E39 Disapointment
Discussion
Gutted, for years and years I have always wanted an E39, remember first seeing one (allbeit a boggo one) when they came out and fell in love with the shape, the styling, thinking one day I will have one of those.
Well fast forward to 2009 we go out and purchase an E34 518i Tourer and I fall in love with the car, ok it is bit slow, doesn't have leather but everything works and I just love it, it asks for nothing, it has cost me about £1300 including buy the car, tyres, an exhaust, couple of suspension bits here and there, only problem was an annoying hunting idle.
Fast forward to 2-3 weeks ago, the E31 is starting to look tired and it needs some restoration work now and some paint, so we need another car, considering our experiences with the 34 and the 31 the logical choice was a 39, then the 34 packs up, fuel pump dies, and we are stuck, we need a car as the 31 and the 34 got used daily, so we hunt for a 39.
Didn't take too long to find one, 39 tourer in Fjord grey (pavement grey) described as 161k mile, FSH, bonnet keyed, scuffs on bumper, few marks, leather interior, £1095, so we go up and see it, and fair play exactly as described, I take it down the road, drives well, everything works electrically, aircon is super cold, steptronic box works well (needs oil change) comfy, pulls well, no knocks or rattles, drives tight, £1000 is exchanged and we drive it away.
Closer inspection it is a gem of a 39 considering age and mileage P/O looked after it well, every stamp in the book, I actually need to buy a new service booklet as the original is full, all new suspension components, new lower arms, it drives like a brand new car, new shockers, new airbags, new lower arms, no play in the steering.
So I have been driving it for a week now, and it is comfortable, it pulls well, the steptronic box works really well, really intelligent makes the Mitsubishi one look like a pile of dog s
t (which it was to be fair) I can't fault, I like the rain sensitive wipers, I like the auto level suspension, I like that when you hit 45mph the stereo gets louder or turns down depending what side of 45mph you are heading, cruise control is excellent, bar all accounts the car is utterly fantastic.
But I don't like it, I don't know what it is, it just feels soulless and I really want my 34 back, could be the stepbox as I hate autos with a passion dreadful things, but I feel nothing for the car, my 34 should be back on the road today and I can't wait to jump back in it, it doesn't have leather, it doesn't have cruisecontrol or other electric items it is a pov spec with a twin sunroof, but I miss it so.
Gutted, I have hankered for a 39 for so long now, since I was about 14 and I just can't love it even though it is the most fantastic thing I have ever driven, as a car it is utterly superb, but it isn't the 34, and that leaves me with a qaundry, when the 34 dies what do I replace it with.
Am I the only one who has stepped up from a 34 to a 39 only to want to step back down to a 34?
I am utterly gutted though, I could almost cry
Well fast forward to 2009 we go out and purchase an E34 518i Tourer and I fall in love with the car, ok it is bit slow, doesn't have leather but everything works and I just love it, it asks for nothing, it has cost me about £1300 including buy the car, tyres, an exhaust, couple of suspension bits here and there, only problem was an annoying hunting idle.
Fast forward to 2-3 weeks ago, the E31 is starting to look tired and it needs some restoration work now and some paint, so we need another car, considering our experiences with the 34 and the 31 the logical choice was a 39, then the 34 packs up, fuel pump dies, and we are stuck, we need a car as the 31 and the 34 got used daily, so we hunt for a 39.
Didn't take too long to find one, 39 tourer in Fjord grey (pavement grey) described as 161k mile, FSH, bonnet keyed, scuffs on bumper, few marks, leather interior, £1095, so we go up and see it, and fair play exactly as described, I take it down the road, drives well, everything works electrically, aircon is super cold, steptronic box works well (needs oil change) comfy, pulls well, no knocks or rattles, drives tight, £1000 is exchanged and we drive it away.
Closer inspection it is a gem of a 39 considering age and mileage P/O looked after it well, every stamp in the book, I actually need to buy a new service booklet as the original is full, all new suspension components, new lower arms, it drives like a brand new car, new shockers, new airbags, new lower arms, no play in the steering.
So I have been driving it for a week now, and it is comfortable, it pulls well, the steptronic box works really well, really intelligent makes the Mitsubishi one look like a pile of dog s
t (which it was to be fair) I can't fault, I like the rain sensitive wipers, I like the auto level suspension, I like that when you hit 45mph the stereo gets louder or turns down depending what side of 45mph you are heading, cruise control is excellent, bar all accounts the car is utterly fantastic.But I don't like it, I don't know what it is, it just feels soulless and I really want my 34 back, could be the stepbox as I hate autos with a passion dreadful things, but I feel nothing for the car, my 34 should be back on the road today and I can't wait to jump back in it, it doesn't have leather, it doesn't have cruisecontrol or other electric items it is a pov spec with a twin sunroof, but I miss it so.
Gutted, I have hankered for a 39 for so long now, since I was about 14 and I just can't love it even though it is the most fantastic thing I have ever driven, as a car it is utterly superb, but it isn't the 34, and that leaves me with a qaundry, when the 34 dies what do I replace it with.
Am I the only one who has stepped up from a 34 to a 39 only to want to step back down to a 34?
I am utterly gutted though, I could almost cry

I can sympathise, having gone from, not an E34, but an E28 528 to an E39. The E28 was much more fun, and decidedly cooler, but, it needed £1,000+ to get it through an MoT, my wife wouldn’t ride in it, and the body wasn’t really sound when one delved deep. So, an E39 it was (via a Volvo V70 R that is another story but was f-f-f-f-frightfully expensive to run).
My E39 is a 530 Sport with a manual ‘box and the cloth/alacantra seats (I don’t like autos or leather...). It is an excellent car, to the point that I have just replaced the front discs and pads AGAIN, and decided to run it for a while longer – I can’t find anything else that is actually better to drive, while having space for the family, a decent combination of performance and costs, etc.
But, for all their undoubted strong points, I don’t think they can be considered exciting, characterful, or... that sort of thing. I am lucky enough to have another car which is characterful and fun, so I accept the E39 as the efficient (if sometimes a bit demanding on the wallet) thing that it is (I quite accept that there are lots of things that are less characterful than an E39, too...). It ticks all my boxes, except... well, fun.
My E39 is a 530 Sport with a manual ‘box and the cloth/alacantra seats (I don’t like autos or leather...). It is an excellent car, to the point that I have just replaced the front discs and pads AGAIN, and decided to run it for a while longer – I can’t find anything else that is actually better to drive, while having space for the family, a decent combination of performance and costs, etc.
But, for all their undoubted strong points, I don’t think they can be considered exciting, characterful, or... that sort of thing. I am lucky enough to have another car which is characterful and fun, so I accept the E39 as the efficient (if sometimes a bit demanding on the wallet) thing that it is (I quite accept that there are lots of things that are less characterful than an E39, too...). It ticks all my boxes, except... well, fun.
I have not even been in an E34 but I did own some contemporary Mercs (W124) and now have an E39 as I saw it as a successor in many ways (quality wise) to the W124s (the later Merc rusts and is unreliable, so was not an option). I must agree on the fact that my E39 (a wonderful, one owner, low miles 530i AT) doesn't seem to exude as much personality as the W124 (an old-ish 200TE with few options) did and that I loved the W124 more, it felt a bit like part of the family.
Having said that, the E39 is a wonderful car and I hope to keep it for as long as possible as the "luxury family hack" and would not want to revert to the W124 now.
For me, E39's have always felt remote and uninvolving - M5 excepted. They're great at soaking up roads and giving you decent levels of comfort, cossetting you over great distances, but they just don't engage you enough.
The E34 feels more focused and direct in comparison. Of course, that's the way the 5er has eveolved. From near lethal handing of the E12 through to the margic carpet F10. It's progress, apparently.
A change of suspension will certainly liven it up and make it feel more connected to you. It is a slushbox daily driver though. Is it worth it?
The E34 feels more focused and direct in comparison. Of course, that's the way the 5er has eveolved. From near lethal handing of the E12 through to the margic carpet F10. It's progress, apparently.
A change of suspension will certainly liven it up and make it feel more connected to you. It is a slushbox daily driver though. Is it worth it?
It is only going to be hack so upgrading suspension etc will never be on the cards, I just find it neutral, such a shame as the 34 is such a great car for its age, and the drive is just so much nicer, truly gutted.
That said looks like the 39 may have an expensive bill coming up, as it is currently sat on my drive, running, the keys are in my hand, and the lock has a serious case of `the spins` so I can't turn it off, bonus.

That said looks like the 39 may have an expensive bill coming up, as it is currently sat on my drive, running, the keys are in my hand, and the lock has a serious case of `the spins` so I can't turn it off, bonus.

Hi
I've had BMW's ever since I passed my test and have been driving. I can understand where you are coming from as I too, previously had a fantastic last of the E34's 525i Sport manual which was utterly fantastic! I'm now in my E39 Touring and for me, it's just as great if not slightly better than my E34!
As mentioned, its because I've modified it and with the suspension lowering on high quality and reputable springs, with a modest power increase I find it can be a relaxed cruiser when I want it to be and I can hustle it along fantastically when I feel like some spirited driving. It's no 3 series coupe, but it hides it's bulk very very well indeed!
The E39 5 like all 5's is a comfortable executive class car, so will be 'muted' on the roads in standard form, excluding the M cars, the 540i with its power carries off the jeckyll & hyde thing very well too and I'd daresay so does the range starter in the shape of the 520i although of course, to a lesser capability level.
I'd suggest doing something similar in terms of subtle modifications at the right time - an Eibach springs and shocks set will instantly transform the old and weary suspension you have at the moment and the car will 'feel' much more taught and eager.
Of course, your taste's might not even like it if you do that, but you never know!
I'm holding onto my E39 and not selling it ever!
Cheers, Dennis!
I've had BMW's ever since I passed my test and have been driving. I can understand where you are coming from as I too, previously had a fantastic last of the E34's 525i Sport manual which was utterly fantastic! I'm now in my E39 Touring and for me, it's just as great if not slightly better than my E34!
As mentioned, its because I've modified it and with the suspension lowering on high quality and reputable springs, with a modest power increase I find it can be a relaxed cruiser when I want it to be and I can hustle it along fantastically when I feel like some spirited driving. It's no 3 series coupe, but it hides it's bulk very very well indeed!
The E39 5 like all 5's is a comfortable executive class car, so will be 'muted' on the roads in standard form, excluding the M cars, the 540i with its power carries off the jeckyll & hyde thing very well too and I'd daresay so does the range starter in the shape of the 520i although of course, to a lesser capability level.
I'd suggest doing something similar in terms of subtle modifications at the right time - an Eibach springs and shocks set will instantly transform the old and weary suspension you have at the moment and the car will 'feel' much more taught and eager.
Of course, your taste's might not even like it if you do that, but you never know!
I'm holding onto my E39 and not selling it ever!
Cheers, Dennis!
pits said:
Am I the only one who has stepped up from a 34 to a 39 only to want to step back down to a 34?
I loved my E34 Touring (a 530i V8 auto, very last of the line registered in 1997 with special order options). But it was never quick enough, and my (now ex-) wife said it seemed a bit old-fashioned, so I changed it for an E39 540i Touring, auto again.At first the E39 felt like a comfy barge in comparison to the low, sporty E34. I really thought I'd made a mistake. But I really came to love the E39; it had much more personality than I first thought and I kept it 3 years, longer than anything else I've ever owned. So give it a bit more time...
Wont be getting rid, it will just be added to the other stable of cars, when it actually gets back from BMW with no doubt an horrendous bill for a new barrel.
Should be back in the 34 later and I am looking forward to it, maybe a manual 39 might change my mind, but that will be when the 34 just can't make it through another MOT (yet to even fail one) so hopefully that will be a long long time as I just don't want to give up my 34
Should be back in the 34 later and I am looking forward to it, maybe a manual 39 might change my mind, but that will be when the 34 just can't make it through another MOT (yet to even fail one) so hopefully that will be a long long time as I just don't want to give up my 34
I have an E39 and while I have never owned an E34 a friend has one for a few years so I can compare them
The E34 does feel a bit lighter or possibly slightly sportier, its more old school feel to it – but its not as if the E34 – well a 518i as opposed to an E34 M5 – whilst a very nice driving car would be the most soulful car ever, like say an E30 M3 or even 325i Sport or whatever
It’s the same with an E36 compare to E46 – when the E46 came out the consensus was its better than an E36 but E36 a bit better to drive. But now when driving them the E36 feel old while the E46 feels a lot better, not as light footed but nicer to driver overall, exact same with E90, when it came out people complained about it being not a sporty as E46 but it is a better car in most ways and I think better to drive too.
I do think the fact your E39 is auto would make a big difference; I have a manual – drove autos and manual before plumping for the manual as I liked it much more
The car you bought seems like a very good one and a bargain and you would have no bother selling it I reckon, so you maybe should sell it and buy any sport manual E39, you’d like it more. It still won't feel as raw an E34 but will be a very nice car to drive and own and I think a better car than an E34. All IMHO of course!
The E34 does feel a bit lighter or possibly slightly sportier, its more old school feel to it – but its not as if the E34 – well a 518i as opposed to an E34 M5 – whilst a very nice driving car would be the most soulful car ever, like say an E30 M3 or even 325i Sport or whatever
It’s the same with an E36 compare to E46 – when the E46 came out the consensus was its better than an E36 but E36 a bit better to drive. But now when driving them the E36 feel old while the E46 feels a lot better, not as light footed but nicer to driver overall, exact same with E90, when it came out people complained about it being not a sporty as E46 but it is a better car in most ways and I think better to drive too.
I do think the fact your E39 is auto would make a big difference; I have a manual – drove autos and manual before plumping for the manual as I liked it much more
The car you bought seems like a very good one and a bargain and you would have no bother selling it I reckon, so you maybe should sell it and buy any sport manual E39, you’d like it more. It still won't feel as raw an E34 but will be a very nice car to drive and own and I think a better car than an E34. All IMHO of course!
Well I have the 34 back and I still prefer driving it, and the 39 has just become uneconmical to sell thanks to the polava that went on earlier the not being able to turn it off melarky, £440 having new barrel and some other bits done.
I wont be using hte 39 that much as insurance on it is a bugger and getting insurance for me means I have to try and get added to a policy, so the old man will use it mostly which is fine, by all means a cracking car and wouldn't sell it, but I have come to the conclusion it is far too big, inside and out and just not as "sporty" as the 518i E34 Tourer, if a 518i Tourer can be classed as sporty...
I am just gutted though
I just hope that when the E60 hits my budget I will enjoy one of those.
I wont be using hte 39 that much as insurance on it is a bugger and getting insurance for me means I have to try and get added to a policy, so the old man will use it mostly which is fine, by all means a cracking car and wouldn't sell it, but I have come to the conclusion it is far too big, inside and out and just not as "sporty" as the 518i E34 Tourer, if a 518i Tourer can be classed as sporty...
I am just gutted though
I just hope that when the E60 hits my budget I will enjoy one of those.An E60 will be bigger and heavier again. I considered changing to one of those myself a while back but its a massive car and I don't need the space. Not dissin the E60 but lots of people prefer the E39 to E60's. And when they are really rock bottom prices with super high miles they will be very expensive to maintain and might not be a wise buy - lots of stuff to go wrong in them. My mechanic always has them in getting stuff fixed on them. An E90 3 series might be a better bet as they are near as big as an E39 but a sportier drive.
I am thinking of chopping my E39 in for a 130i M sport, I want a hot hatch but have gotten to used to the high quality of the E39 so its probably what I'm gonna buy next, just haven't found the right one at the right money yet
I am thinking of chopping my E39 in for a 130i M sport, I want a hot hatch but have gotten to used to the high quality of the E39 so its probably what I'm gonna buy next, just haven't found the right one at the right money yet
Also, as a side point, a mate has an E60 M5 and previously had an E39 M5 - I know these are the M Power versions - but he says the E60 is too big etc to hussle down a road. Whereas the E39 was not that big in comparison and a bit more forgiving and you could drive the she-ite outta it, broadside everywhere and great fun, but the E60 too big and too powerful which makes it intimidating to hussle. He loves the mental pace of the E60 but is thinking of selling up and buying another E39 as he liked it more.
yet to drive an E39 but have done about 1500 miles or so in a 1990 E34 535i manual SE which was fully spec except leather (air con, cruise control, electric memory seats, trip computer etc) and fell in love with it for all it was worth. truly spanked my E21 in every respect, however, ironically, i felt the E34 lacked soul compared to my much slower, much older E21. this 535i had 227k on the clock and was still going fine, all electrics worked too.
lovely car and was tempted to buy it. in 2 weeks i did 1000 miles in it and it was faultless.
a shame this thread, as the E39 has always been on of my favourite BMWs ever.
lovely car and was tempted to buy it. in 2 weeks i did 1000 miles in it and it was faultless.
a shame this thread, as the E39 has always been on of my favourite BMWs ever.
It just goes to show,
everyone has different views and experiences of the same examples of each car. Add to that, you 'could' drive a real gem of an example or a real dog of one and have skewed views as a result.
I remember just prior to driving, some older friends had E21 323i's and E24 635CSi, the 323i was great and I remember then going in other friends Renault 5 GTTurbo's, Fiat Uno Turbo's, Ford Orions, Capri's, Astra's and Nova's etc etc which were all a bit newer and thinking they were rubbish compared to the BMW!
The buying public is now used to even bread and butter cars being quiet and comfortable, so the luxurious end of the market is even more hushed and refined. The older BMW's now have words such as aggressive, raw, edgy, character, soulful, entertaining often associated with them, and the newer stuff has words like hushed, unfussy, smooth, refined, muted, subdued powerful etc.
Remember how the Porsche 911 was on many of our bedroom walls as a kid? perhaps 11+ years ago, I had a left hand drive 911 (993) in my list of cars to potentially buy and I remember sitting in those and thinking wow! fast forward to last year and a friend has a 94/95 model C2 and visually it looks great, then I clambered in and was disappointed! it really is 80's and whilst I bet on the move it's great, I'm not such a fan anymore. I think this is perhaps what's happened with the OP and the E39!
Great to see other's views and experiences and thoughts though!
Cheers, Dennis!
everyone has different views and experiences of the same examples of each car. Add to that, you 'could' drive a real gem of an example or a real dog of one and have skewed views as a result.
I remember just prior to driving, some older friends had E21 323i's and E24 635CSi, the 323i was great and I remember then going in other friends Renault 5 GTTurbo's, Fiat Uno Turbo's, Ford Orions, Capri's, Astra's and Nova's etc etc which were all a bit newer and thinking they were rubbish compared to the BMW!
The buying public is now used to even bread and butter cars being quiet and comfortable, so the luxurious end of the market is even more hushed and refined. The older BMW's now have words such as aggressive, raw, edgy, character, soulful, entertaining often associated with them, and the newer stuff has words like hushed, unfussy, smooth, refined, muted, subdued powerful etc.
Remember how the Porsche 911 was on many of our bedroom walls as a kid? perhaps 11+ years ago, I had a left hand drive 911 (993) in my list of cars to potentially buy and I remember sitting in those and thinking wow! fast forward to last year and a friend has a 94/95 model C2 and visually it looks great, then I clambered in and was disappointed! it really is 80's and whilst I bet on the move it's great, I'm not such a fan anymore. I think this is perhaps what's happened with the OP and the E39!
Great to see other's views and experiences and thoughts though!
Cheers, Dennis!
E21_Ross said:
yet to drive an E39 but have done about 1500 miles or so in a 1990 E34 535i manual SE which was fully spec except leather (air con, cruise control, electric memory seats, trip computer etc) and fell in love with it for all it was worth. truly spanked my E21 in every respect, however, ironically, i felt the E34 lacked soul compared to my much slower, much older E21. this 535i had 227k on the clock and was still going fine, all electrics worked too.
lovely car and was tempted to buy it. in 2 weeks i did 1000 miles in it and it was faultless.
a shame this thread, as the E39 has always been on of my favourite BMWs ever.
I wouldnt be too worried about this thread tbh, one thread doesnt make the E39 a bad car!!! ;-)lovely car and was tempted to buy it. in 2 weeks i did 1000 miles in it and it was faultless.
a shame this thread, as the E39 has always been on of my favourite BMWs ever.
My E39 is a diesel - but I got a test driver in a 540i [Sport & the essential manual box] - with a performance pipe - it was real nice to drive, fast, nice handling and sounded great. I never drove an E34 535i but was a passenger in one but I would prefer the E39 540i to the E35 535i from driving one and passengering the other. Both be as cheap as chips now too
It's an interesting discusion that ultimately comes down to personal prefs/biases etc.
I'm into my 3rd year running an E34 540 - not that I'm sure I really intended to, I'd always just liked the E34 design, finally bought one - and for all its minor asides I really have not found anything else yet to replace it with.
The comparison with the E39 is interseting. Over the last 2yrs I've had plenty of ops to play with a close mate's E39 540T. In and of itself - it was a very lovely thing; a car that makes it just so easy to cover vast amounts of ground at high speed, totally competent, etc... but somewhere along the way I've always preferred the slightly-less-polished but engaging old E34. To the extent - I could just buy an E39/e60 M5 if I wanted, but after trying ... I really, really just dont. I kept the E34 and bought a secondary (smaller/ even faster) toy instead.
I'm into my 3rd year running an E34 540 - not that I'm sure I really intended to, I'd always just liked the E34 design, finally bought one - and for all its minor asides I really have not found anything else yet to replace it with.
The comparison with the E39 is interseting. Over the last 2yrs I've had plenty of ops to play with a close mate's E39 540T. In and of itself - it was a very lovely thing; a car that makes it just so easy to cover vast amounts of ground at high speed, totally competent, etc... but somewhere along the way I've always preferred the slightly-less-polished but engaging old E34. To the extent - I could just buy an E39/e60 M5 if I wanted, but after trying ... I really, really just dont. I kept the E34 and bought a secondary (smaller/ even faster) toy instead.
Huff said:
It's an interesting discusion that ultimately comes down to personal prefs/biases etc.
I'm into my 3rd year running an E34 540 - not that I'm sure I really intended to, I'd always just liked the E34 design, finally bought one - and for all its minor asides I really have not found anything else yet to replace it with.
The comparison with the E39 is interseting. Over the last 2yrs I've had plenty of ops to play with a close mate's E39 540T. In and of itself - it was a very lovely thing; a car that makes it just so easy to cover vast amounts of ground at high speed, totally competent, etc... but somewhere along the way I've always preferred the slightly-less-polished but engaging old E34. To the extent - I could just buy an E39/e60 M5 if I wanted, but after trying ... I really, really just dont. I kept the E34 and bought a secondary (smaller/ even faster) toy instead.
to be fair, the E34 540 isn't going to be slow at covering large distances I'm into my 3rd year running an E34 540 - not that I'm sure I really intended to, I'd always just liked the E34 design, finally bought one - and for all its minor asides I really have not found anything else yet to replace it with.
The comparison with the E39 is interseting. Over the last 2yrs I've had plenty of ops to play with a close mate's E39 540T. In and of itself - it was a very lovely thing; a car that makes it just so easy to cover vast amounts of ground at high speed, totally competent, etc... but somewhere along the way I've always preferred the slightly-less-polished but engaging old E34. To the extent - I could just buy an E39/e60 M5 if I wanted, but after trying ... I really, really just dont. I kept the E34 and bought a secondary (smaller/ even faster) toy instead.

the 535i manual i drove (with the M30 straight 6) would happily sit at north of 100mph all day long. in the UK at least, i suspect they'd be little difference between many very fast cars and that 535i unless you really risk your license to be honest. the fuel bill of that big 6 wasn't great though

the main difference i guess would be on single lane A roads where the extra overtaking ability of faster metal would help, but again, the 535i isn't "quick" compared to many of the faster cars i've been in, but it's no real slouch. i think the main of the character i felt from the car was the fact it had such high miles and was still fine. i thought it quite funny. i knew it had lived a hard life (it's a courtesy car for a classic BMW indy garage!!) and yet it still pulled like a train!
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


