Cayman S from E60 M5
Cayman S from E60 M5
Author
Discussion

DocSteve

Original Poster:

731 posts

253 months

Sunday 21st August 2011
quotequote all
Hi,

I was thinking about replacing my E60 M5 with one of these. I'd like something a bit lighter and more fun to drive, and having driven one and read the reviews I think the Cayman S ticks most of the boxes.

I was wondering about the relative costs. The M5 is a heinously expensive beast to run, averaging around 13 - 14mpg with a mixture of back road fun, town and motorways at sensible pace. I was hoping I might nearly half my monthly fuel bill driving one of these - is this realistic?

I'm looking at a new one - the dealer reckons it won't need anything doing until 20k miles (save tyres and perhaps pads/discs). Have owners found them to be fairly reliable, and do they eat through brakes and tyres if driven hard or tracked? I realise any car will do if driven this way but I imagined its lighter weight wouldn't be as hard on components/consumables as my M5 when used in the same manner.

I was thinking of one with the PDK and sport chrono kit, the PDK seems like a revelation coming from the single clutch unit on my M5 and the speed and smoothness of the shifts was genuinely surprising.

Any advice welcome.

Many thanks
Steve

March2008

302 posts

220 months

Sunday 21st August 2011
quotequote all
Hi Steve,

I think you might have a sneaking suspicion already, but the Cayman especially in Gen 2 guise is a great car to run long term, my Gen 1 easily averages 30mpg during normal driving and whilst having a Gen II for a short time, found it much of the same, but even more frugal. I'd suspect that if you like to drive them hard now and again, you should easily average 30mpg.

My car only sees the workshop every 2 years, as I don't manage the 20,000 miles sooner than that. With the PDK, which is a far superior system to the SMG robotised gearbox, you might find yourself using the brakes a bit more than a manual, but not much I wouldn't think. You also benefit from the 7th Gear in the PDK, so that'll give you even greater fuel economy on the longer trips.

Depreciation is the biggest cost in terms of a new Cayman Gen 2, other than that, they are completely painless to own, beautifully built, they ride and steer better than you'd imagine too. Coming from an M5 (was in my brother in laws M5 today), you'll appreciate the ride of the Cayman is much better, it's a fair bit louder in the cabin though, but that's the only downside really! Maybe a Cayman in 18 inch wheels is quieter???

Good luck, and get it bought.





Sideways Rich

1,121 posts

208 months

Sunday 21st August 2011
quotequote all
Making a similar move but in reverse, just selling my Gen 1 Cayman S Sport and have bought an E39 M5 as a daily runner. The Cayman S in Gen 1 or II guise is a brilliant car as a daily runner that can be a fantastic sports car when the mood takes. I racked up 34k miles in 2 and a bit years of ownership and they are surprisingly good value to run with the 20k service intervals and Porsche build quality.

As above, get one bought! smile

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Sunday 21st August 2011
quotequote all
DocSteve said:
Hi,

I was thinking about replacing my E60 M5 with one of these. I'd like something a bit lighter and more fun to drive, and having driven one and read the reviews I think the Cayman S ticks most of the boxes.

I was wondering about the relative costs. The M5 is a heinously expensive beast to run, averaging around 13 - 14mpg with a mixture of back road fun, town and motorways at sensible pace. I was hoping I might nearly half my monthly fuel bill driving one of these - is this realistic?

I'm looking at a new one - the dealer reckons it won't need anything doing until 20k miles (save tyres and perhaps pads/discs). Have owners found them to be fairly reliable, and do they eat through brakes and tyres if driven hard or tracked? I realise any car will do if driven this way but I imagined its lighter weight wouldn't be as hard on components/consumables as my M5 when used in the same manner.

I was thinking of one with the PDK and sport chrono kit, the PDK seems like a revelation coming from the single clutch unit on my M5 and the speed and smoothness of the shifts was genuinely surprising.

Any advice welcome.

Many thanks
Steve
looks like you are looking for fun???

one word - begins with S and ends in PYDER!

PDK + Sport Chrono = amazzzzzing experience!

cpufreak

478 posts

239 months

Sunday 21st August 2011
quotequote all
if buying new, depending on the spec you're after, it may make sense for you to consider a cayman r too..

dontdobends

485 posts

245 months

Sunday 21st August 2011
quotequote all
Steve you won't be disappointed with the gen2 cayman s the pdk is very good on road and track get the wheel with paddles,plus the 7th gear makes it easy to get in the mid thirtys mpg on the motorway.
The front discs don't last long I had two set in 10,000miles,the brakes do work fine with a fluid change and a set of RS19 pads on track

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
dontdobends said:
The front discs don't last long I had two set in 10,000miles,the brakes do work fine with a fluid change and a set of RS19 pads on track
Seriously, you only managed 5,000 miles on a set of discs ???? Maybe it's those fancy pads that eat them or 1 track day a week ? Or both ?

I find OE pads brilliant for road use and fine for occasional track use. The limiting factor seems to be the amount of grip from the front tyres rather than the amount of friction between pad and disc.

R Soul

123 posts

196 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
Regards fuel consumption my Gen-1 does (approx) 11MPG loony hooning, 11-13MPG cruising at 140-160 (amazingly good imo), 16-18 in the city or fast cruising, 22-26 during 'normal' driving in a mixture of environments, 24-32 cruising at 75-95, and around 34-36 cruising at 60ish.

The Gen-2 is more fuel efficient by at least 10% iirc.

Great car, shame you can't order it with the best NA or turbo engine.

dontdobends

485 posts

245 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
Seriously, you only managed 5,000 miles on a set of discs ???? Maybe it's those fancy pads that eat them or 1 track day a week ? Or both ?

I find OE pads brilliant for road use and fine for occasional track use. The limiting factor seems to be the amount of grip from the front tyres rather than the amount of friction between pad and disc.
the discs didnt wear out its just that I got cracks to the outside of the disc and that was in approx 10 trackdays, nothing wrong with the OE pads great on the road but will start to wilt after 3 laps

Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
From M5, Cayman will be to slow would advise looking at 996 Turbo.

Stunters

619 posts

225 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
Cayman S will feel plenty fast enough in everyday driving, providing you're prepared to rev the engine and work the gearbox (my other car's an E90 M3 so can at least make an obliquely valid comparison).

Discs and pads last reasonably well as long as you're not mentally aggressive - my car is just coming up to 60,000 miles and I've just replaced the discs and pads all round after about 45,000 miles including about 5 trackdays. First set were replaced at 15,000 after someone decided to steal the car and take it for a few donuts...

DocSteve

Original Poster:

731 posts

253 months

Thursday 25th August 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice guys.

I have done it and ordered a new Cayman S. The deal that could be negotiated on one already manufactured was so much better than speccing one from scratch I had to compromise on a few things to find one (mainly the LSD, which I was hoping for but not commonly specced). Anyway, it has PDK, sport chrono, infotainment pack, 19" turbo II wheels and a few other things like heated seats / parking sensors that I'm not too fussed about.

I think it certainly will be a change! Look forward to getting it next month :-)

Edited by DocSteve on Thursday 25th August 19:35

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Thursday 25th August 2011
quotequote all
Congratulations Steve!

I've done 20,000 miles in my Gen 1 car since I bought it 11 months ago. Its cost me approx £2,000 in servicing and maintenance but its been a brilliant all rounder. I average about 26mpg according to the on-board computer. This is with considerable motorway miles and a pair of lead boots. wink

I hope you enjoy it as much as I have.

SFO

5,191 posts

214 months

Thursday 25th August 2011
quotequote all
DocSteve said:
I have done it and ordered a new Cayman S.
not tempted by Cayman R? LSD standard.

OldBob

290 posts

190 months

Friday 26th August 2011
quotequote all
DocSteve said:
Thanks for the advice guys.

I have done it and ordered a new Cayman S. The deal that could be negotiated on one already manufactured was so much better than speccing one from scratch I had to compromise on a few things to find one (mainly the LSD, which I was hoping for but not commonly specced). Anyway, it has PDK, sport chrono, infotainment pack, 19" turbo II wheels and a few other things like heated seats / parking sensors that I'm not too fussed about.

I think it certainly will be a change! Look forward to getting it next month :-)

Edited by DocSteve on Thursday 25th August 19:35
Good choice and reasoning IMO. I specced up and ordered a Cayman S, PDK, LSD, PASM, 19", Sport chrono plus, at the end of May this year and am still waiting for a delivery date (was promised end July initially :-( ) I couldn't find one with LSD etc and the right colour for the missus so went for new spec. Having test drove a few beforehand I can honestly say I found the handling and drive-ability just sublime. I have a stage 2 GTR R35 and have spent some time on track with F458 and whilst the Cayman is not that quick relatively, it easily handles, points, brakes and turns as good as the Fezza and exposes the heaviness of the GTR in these respects. Can't wait till she let's my sons and I take it on track ;-)

DocSteve

Original Poster:

731 posts

253 months

Sunday 4th September 2011
quotequote all
Well I picked it up on Friday, and am pretty pleased with it so far.

It doesn't feel as ferociously fast as the M5 but it makes up for it by feeling more like a go kart in comparison through the bends. Not properly experimented with it yet but it does feel like the throttle really affects the car during bends, with lift-off tightening it up and bringing the rear out. Will look forward to getting it on a track.

One thing I have noticed, which may be ?normal searching the net, is a moderately intrusive buffeting noise in the cabin as if a window is slightly open. Otherwise, it feels like something I could happily cross continents in.