. I let others more qualified comment on its merits.

But I can comment on the 996 Turbo.

IMO the 996 Turbo lacks power, noise and interaction. It sometimes is just too much of a "GT" although a very good one.

If you want interaction, try driving it with PSM off - it is a different car. I am not sure how many owners actually do this.

However the one advantage is that you can, subject to having the cash, never have to get bored of it. Whilst it may not be a GT2 you can certainely do enough mods to suspension and so on to eliminate a lot of the difference. Hell you can convert in hours the car to RWD if you want.

I probably have a different perspective to most because I have been fortunate to drive some different variants of the 996tt, but after driving a "1000hp" performance version of it, both with PSM on and off, I cannot imagine anything coming close to providing that thrill factor. I was still trying to stop thinking about the drive days later.

That is an extreme example and would cost you nearly 3 times the budget you quoted, but the main point being that you also know that you can increase the dosage of your fix in the future.

Anyway just my view on the 996 turbo at least.

996ttalot

1,931 posts

206 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
I'm very happy with my turbo these days. It's a very capable car, extremely happy with the handling since visiting CG and it's insanely quick - especially with the remap, but even before that. However - I would not describe it as exhilarating. Great fun, but not exhilarating - they are just too much of an all rounder to take that accolade.

Try to find a GT3. If you bought a turbo, I think you'd be disappointed once the novelty wore off.
Dave, you need your next fix hehe

Diesel130

1,549 posts

243 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
V9GRT said:
Why is this one so cheap ?

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1982460.htm

Thanks guys this help is invaluable
Not exactly sure, but it has been on sale for a _very_ long time - must be a year now. The wheels look aftermarket, which is a bit odd. It's had rear seat belts fitted, which may be handy for you. Get it checked out and if OK, offer £30K...

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
Diesel130 said:
V9GRT said:
Why is this one so cheap ?

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1982460.htm

Thanks guys this help is invaluable
Not exactly sure, but it has been on sale for a _very_ long time - must be a year now. The wheels look aftermarket, which is a bit odd. It's had rear seat belts fitted, which may be handy for you. Get it checked out and if OK, offer £30K...
Did then facelift GT3 ever have those style of wheels? I thought they all had the GT2(mk2) style wheels?

911Thrasher

2,573 posts

230 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
GT3 anytime...also for once i will elaborate on depreciation: dont know where the GT3 will end up but the 996 turbo is only going down (you can pick some up for £25k already)

sy247

377 posts

225 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
Don't get a 996 turbo whatever you do, I find mine terribly boring

carcrazypop

579 posts

195 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
911Thrasher said:
GT3 anytime...also for once i will elaborate on depreciation: dont know where the GT3 will end up but the 996 turbo is only going down (you can pick some up for £25k already)
Yes, but the mint, low mileage 996 turbos are becoming few & far between; Paragon have recently sold a 2003 996t with 16k miles for £38k and it only took a couple of days to sell, and it's a tip !

The good ones are going to become scarce and therefore hold their value but the high mileage, neglected ones probably won't IMHO.


sy247

377 posts

225 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
Regarding 996 turbos within the 25 - 35K price range you will find a great variation in cars condition. There is no such thing as a cheap Porsche, especially a turbo. The cheap cars will be cheap for a reason. You can lose 3K + into one of these cars at the drop of a hat.

AtomMan

10,742 posts

265 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
As has already been said, a GT3 is probably the way to go. However, buying is one thing, keeping it on the road in top condition is something else. And if you are spending every penny you have to buy it, surely you are just setting yourself up for further pain once it's on your driveway? Especially as you are looking at bottom of the market cars..

If it was me, I would consider a 993 or 964 for maybe late teens or early £20Ks. Can do some sensible track orientated mods and still have plenty in reserve. And you can buy a decent car in the first place!biggrin

David Hype

2,296 posts

283 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
OP. Your budget has made your decision for you!

There are many more Turbos around to choose from in your price range. Not so, with the GT3.

At you budget the GT3 is going to be older, higher mileage, not the perfect spec. and possibly have some stories. Probably more relevant, is that you are going to have to wait a lot longer and do far more research to find your ideal car for the money.

Going for the Turbo, will offer you more choice and a better chance of getting into a sound car.

Another £5K on the top end of your budget and the land of really good GT3`s will open up for you, so why not be a bit more patient and wait for the right time to come along.

Oh, and try them both before you make your mind up.

Happy hunting driving