What (automatic) first car?
What (automatic) first car?
Author
Discussion

unpc

Original Poster:

2,998 posts

242 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Yes, yes another dreary what car thread I know but a friend of mine has £2k to blow on a first car but it must be AUTOMATIC. It also needs to be smallish and reasonably economical although she won't be doing mega miles. Not sure what the insurance implications of being a new driver at 30 are but it needs to be sensible.

She doesn't want a Smart or an MX5 although I did point out the error of her ways hehe

Also, did we ever get to the bottom of what constitutes an automatic? Do they have to be torque converter types or are DSG type boxes deemed to be Autos too?


dvance

605 posts

197 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
I don't see why you would want an automatic as a 1st car if you don't have a disability of some sort. Better learn to drive right when you start off to because otherwise you would not.

Mind you some people would consider being a girl a disability when it comes to driving hehe

adsvx220

705 posts

212 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Nissan micra s 1.1. Very very fast and the kick down is just amazing with that little engine roaring ;-)

Liquid Knight

15,754 posts

212 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Does she only have one leg?

dvance

605 posts

197 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
doogz said:
Micra.

DSG i believe can be driven on an auto licence, but you'll not find a DSG anything for £2k i don't imagine.
Should be able to pick up just the gearbox I imagine hehe

Baryonyx

18,281 posts

188 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Nissan Micra has to be the one here. Cheap as chips to run and insure and it doesnt sound like your friend is after thrills or quality.

That said, I wouldn't advocate getting an automatic first unless it's a necessity due to disability or not being able to pass a manual test. There is still plenty of learning to be done about clutch control, gearing and shifting to be done for a new driver.

unpc

Original Poster:

2,998 posts

242 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Liquid Knight said:
Does she only have one leg?
Actually she has 2 very nice ones but seems to be struggling with the driving thing to such an extent that she sees going auto as the only answer.

WOO5IE

966 posts

226 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Where are you in Essex as my elderly next door neighbour has just stopped driving and her Honda Jazz was going to put up for sale via her son a couple of weeks ago. I thinks its still in the garage as it is always been kept there.

It is an auto and in very good mechanical condition. It does have a few scrapes though as her judgement wasnt what it used to be . Hence the packing up driving

If you are interested and I havent a clue what is worth then email me .

It would be an excellent buy for a new driver.

unpc

Original Poster:

2,998 posts

242 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
dvance said:
doogz said:
Micra.

DSG i believe can be driven on an auto licence, but you'll not find a DSG anything for £2k i don't imagine.
Should be able to pick up just the gearbox I imagine hehe
The DSG question was an aside smile I do realise that they are a bit too new.

I assume it's going to be the Micra blob at this money?

dvance

605 posts

197 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
unpc said:
Actually she has 2 very nice ones but seems to be struggling with the driving thing to such an extent that she sees going auto as the only answer.
Teach her? Or in case you're not up for the task at hand, pass her number to the PH massive -- I am sure there's plenty who'll be happy to help hehe

RobCrezz

7,892 posts

237 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
doogz said:
If she struggles with driving, maybe she shouldn't drive.

Not trying to be a prick about it, but someone ploughed into my Subaru the other day, just, a st driver, and there's too many of them about.
Yeah good point. Changing gear is a small part of being a half decent driver.

Futuramic

1,763 posts

234 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
dvance said:
unpc said:
Actually she has 2 very nice ones but seems to be struggling with the driving thing to such an extent that she sees going auto as the only answer.
Teach her? Or in case you're not up for the task at hand, pass her number to the PH massive -- I am sure there's plenty who'll be happy to help hehe
Going auto definitely is NOT the answer. Changing gear and pulling away are easy with a few minutes practice; it's the other stuff she should be concerned about: steering and looking etc. An automatic won't do that for her.

And the answer is: a Cadillac Eldorado. That barely needs a gearbox at all.

unclepockets

553 posts

195 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
I'd avoid anything with CVT, hatefull box IMHO.

so called

9,160 posts

238 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Maybe she's better off not messing around with gears.
Leaves her more time to focus on the main objective of driving ie. Getting from A to B without hitting anyone.
There are plenty of knobs out there that think they can drive but can't but can't admit they should be in an auto.

sadako

7,080 posts

267 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Smart cars technically have a DSG, albeit a really simple, crap one iirc. It is built by Getrag too.

va1o

16,113 posts

236 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
sadako said:
Smart cars technically have a DSG, albeit a really simple, crap one iirc.
confused

VW Group offer the same 7-speed DSG in superminis as they do further up the range. You won't get a car with one for £2k though.

runboy

244 posts

210 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Not sure if Kia Picanto is down to that money but might well be for high mileage.

Or look at some of the Hyundai - Getz/Atoz etc.

These far east cars tend not be lookers but they are reliable and easy to drive with a few toys. We had an auto Picanto that didn't need more than general servicing, was nippy, comfy with aircon, elec windows, remote locking etc

Rawwr

22,722 posts

263 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Hmm, small engines mated to automatic gearboxes tend to be completely and utterly woeful. Get her in an S-Class.

RobCrezz

7,892 posts

237 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
sadako said:
Smart cars technically have a DSG, albeit a really simple, crap one iirc. It is built by Getrag too.
Really? I thought it was just a automated single clutch manual?

carmadgaz

3,204 posts

212 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
doogz said:
If she struggles with driving, maybe she shouldn't drive.

Not trying to be a prick about it, but someone ploughed into my Subaru the other day, just, a st driver, and there's too many of them about.
This. Clutch control isn't difficult with a bit of practice.