Bore/engine inspections in London/M25 area?
Bore/engine inspections in London/M25 area?
Author
Discussion

R Soul

Original Poster:

123 posts

196 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Any recommendations on where to get a decent borescope/boroscope engine inspection in, or near-ish, London?

I'd like to put my mind at rest, or otherwise, with any potential impending engine woes instead of just crossing my fingers!


Martian O

2,734 posts

193 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
About 30 mins from the M25: www.psrautomotive.com

fergus

6,430 posts

306 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Why not just get aleakdown test done? Are you looking for cracked liners?

R Soul

Original Poster:

123 posts

196 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Martian O thanks but was hoping for something closer preferably.

Fergus that sounds like a great test to have done - thanks for that.

I wanted to know if I've got scored bores (err the car actually) and if so to what extent, plus I guessed it'd give a fair insight into the condition of the cylinders and piston crowns, which is why I've been thinking of having the motor 'scoped. Having read so much about 986/987/996/997 engines having bore-related issues I wanted to see what mine were like, and if any problems were found, to get it sorted out - it's covered with an OPC warranty so wanted some insight (no pun intended) before booking it in for its next service.

Leak-down test sounds like an ideal thing to get done along with a cylinders inspection.

Sound fair enough?

fergus

6,430 posts

306 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Be aware that depending on the rod angle that a 911 uses combined with how short the piston skirts are may leave a much more prominant mark on the thrust side of the cylinder. Leave the inspection of the cylinder liners to someone who's seen a lot of them, otherwise you may misread what you see. Good luck.

s_mcneil

1,009 posts

226 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Porsche West Byfleet, 10 minutes from M25.

Gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
we can do this PM if your stuck.
(leakdown wont suffice)
G

R Soul

Original Poster:

123 posts

196 months

Sunday 17th July 2011
quotequote all
Yes I'd definitely like to get the car looked at by someone experienced with these engines and a bore inspection + a leak-down test currently seem like a good starting point.

Does Porsche West Byfleet do borescope inspections? (I ask as I've read so many threads where OPCs seem to have stripped engines for an initial examination)

I'd like some hard facts as to what's going on with my engine and have been concerned about getting fobbed of with the "they all do that Sir" and "it's normal" - which is the response I've had from an OPC so far.

My engine makes a 'ticking' sound at idle (often but not always) and can use up to around a litre of Mobil-1 every 500 or so miles. According to the owners manual this level of oil consumption is considered normal, however I've read of many users posting that their cars use little or no oil and my personal feeling is that this is unreasonably high oil consumption.

So my guess (and it is a guess) is that 'something' is causing this level of oil consumption, and 'something' is causing the ticking noise and that maybe these two 'somethings' could be related?

So I'm looking for a, hopefully, reliable and knowledgeable Porsche specialist (OPC or Indy) that will actually look at what may be going on as I'm feeling a little fobbed-off and suspicious with the "it's normal" response I've received so far.

Perhaps it is normal, perhaps it's indicative of a major or minor problem, either way I want some checks carried out to know so that I can either put my mind at rest or get any problems resolved.

Any help, pointers, tips or advice greatly appreciated!

@Gary11 - what do you mean we can do this PM??

Gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Sunday 17th July 2011
quotequote all
Gary11 said:
R Soul said:
Yes I'd definitely like to get the car looked at by someone experienced with these engines and a bore inspection + a leak-down test currently seem like a good starting point.

Does Porsche West Byfleet do borescope inspections? (I ask as I've read so many threads where OPCs seem to have stripped engines for an initial examination)

I'd like some hard facts as to what's going on with my engine and have been concerned about getting fobbed of with the "they all do that Sir" and "it's normal" - which is the response I've had from an OPC so far.

My engine makes a 'ticking' sound at idle (often but not always) and can use up to around a litre of Mobil-1 every 500 or so miles. According to the owners manual this level of oil consumption is considered normal, however I've read of many users posting that their cars use little or no oil and my personal feeling is that this is unreasonably high oil consumption.

So my guess (and it is a guess) is that 'something' is causing this level of oil consumption, and 'something' is causing the ticking noise and that maybe these two 'somethings' could be related?

So I'm looking for a, hopefully, reliable and knowledgeable Porsche specialist (OPC or Indy) that will actually look at what may be going on as I'm feeling a little fobbed-off and suspicious with the "it's normal" response I've received so far.

Perhaps it is normal, perhaps it's indicative of a major or minor problem, either way I want some checks carried out to know so that I can either put my mind at rest or get any problems resolved.

Any help, pointers, tips or advice greatly appreciated!

@Gary11 - what do you mean we can do this PM??
I meant if you email me ill help with the boroscope if I can,your problems are typical of early symtoms of bore scoring IE ticking noise and oil consumption,I would do as few miles as possible and get some one to investigate for you.Its much cheaper to do now rather than keep driving and cause more internal engine damage.

R Soul

Original Poster:

123 posts

196 months

Monday 18th July 2011
quotequote all
Gary11 said:
I meant if you email me ill help with the boroscope if I can,your problems are typical of early symtoms of bore scoring IE ticking noise and oil consumption,I would do as few miles as possible and get some one to investigate for you.Its much cheaper to do now rather than keep driving and cause more internal engine damage.
Thanks for the advice, yes the bore(s) being scrap is what I was concerned about, but I was hoping to get someone who could do further tests (like the leak-down test fergus mentioned) should the bores actually be OK - a one-stop shop sort of thing.

Gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Monday 18th July 2011
quotequote all
R Soul said:
Thanks for the advice, yes the bore(s) being scrap is what I was concerned about, but I was hoping to get someone who could do further tests (like the leak-down test fergus mentioned) should the bores actually be OK - a one-stop shop sort of thing.
OK we are quite busy in workshops but if your stuck let me know,autostrasse may be able to help in coggeshall.
G

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Monday 18th July 2011
quotequote all
R Soul said:
My engine makes a 'ticking' sound at idle (often but not always) and can use up to around a litre of Mobil-1 every 500 or so miles. According to the owners manual this level of oil consumption is considered normal, however I've read of many users posting that their cars use little or no oil and my personal feeling is that this is unreasonably high oil consumption.

So my guess (and it is a guess) is that 'something' is causing this level of oil consumption, and 'something' is causing the ticking noise and that maybe these two 'somethings' could be related?
Combined, the symptoms mean you need this getting looked at pronto. Gary's right - drive only to where you can get it diagnosed.

Re my emboldened text - if that were the only symptom, I'd still take the car straight away to get a diagnosis done. That rate of consumption is not acceptable (whatever the manual or any OPC will say).

BertBert

21,355 posts

242 months

Monday 18th July 2011
quotequote all
GT-One in Chertsey?

R Soul

Original Poster:

123 posts

196 months

Monday 18th July 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies! It's now booked in to an OPC who state they can scope the cylinders, and if OK perform a pressure test.

Am pretty happy with this route (the car is covered with a Porsche warranty) as it requires a service soon anyway - should the motor not be scrap!

Thanks again for everyones input!

R Soul

Original Poster:

123 posts

196 months

Monday 18th July 2011
quotequote all
coanda said:
Could you let us know how you get on with the scoping please?....And please can you try and get pictures and pressure values out of the opc?. I think it is a good idea to keep a record of these things.
Yes will do, it'll give us all some idea at least - hopefully!

Gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Monday 18th July 2011
quotequote all
We have just purchased a new scope with the facility to photograph and video the bores enabling clips and stills to be sent by email immediately rather than a verbal report!
G

R Soul

Original Poster:

123 posts

196 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
OK so I got a borescope done at an OPC and it showed oil droplets on cylinder six's liner - the following pics are reputedly just cylinder six, the last photo shows the oil:









Regards the pressure tests, unforutnately, I wasn't given the readings despite asking however I was informed that "the pressures seemed OK".

The engine was stripped, new crankcases (cylinder blocks), all new piston rings, all new big-end bearing shells, one new piston (cylinder six), one new conrod (cylinder six), and all new bolts etc. Additionally I paid extra (about 500quid) for all new main bearings and crankshaft cradle bolts. I was told that all engine components were stripped, cleaned, and checked.

On collecting the car I asked to see piston six:



I was shocked at how scored this piston was yet the OPC informed me they had seen much worse yikes

Amazing that the piston was that scored (and just take a look at the dents/grooves in the rings) yet the only outward signs of any problem was a slight ticking noise at idle and high oil consumption.

Apologies for the brevity as I'm a bit busy today, will update the reliability thread later.

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
Absolutely shocking! yikes Your oil consumption was IMO astronomical, and here's the evidence indeed.

Please remind/tell us, what was the mileage recorded?

I continue to maintain that oil consumption is not a symptom of an engine running okay. I've only ever had one car with oil consumption, and that had been caused by head/gasket damage done by a dealership (in my much more naive than now student days).

Good luck. I recommend you run the engine in properly (with 1k and 3k milestones - don't exceed 4k before 1k miles, and load gently, watch your oil temp, etc). Or just ask Baz! smile

nickfrog

25,491 posts

248 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
Sorry OP, but car/engine is this ?

Gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
The piston skirt seems so deep perhaps is the angle of the shot.also I note the scoring is over the entire depth of the piston skirt right up to the rings.
G
are there any shots of the bore? was it honed or bored? if so is the new piston oversized?

Edited by Gary11 on Tuesday 23 August 23:13