Weekend Porsche: 928 or 944?
Weekend Porsche: 928 or 944?
Author
Discussion

Seeker UK

Original Poster:

1,443 posts

189 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
I've always fancied a Porsche, just not as a daily driver.....but I'm in the fortunate position of being able to afford and house one as a weekend toy. bounce

My budget is £6k and looking at the classifieds, that can get me a 928 or 968 and I'm not sure what to go for. I appreciate the 944 is a different beastie to a 928 in terms of drive and I've still to test drive both to make that decision.

Firstly, 944. If I buy a 944, I can get one for well under budget and hold the rest back for repairs it will invariably need (being at least 20 yrs old). S2 is the obvious choice but are the other models that bad? Turbos are bang on budget but that leaves little for repair - are they any more to maintain than an S2?

928. Like the 944 turbo, not a lot left in the budget for fixes if I get one. Apart from the shed that they had on Top Gear, are sub £5k 928s more trouble than they're worth? Are there easier models to live with than others (ie more reliable / cheaper)?

Are any models easier to do 'small' DIY repairs on than others? I suspect a 928 doesn't have alot of room in the engine bay to work in..

Thanks in advance for any advice.

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
944 gets my vote!

Ray Singh

3,084 posts

261 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
All depends on what your running cost budget is.
928 mainly came as autos. Manual ones are rarer. These will be expensive to run fuel wise compared to a 944/968. The engines are double the size.

968s are very nice and more modern than the 944 and 928 (in your budget). The bargain at the moment is the 944 S2. This is basically a 968 (without variocam and 6 spd box) and can be had for way under your budget.
Independent servicing can be fairly cost effective too. Make sure you check the sills and bottoms of front wings for any signs of rust.





anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
having had an S2 and currently a 968 cs (but lusting for a 928 gts manual) i would say you are bang on in your assessment and the s2 is where i would put my money without question

just do your diligence esp on bodywork and enjoy it

Seeker UK

Original Poster:

1,443 posts

189 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
What about a 2.7?

Many of these on the face of it seem to be a good price and many seem to be extremely well cared for. Better than some S2s TBH.

shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
At £6k I'd be looking for a good 944S2 or one of the best 944 2.7s on the market rather than a 'cheap' 968, 944t or 928.

Each of the latter three can suck up thousands in maintence very easily, but a good 944 will still give you lot of pleasure with a much reduced risk of financial heartache.

SS7

barchetta_boy

2,515 posts

263 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
I'd take a careful look at this car

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2779126.htm

Looks stunning and from the ad, has been well maintained. GT One look after my cars and are superb. If it has had £5.5k spent there then all of your major worries are covered.

The 928, in my biased view, has five times the presence of the '44, fine car though that is. All old Porsches can cost you a lot. Personally I think the differences between models are overstated. At this age and price bracket, condition is far more important.

See if you can drive a couple. There is no way I could have bought a 944 having experienced the noise and thrust of the 928's V8.

Joel

Robbo101

180 posts

187 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Must be something in the air today (see my thread on 944 cabriolets v Boxsters).

OP, have you thought about a Boxster or doesnt that float your boat ?

Seeker UK

Original Poster:

1,443 posts

189 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Robbo101 said:
OP, have you thought about a Boxster or doesnt that float your boat ?
I have considered a Boxster and even gone as far as test driving a couple but even a 10 minute test drive cripples me. I'm hoping a 944/928 have better seats.

kamilb1998

2,221 posts

208 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
I'd go for a late & sorted 944.

stratfordshark

111 posts

214 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Funny you should ask that...

http://forums.rennlist.com/rennforums/928-forum/63...

To summarise a 4 page thread - and my personal opinion - both great cars, but chalk and cheese. Drive and decide!

Edited by stratfordshark on Tuesday 26th July 15:07

danielw

210 posts

279 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Remember that a 928 engine is two 944 engines in a V smile

I had a 944S2 (3 litre 4 cylinder) followed by a 928GT (5 litre 8 cylinder). There was no comparison and there could be no going back to a 944. I suspect that those that favour a 928 over a 944 have never lived with both.

928's are slightly bigger and heavier, but are more car in every way.

Obviously a tuned 944 turbo would be a different proposition from an old 928 auto, but it really depends what you want from your weekend car experience.

My 928 was always an experience - the 944 was always efficient.

Jon951

257 posts

218 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Very different cars so it depends what you want from a weekend toy. Have long lusted after a 928 but a couple of years ago test drove an auto S4 having stepped out of my modded 944 turbo and must admit I was a bit underwhelmed by the experience. That said I would prefer the 928 over the 944S2 if my budget could cope.

Still hanker after a 928 one day though...


barchetta_boy

2,515 posts

263 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
It just goes to show how little understood the 928 is that people can even think about not picking one over a 944.

It was Porsche's flagship car for heaven's sake, the first-ever clean sheet design by the company, superb all-alloy V8 that will run for 200k with no need of a rebuild, totally new suspension design (later carried over to the 911 but not until the 993) double wishbones all round, 50-50 weight balance, huge torque (even the 1980 S boasts 295 ft/lb, same as a 996 GT3), unrivalled stability, great performance.

The sad thing is that most of them are rather sorry now, but hey the same goes for all old classics that are worth less than 100 hours time at the local specialist.

944s, great cars, but which would you have, a 1970 911 2.2S or a 912?

NJH

3,021 posts

240 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Have to admit that as a weekend road car, probably a GT the 928 would be more of interest to me but that is probably because I have owned 944/968 for so long. If your going to take it on track the 944/968 makes much more sense, if your going to commute in it again the 4 pot cars make more sense but for a weekend car I just don't think any of the 4 pot cars are interesting enough. Its the engine you see even in the 968 which has the sweetest motor of the lot its efficient rather than kick in the back shove and the sound is OK to fairly nice rather than putting the hairs up on your neck stuff.

Seeker UK

Original Poster:

1,443 posts

189 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Well went and had a look at a 928S for sale locally for no other reason than to sitin one and see whether I liked it. It sort of reminded me of the M6 I had. I was impressed with some of the "features" such as the whole binnacle moving when you adjust the wheel. Also gave me a chance to look one over; see how easy it is to check the sills etc.

I won't be buying that particular one - mechanically it was OK, but needed a few bits of trim / paintwork doing which is something I couldn't do. Also it had my only real "red line" when it comes to buying a car, which is a blue interior.

Now I need to drive one.

Are 928s easy to maintain as a DIY prospect?

Angelus

2,209 posts

195 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
stratfordshark said:
Funny you should ask that...

http://forums.rennlist.com/rennforums/928-forum/63...

To summarise a 4 page thread - and my personal opinion - both great cars, but chalk and cheese. Drive and decide!
^^ This.

They're not the hardest of cars to DIY and a bit daunting when you first look at it, but that's half the fun. There is a lot of help out there from the 928uk community if you want to get stuck in. I had both until a few weeks ago, guess what I still have and which one I sold? How far are you from this one??

-Pete-

2,914 posts

207 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
barchetta_boy said:
I'd take a careful look at this car

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2779126.htm

Looks stunning and from the ad, has been well maintained. GT One look after my cars and are superb. If it has had £5.5k spent there then all of your major worries are covered.
Having asked the same question on here a few years ago, I believe 944's aren't much cheaper to service, so it comes down to petrol costs. The 928 sounds amazing though, especially with a decent exhaust.

I almost bought a 928 S4 manual, but I think that ad shows the problem. If the owner spent £5.5K in the last year it means the car was worth £250 one year ago - and it's unlikely that's what he paid for it.

So maybe the real question is what are the annual running costs? I would allow £2K/year plus tax, insurance and petrol to keep a 928 in good condition, £500 less if you're good at DIY, £1-2K more if you're not.

Edit: And talk to Paul Anderson, mentioned in the rennlist advert - he's the 928 expert.

Edited by -Pete- on Tuesday 26th July 21:49

Seeker UK

Original Poster:

1,443 posts

189 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
Angelus said:
How far are you from this one??
Good question. I can't see a location on the ad.

911sse

191 posts

197 months

Tuesday 26th July 2011
quotequote all
For that money; and I've owned 911, 944, Boxster etc.....

I'd buy the best 1989 944 2.7 lux I could find.

Cheaper to insure, maintain and run than a 944 S2, and a 928 is a different ball game altogether in all those three areas.

However, that is a very nice looking 928 above and I'd be interested in that car, knowing what the runnings costs can be - stingy!

Edited by 911sse on Tuesday 26th July 22:42