How would this scam work?
How would this scam work?
Author
Discussion

belfry

Original Poster:

1,081 posts

213 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
My 997 is up for sale on Pistonheads classified.

Almost immediately I had a call from a man who wanted to know what was the lowest price that I'd take. I said that I didn't have a set price in mind and that I was going to sell to the person who made the highest offer.

"Would you take £32k?"
"No."
"£33k?"
"Look, why don't you come and have a look at the car?"
"I'll give you £33k. I can transfer £33k into your bank now. Then my mate will come down and collect it once you've got the money in your ."

I am aware that it is possible for electronic transfers to be retracted after a few days. So, if I was to move the £33k to another bank account with another bank, would I still be at risk?

The whole scenario seems a little strange but I am interested to understand the theory behind these potential scams.

Diesel130

1,549 posts

243 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I don't remember the details exactly, but wasn't there a scam where they deposit a cheque, but with the paying in reference set to "CHAPS", so when you look quickly at your bank accont on-line, it isn't a real chaps payment. You give them the car, then the cheque bounced... or something like that. I guess you wouldn't be able to transfer the money to another account until the payment cleared.

Martian O

2,734 posts

193 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
If it sounds too good to be true...........

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
How much is the car advertised for? The guy could be for real? (Not suggesting you take risks, but stranger things have happened).

JBL930

1,837 posts

247 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
It was fake bankers drafts, it would show as cleared until the bank realised it and then the money disappeared..... Just ask your bank how long it would take for the transfer to be absolutely clear with no chance of it being retracted, then pass on the info to him, if he seams ok with it then fine.... If it all goes quiet then you have your answer

stuttgartmetal

8,167 posts

247 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
If he's genuine, he'll turn up and look.
Unless he's a trader just getting stock, and even then he must be a big player just to buy cars unseen.
Get a landline number, suss him out more, string him along for more info, but treat him like a scammer until its sold.

madala

5,063 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
...sniffs like something rotten to me.....but there again I trust no 'fecker.

RedSpiseeBalls

441 posts

190 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
belfry said:
a man who wanted to know what was the lowest price that I'd take
Probably is a scam...

but surely the incentive for a quick sale and thus the scam to work would be if he 'paid' over the top, not the minimum

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
belfry said:
I can transfer £33k into your bank now. Then my mate will come down and collect it once you've got the money in your ."

I am aware that it is possible for electronic transfers to be retracted after a few days. So, if I was to move the £33k to another bank account with another bank, would I still be at risk?
I don't think an electronic tranfer can be reversed - it's a massive problem if you get one wrong and send money to the wrong account as the person has to pay it back.

However what you were told is just an opening gambit to get you hooked. They'll say they can't do the transfer so will pay by bankers draft and / or the guy can't collect it so they'll overpay you and ask you to pay a shipping company (via a western union account).

If you do accept money into your account, say from a forged draft, and it bounces, the bank will still come after you for the money even if you wothdraw it.

carcrazypop

579 posts

195 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
Probably worth speaking to your bank; I thought electronic transfers were pretty safe, but certainly worth checking first.

oldcynic

2,166 posts

192 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
However what you were told is just an opening gambit to get you hooked. They'll say they can't do the transfer so will pay by bankers draft and / or the guy can't collect it so they'll overpay you and ask you to pay a shipping company (via a western union account).
Sounds about right - they'll pay you by Western Union or similar, you pay the shipping for your car to be stolen. Car will be out of the country before you realise what's happened.

AndyT955

112 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I agree most of these sound like a scam, but I advertised a car and did a deal on the phone within an hour they came to collect it and transfered the money whilst they were there, they were dealers and had no problems, although it is unusual.

Jobbo

13,921 posts

295 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
carcrazypop said:
Probably worth speaking to your bank; I thought electronic transfers were pretty safe, but certainly worth checking first.
There's more than one sort of electronic transfer - BACS isn't as secure as CHAPS. Only accept the latter.

Still looks like a scam of some sort; why not agree to accept the money into your account then give the buyer a false address for collection wink

Magic919

14,596 posts

232 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
Diesel130 said:
I don't remember the details exactly, but wasn't there a scam where they deposit a cheque, but with the paying in reference set to "CHAPS", so when you look quickly at your bank accont on-line, it isn't a real chaps payment. You give them the car, then the cheque bounced... or something like that. I guess you wouldn't be able to transfer the money to another account until the payment cleared.
This is the version I've heard.

belfry

Original Poster:

1,081 posts

213 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
Jobbo said:
why not agree to accept the money into your account then give the buyer a false address for collection wink
rofl

Manks

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
belfry said:
My 997 is up for sale on Pistonheads classified.

Almost immediately I had a call from a man who wanted to know what was the lowest price that I'd take. I said that I didn't have a set price in mind and that I was going to sell to the person who made the highest offer.

"Would you take £32k?"
"No."
"£33k?"
"Look, why don't you come and have a look at the car?"
"I'll give you £33k. I can transfer £33k into your bank now. Then my mate will come down and collect it once you've got the money in your ."

I am aware that it is possible for electronic transfers to be retracted after a few days. So, if I was to move the £33k to another bank account with another bank, would I still be at risk?

The whole scenario seems a little strange but I am interested to understand the theory behind these potential scams.
At a guess, the "buyer" will pay in a duff cheque and put a reference CHAPS against it. You, he hopes, will not notice that it isn't actually a CHAPS payment and release the car to his chum. A week or so later the cheque is returned unpaid and you have neither the money nor the car.


RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
Ask him for a scanned copy of his passport, driving license and a utility bill in his name. If he is genuine, shouldn't be an issue.

Then take all the precautions mentioned previously about checking the authenticity of the payment.

all2ofme

855 posts

219 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
All good notes on this thread so far.

Much smaller figures to talk about here, but several years ago I sold a laptop for £1800. Chap paid with a bank draft and all was well until 5 weeks later when my bank (Barclays at the time) reversed the credit and took the money out of my account again. Ended up getting £350 back from them after a few letters to the banking ombudsman, but all the same - lesson learnt.

In addition to all the pre-sale checks you'd want to do on a buyer you also want someone's name, extension etc. at the bank telling you the money is cleared and can't be reversed.

I've only lost money once through being overly trusting, but I'd far rather that than a lifetime of trusting nobody smile

Peely

902 posts

250 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
They email nearly every highly priced car advertised on PH !

It is a scam, they transfer a cheque or bank transfer into your account, they contact you a few days later when the money is shown in your account and is in effect 'In your account' !

They then have a representative collect the car.

What a lot of people don't realise is that the transfer takes 6 working days to fully clear, and yes you guessed it, the bank reclaims the money, stating that the cheque or transfer was fraudelent.

Car gone, and you owing £000's stay clear !

chris_w

2,571 posts

290 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I sold our station car a few weeks ago and had a similar call. The guy explained he was 'out of the country' and would have to send a friend to collect the car but would send payment via PayPal. He knew nothing about the car, asking silly questions that anyone who'd read the ad woulnd't have and then appeared to forget the asking price and offered £400 over.

I told him to get lost and hung up but wasn't really sure how the scam worked until a friend (who works for Visa) explained that it's a phishing scam. You provide your PayPal account details so they have your email. A day before they come to collect the car you appear to get an email from PayPal confirming they have recieved the payment but, owing to the amount involved/lack of verification on your account etc they will hold it in escrow until the following following day and they receive confirmation that the sale has been completed. I guess some people get caught up in the story and actually hand their cars over?