Discussion
Hi, new to the Porsche forum on here. I've been tempted by the 911 for a while, and recently had the pleasure of a test drive courtesy of the OPC in Reading, who let me take a 997 C2S with PDK and sports chrono plus package out for a blast. What a car! Simply staggering amounts of speed, acceleration and grip!
I've well and truly got the bug now, but, I'm keen to know if the Gen 2 car is worth saving for over the Gen 1 997? Is the engine a completely different design? Is DFi the key difference?
I'm asking because a Gen1 997 with manual 'box and sports chrono is more within my immediate price range (PDK only on Gen 2 from wha I can tell). Is it worth me saving the extra and waiting a bit longer to get a newer model?
I've well and truly got the bug now, but, I'm keen to know if the Gen 2 car is worth saving for over the Gen 1 997? Is the engine a completely different design? Is DFi the key difference?
I'm asking because a Gen1 997 with manual 'box and sports chrono is more within my immediate price range (PDK only on Gen 2 from wha I can tell). Is it worth me saving the extra and waiting a bit longer to get a newer model?
I think what he means is buy the newest you can afford, all other things being equal. It's just that they seldom are.
I agree with you, ZeroH - I'd find several cars that were good value for what they were and choose from them. A £35k car might be amazing value (a funny colour that I happen to like, for example, or in incredible nick with a heap of motorway miles), whereas a £40k car might be 3 years newer, same spec etc. but in worse condition. I know which one I'd go for. (Hint - I'd have £5k to spend afterwards.)
It's great we're all different though, as there'd be fewer others to bat away with a s
tty stick when I met the seller of the £35k car. I do see the attraction of having a newer car, but there are so many other factors to take into account that it's hardly the first thing I look at. You're buying a whole vehicle, not a MY or number plate.
I agree with you, ZeroH - I'd find several cars that were good value for what they were and choose from them. A £35k car might be amazing value (a funny colour that I happen to like, for example, or in incredible nick with a heap of motorway miles), whereas a £40k car might be 3 years newer, same spec etc. but in worse condition. I know which one I'd go for. (Hint - I'd have £5k to spend afterwards.)
It's great we're all different though, as there'd be fewer others to bat away with a s
tty stick when I met the seller of the £35k car. I do see the attraction of having a newer car, but there are so many other factors to take into account that it's hardly the first thing I look at. You're buying a whole vehicle, not a MY or number plate.banjolucknicker said:
I'm keen to know if the Gen 2 car is worth saving for over the Gen 1 997? Is the engine a completely different design? Is DFi the key difference?
The DFI engines have the potential to be a lot more reliable than the earlier water cooled engines (Except the GT1 blocked GT3's and Turbos of course). Bore scoring, D chunk failure, IMS etc should be a thing of the past. Should!For this reason, I would have thought that the DFI cars are going to be much better buys?
MTR
Dr S said:
If a 7.2 C2S already blew you away then stay clear of GT3s 
Ha! I would gladly have a test, but I have two small children too, so the small seats are a must, hence the C2 or C4's.
A 996 GT3 is a tempting prospect at the prices they are, but sadly not quite practical enough (I did see some sort of rear seat contraption on a GT3 once, but that's like painting a moustache on the Mona Lisa)
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


