what diesel.....335D or 535D?
Discussion
Hello all, looking to get either a used 335D or a 535D to use as a commuter and wondered what peoples thoughts on what one to get are? Now will be after a MSPORT version of either a 335D or a 535D. The 535D seems to be cheaper to buy and most seem to come with satnav etc whereas the 335Ds do not, but the 335D has the paddle shift.....
So, what are peoples thoughts as I only want to spend up to about £13K on one?
Thanks
Lee
So, what are peoples thoughts as I only want to spend up to about £13K on one?
Thanks
Lee
leemarkadams said:
Hello all, looking to get either a used 335D or a 535D to use as a commuter and wondered what peoples thoughts on what one to get are? Now will be after a MSPORT version of either a 335D or a 535D. The 535D seems to be cheaper to buy and most seem to come with satnav etc whereas the 335Ds do not, but the 335D has the paddle shift.....
So, what are peoples thoughts as I only want to spend up to about £13K on one?
Thanks
Lee
Its no wonder the 335d's are not equiped with satnav if you only have 13k, look higher you will see plenty of M cars with the nav system. I get 38mpg combined and 42-44mpg on a decent run from my 335d.So, what are peoples thoughts as I only want to spend up to about £13K on one?
Thanks
Lee
I put 134k on a 335d, paddles are a novelty that soon wears off. Its lighter on its feet (tyres) than the 5, but the 5 has better comfort.
I used to average about 25 mpg with a worst of 19 mpg (track) sold mine for 9.5k and the DPF went a week later. Spend more to get better. Oh, leather is crap and wears badly.
I used to average about 25 mpg with a worst of 19 mpg (track) sold mine for 9.5k and the DPF went a week later. Spend more to get better. Oh, leather is crap and wears badly.
5 has more room and as has been said is far more comfortable than a 3.
My 535d returns around 28-32 over a tank, this increases dramatically if the wife drives it however, she can see 38-42.
I totally agree that xenon’s are a must, they turn night into day, simple.
If you can stretch to £15k it'll open up some far better deals IMO.
I do like the 335d coupe, cracking looking cars in MSport trim however having had two E60’s now I couldn’t go back to a smaller chassis. You can throw a 5 around just as well and the control if you do wish to be silly is epic, just be aware it’ll eat rears if you like to let it all hang out.
My brother just had his 530d remapped and I’m amazed at the performance increase, turned a great car into a stunner, I now want my 535 done!
My 535d returns around 28-32 over a tank, this increases dramatically if the wife drives it however, she can see 38-42.
I totally agree that xenon’s are a must, they turn night into day, simple.
If you can stretch to £15k it'll open up some far better deals IMO.
I do like the 335d coupe, cracking looking cars in MSport trim however having had two E60’s now I couldn’t go back to a smaller chassis. You can throw a 5 around just as well and the control if you do wish to be silly is epic, just be aware it’ll eat rears if you like to let it all hang out.
My brother just had his 530d remapped and I’m amazed at the performance increase, turned a great car into a stunner, I now want my 535 done!
On the E60 you really want the LCI (facelift) model from mid 2007 onwards... not least as the earlier auto boxes aren't great. But £13k won't get you one - £15-16k for a high miler, £18k plus for something under 80k miles.
My 535d (LCI) does 29mpg around town, will get close to 40mpg on a steady motorway run, 70ish flowing in traffic.
My 535d (LCI) does 29mpg around town, will get close to 40mpg on a steady motorway run, 70ish flowing in traffic.
Hi everyone - I'm a lowly Audi A3 2.0 TDI DSG (140, mapped to 180) owner but I am thinking about making amends and getting a used 335D M Sport or 535D LCI M Sport. I drove a nice 335D M Sport today (E90 pre-facelift) and I liked it but not quite as much as I was hoping I would. Certainly pulled well but couldn't help but think 'remap', which I understand they do very well. The old style auto 'box felt mushy compared to the DSG in my Audi and I found the steering perhaps a little heavy. I haven't drive a 535D yet. A few questions:
i) What are the differences between the E90 335D pre and post facelift? I think the face and tail are slightly reshaped and the iDrive controls are improved? Are there any other changes? I think I read somewhere that the steering went from hydraulic to electric but not sure if that's true. The specs on Autotrader show a slight improvement in MPG and 0-60 in 6.0 rather than 6.2.
ii) I'd like to have split/fold rear seats but these seem rare as hens teeth. The retrofit seems like a reasonably straightforward job BUT you need to find matching seats from a breakers yard (or no doubt pay through the nose for new from BMW), which I am guessing is not that easy. Any comments?
iii) Clearly I need to drive a 535D next but what are people's opinions about the handling characteristics? I see that there is only a little over 100kg between the 335D and 535D, which surprised me because I had always thought that the 5 series was a much larger and heavier car. Is a 535D significantly less fun on twisty B roads than a 335D? Most of my driving is town/motorway dull stuff, so most of the time I'd go for comfort but the 335D seemed probably even more comfortable than my nicely spec'd 2004 A3. I drove an Audi A5 Sportback 3.0 TDI Quattro last year and it felt like a ship compared to my A3 and I didn't like it at all. The 335D felt heavier than the A3 but a lot more powerful. I wonder if the 535D would just be too boat like? Clearly subjective and again I really need to go drive a 535D to compare. However, all opinions welcome.
iv) Anyone know if there are any problems retrofitting a removable tow bar to either the 335D or 535D?
Sorry for the mass of questions.
Cheers,
Jim
i) What are the differences between the E90 335D pre and post facelift? I think the face and tail are slightly reshaped and the iDrive controls are improved? Are there any other changes? I think I read somewhere that the steering went from hydraulic to electric but not sure if that's true. The specs on Autotrader show a slight improvement in MPG and 0-60 in 6.0 rather than 6.2.
ii) I'd like to have split/fold rear seats but these seem rare as hens teeth. The retrofit seems like a reasonably straightforward job BUT you need to find matching seats from a breakers yard (or no doubt pay through the nose for new from BMW), which I am guessing is not that easy. Any comments?
iii) Clearly I need to drive a 535D next but what are people's opinions about the handling characteristics? I see that there is only a little over 100kg between the 335D and 535D, which surprised me because I had always thought that the 5 series was a much larger and heavier car. Is a 535D significantly less fun on twisty B roads than a 335D? Most of my driving is town/motorway dull stuff, so most of the time I'd go for comfort but the 335D seemed probably even more comfortable than my nicely spec'd 2004 A3. I drove an Audi A5 Sportback 3.0 TDI Quattro last year and it felt like a ship compared to my A3 and I didn't like it at all. The 335D felt heavier than the A3 but a lot more powerful. I wonder if the 535D would just be too boat like? Clearly subjective and again I really need to go drive a 535D to compare. However, all opinions welcome.
iv) Anyone know if there are any problems retrofitting a removable tow bar to either the 335D or 535D?
Sorry for the mass of questions.
Cheers,
Jim
pengjn said:
...........iii) Clearly I need to drive a 535D next but what are people's opinions about the handling characteristics? .
iv) Anyone know if there are any problems retrofitting a removable tow bar to either the 335D or 535D?
I've got an LCI (2008) 525d M sport Touring manual which I feel is more than fast enough for 94.7% of the time iv) Anyone know if there are any problems retrofitting a removable tow bar to either the 335D or 535D?

They handling is sublime, you can throw them around like a much smaller car and they don't tend to wash out at the front by default, they steer from the rear, if you know what I mean. Steering feel is also excellent, loads up nicely when pressing on but then fingertip light at slow speed. They are in fact lighter than the previous generation E39, it usually goes the other way. Compares to the E90 I've driven I much rather be in my 5 - it "feels" better.
Must have options are the pro Nav and adaptive Xenons - the headlights are awesome compared to a conventional set up; they seem to bend light round corners so the whole of the road is always visible.
Anyway, to the OP - I would seriously consider the 525/30d as well as the 535d - they are similarly epic cars.
Paddle shift in the 335d is a waste of time IMO. Tried to use it a couple of times, but the rev-range is too small to take full advantage of it so you just end up watching the clocks all the time for the red-line. Better off letting the box just do its own thing, which it's pretty good at
Also, the push/pull thing on each paddle isn't a great set-up, SMG functionality of up and down on different levers is much better
Also, the push/pull thing on each paddle isn't a great set-up, SMG functionality of up and down on different levers is much better
I've had my 55 535d for a few months now and it's a terrific commuter car. We've also just been to cornwall 4 up in it for a week and it was perfect for that.
It feels like a big car but the handling is very good indeed. The engine is amazing and pulls incredibly well. With the gearbox in normal drive it's best suited to motorway and open A roads but is a little frustrating on b-roads and the twistier stuff. This is only my 2nd auto though and the last one was in a vauxhall carlton so I'm not the best judge. If you put it in sport mode it seems always to be in the right gear on twistier roads and it's a lot of fun to drive.
The adaptive (steering) headlights are amazing and worth having. The satnav is garbage and I'd rather user a tom tom for both the ease of destination entry and it's choice of roads. The only thing I wish my car had were the next level of seats up from mine where you can adjust the lumbar but these things are hen's teeth at reasonable money and I'm happy with the 49k miles 55 plate msport saloon with fsh I got for 12,600.
It also tows brilliantly. I fitted a removeable tow bar because I thought that the towball would confuse the parking sensors but it doesn't. If you have the msport kit you'll need a replacement rear valance with a removable panel which covers the hole you need for the towbar. I haven't got round to getting one yet so just have a hole I cut in the original panel which had a small ding in it. I tow my track car on a double axle BJ trailer and the combination of engine and gearbox are perfect for that.
Cheers,
Mark
It feels like a big car but the handling is very good indeed. The engine is amazing and pulls incredibly well. With the gearbox in normal drive it's best suited to motorway and open A roads but is a little frustrating on b-roads and the twistier stuff. This is only my 2nd auto though and the last one was in a vauxhall carlton so I'm not the best judge. If you put it in sport mode it seems always to be in the right gear on twistier roads and it's a lot of fun to drive.
The adaptive (steering) headlights are amazing and worth having. The satnav is garbage and I'd rather user a tom tom for both the ease of destination entry and it's choice of roads. The only thing I wish my car had were the next level of seats up from mine where you can adjust the lumbar but these things are hen's teeth at reasonable money and I'm happy with the 49k miles 55 plate msport saloon with fsh I got for 12,600.
It also tows brilliantly. I fitted a removeable tow bar because I thought that the towball would confuse the parking sensors but it doesn't. If you have the msport kit you'll need a replacement rear valance with a removable panel which covers the hole you need for the towbar. I haven't got round to getting one yet so just have a hole I cut in the original panel which had a small ding in it. I tow my track car on a double axle BJ trailer and the combination of engine and gearbox are perfect for that.
Cheers,
Mark
I have a slight admission to make...I couldn't get sufficiently excited about the 335D I tried last week, despite the amazing performance/economy combination. I went to drive an E46 M3 CS SMG today and, erm, accidentally fell in love with it and bought it. My heart is still racing with excitement. Oh dear - I thought I'd got fast cars out of my system with the 993 ten years ago but apparently not!
Edited by pengjn on Sunday 2nd September 21:40
Drek said:
I wouldn't buy a 335d for commuting that's for sure. It's no more economical around town than my old A3 3.2 although it's a damn sight more comfortable. If you're buying a d for commuting, why not the 320d?
Not everyone commutes around town.I do 20 miles to work in my 335d touring all on A roads, and its great for it.
Around town they are pretty rubbish though.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


