Wheel Balancing - 996 Turbo
Wheel Balancing - 996 Turbo
Author
Discussion

stubbsy996

Original Poster:

785 posts

244 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
Car failed it's MOT this week, (the shame & embarrasment!), on front n/s tyre inside edge below legal limit + advisory on o/s front for same problem. Two new front tyres fitted this morning resulting in MOT pass smile Annual service booked this week + 4 wheel alignment at Autostasse.
However, they had problems balancing the front wheels. What should have been 1/2 hour job tooj most of this morning! At first they thoght it was the balancing machine playing up, so they took it to another wheel place. They ended up balancing the wheels, (which are true/no buckling etc.), with 120g weights on one side and 280g on the other! Doesn't look too pretty. Tyre dealer said he'd never come across such an excessive weighting before and couldn't say why.

Anyone else had this and if so what did they reckon is the cause?

Is the weighting excessive and do I have a problem?

Wheels are 18" standard turbo hollows fitted with Continental Sport Contact N2's and tyres are standard 225/40 front and 295/30 rear.

Edited by stubbsy996 on Saturday 23 July 14:04

BertBert

21,353 posts

242 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
Assuming the previous tyres didn't need such weights, that points towards a tyre (imbalance) problem surely?
Bert

A2MVS

40 posts

218 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
I had exactly the same problem and the tyres were to blame for causing the imbalance.

stubbsy996

Original Poster:

785 posts

244 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
A2MVS said:
I had exactly the same problem and the tyres were to blame for causing the imbalance.
Thanks. Did you do anything to remedy the problem, or just have the tyres with the additional weights to balance it up?

Lemans Party

558 posts

186 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
Yikes! Not sure I'd be happy with over a quarter kilogram whizzing around when doing 150mph+.
If that got loose, it would go through the wing!

Martian O

2,734 posts

193 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
I'd take the tyres back and ask for replacements, they obviously seem faulty.

NickUSA

812 posts

198 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
.... or at least have the tyres remounted on the rim but rotated through 180 degrees.

m996tt

407 posts

242 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
NickUSA said:
.... or at least have the tyres remounted on the rim but rotated through 180 degrees.
Then put the weights on the other side spin

GreigM

6,740 posts

280 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
NickUSA said:
.... or at least have the tyres remounted on the rim but rotated through 180 degrees.
this, they need to rotate the tyre on the rim until it balances better.....it always amazes me that so many tyre fitters are unaware of this basic solution

A2MVS

40 posts

218 months

Saturday 23rd July 2011
quotequote all
If Nick's suggestion doesn't work send the tyres back. You shoudn't need more than 10-20g of balancing weight per side.

Lemans Party

558 posts

186 months

Sunday 24th July 2011
quotequote all
Here's a suggestion... take the tyres off and check how much balancing the wheels would need on their own.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Sunday 24th July 2011
quotequote all
OE tyres that need more than 2 x 60g weights are rejected and that is rarely.

Unless you have a damaged rim, which will show up if you spin up the rim on its own, the rims will not be significantly out and it is most likely you have some poor tyres, unless there is something on the centre of your rims preventing them from being mounted properly.

Whatever, something is wrong. There is no way any self respecting tyre fitter would send a car off with tht much weight.

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Monday 25th July 2011
quotequote all
NickUSA said:
.... or at least have the tyres remounted on the rim but rotated through 180 degrees.
But would that not just shift the problem to another point on the wheel?


(assuming the wheels are generally OK, which is probably a fair assumption if the last set of tyres didn't need so much balancing weight)

stubbsy996

Original Poster:

785 posts

244 months

Monday 25th July 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for all your advice fellas!
Having taken all your comments on board spoke this morning to the manager at the garage where new tyres were fitted. He is confident that there was no problem with tyres. He thinks there may be a problem with one of the alloys being heavier than the other because there were a large amount of weights on one side when they took the wheels off to fit the new tyres. He also says he's confident that they are safe for "normal" driving! Suggested I buy and fit one new alloy which he reckons will cure the problem!!
I'm still not happy and the weights look so bloody ugly but as it's booked into Autostrasse this Friday for annual service + wheel alignment I think I'll wait till then and get the Porsche experts advice?

Edited by stubbsy996 on Monday 25th July 13:25

AshleyPatience

286 posts

206 months

Monday 25th July 2011
quotequote all
I also had this problem after fitting new tyres; I had a significant vibration from 90mph+ that got practically unbearable above 120mph.

Had them re-balanced twice but problem remained.

Took the car to NE and Ken used a local specialist to sort it out. Wasn't as cheap as a Kwik-Fit balance but car is now fine.

As you say, wait until a specialist has reviewed but as said above 280g rotating at 150mph is a recipe for disaster!

zeb

3,297 posts

249 months

Monday 25th July 2011
quotequote all
I would stubbsy, thats an awful lot of weight on one wheel. For comparison sake mine is 10 on each

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
stubbsy996 said:
Thanks for all your advice fellas!
Having taken all your comments on board spoke this morning to the manager at the garage where new tyres were fitted. He is confident that there was no problem with tyres. He thinks there may be a problem with one of the alloys being heavier than the other because there were a large amount of weights on one side when they took the wheels off to fit the new tyres. He also says he's confident that they are safe for "normal" driving! Suggested I buy and fit one new alloy which he reckons will cure the problem!!
I'm still not happy and the weights look so bloody ugly but as it's booked into Autostrasse this Friday for annual service + wheel alignment I think I'll wait till then and get the Porsche experts advice?

Edited by stubbsy996 on Monday 25th July 13:25
Did they try the suggestion above, re the balancing the wheel on its own?

stubbsy996

Original Poster:

785 posts

244 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
stubbsy996 said:
Thanks for all your advice fellas!
Having taken all your comments on board spoke this morning to the manager at the garage where new tyres were fitted. He is confident that there was no problem with tyres. He thinks there may be a problem with one of the alloys being heavier than the other because there were a large amount of weights on one side when they took the wheels off to fit the new tyres. He also says he's confident that they are safe for "normal" driving! Suggested I buy and fit one new alloy which he reckons will cure the problem!!
I'm still not happy and the weights look so bloody ugly but as it's booked into Autostrasse this Friday for annual service + wheel alignment I think I'll wait till then and get the Porsche experts advice?

Edited by stubbsy996 on Monday 25th July 13:25
Update:

Spoke to Ken at Autostasse yesterday and he said he hadn't come across this problem with Porsche wheels/tyres before.

Wheels are genuine Porsche and I'm sure if they were not fully kosher in the first place Porsche would have rejected them.

Having lost confidence in the garage that fitted the tyres, took the car in to a local tyre specialist this morning for a second opinion. Having explained the problem got them to check it out & re-balance the wheels.
They found no problems with the tyres but there is definitely some sort of problem with the wheels. Although they are not buckled, no signs of damage & no paint overspray on the hub faces they still had problems balancing, and I watched em this time! They did rotate them through 180 degrees, as suggested, but still ended up with I think it was 220g on one side & 160g on the other.
The only thing they can think it can be is when the wheels were re-furbed, if they were sprayed by hand, the paint coating is uneven depth.
However, they have assured me that even though the wheel weighting seems excessive the wheels are balanced and it's perfectly safe!

Having re-fitted the wheels had an alignment done. Gave the car a blast this morning and drives fine, no vibration at all at speeds up to ?smile

Anyway, seems I've probably got 3 options viz:
1) Stick with what I've got.
2) Buy two second hand ones (no guarantee I won't be buying similar problem.
3) Buy two brand new ones (ouch - probably £1k a corner!)

Think I'll stick with option 1 for time being, given that car drives perfectly!

Anybody has anything else to offer please feel free!
On the whole constructive responses from the Porsche PH massive. Cheers guys!
(Also tried on a certain US site but all I got was 1 response! smile)

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
a quarter kilo of paint???

yikes

steve singh

3,995 posts

204 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Bloody hell that's a lot of weight - sounds like a poor refurb or alloys which are not genuine?

Have you checked the stamps on the inside of the alloy to ensure they're authentic?