Is this a scam?
Author
Discussion

softinthehead

Original Poster:

1,550 posts

270 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Ive agreed a trade-in price with OPC on my new car, and have been given what I consider to be a fair trade-in considering they've not seen the car. My local OPC (who weren't able to source me a suitable new steed) had seen my car (manual 968 cab) but had offered a higher trade-in after inspecting the car.

I'm trading next week so in the interim thought I had nothing to lose by putting a final reduction price on my pistonheads advert, which would give me a modest profit and give a private buyer the chance to get what I believe to be a very good deal.

So this email has just arrived via pistonheads:

"Hi Tim
I don't know what your time line is for your new car, but I'm interested in buying it for the asking price. On a serious note , I'm in Australia and I would need some time to organise the shipping. How does that fit with you?
Regards"

Interestingly this email is generated through the Pistonheads classifieds response facility, which also includes an embedded link warning of various scams, including foreign buyers offering the asking price, so I assume this is a scam.

The odd thing is that at the top is another notice saying "For information; this message originates in Australia"

So genuine or scam?

Diesel130

1,549 posts

243 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
very suspicious as no questions about the car itself.

Ultra Violent

2,827 posts

300 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
You've answered your own question, assuming you are aware of your own user name...

elliot_holder

200 posts

220 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Sounds like a scam to me..

SIIX TT

484 posts

215 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
When I sold my Tuscan a few years ago I was sent an email from a man in the South of France who offered the asking price, said he needed time to get his cash, drive to Charles De Gaulle, fly to Newcastle etc etc...

I know it isnt exactly Oz but it turned out that he was 100% genuine.

I got him to :

JPeg me some ID
Pay a small deposit via Paypal to test his validity
Pay the full amount by CHAPS a week before he collected

He was infact just a PH from France, not psycho fraudster....

Point being - who knows. As long as your careful and can be bothered with the hasle for the extra cash



RedSpiseeBalls

441 posts

190 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Ultra Violent said:
You've answered your own question, assuming you are aware of your own user name...
LOL.

But seriously, does the modest profit (£500 maybe) you mention sound like its worth the agro?

Obv I dont know ur financial situation but you've ordered a great Cayman

Give it to the OPC as you originally intended (for a price u were happy with at some stage) and pick up your new car.

Paul Dishman

5,430 posts

268 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Hard to tell if genuine or not. You could see if he'd CHAPS you the full price, but banks are closed Monday so thats a day less in which to act and you'd have to check that a fraudulent transfer couldn't be taken back.

softinthehead

Original Poster:

1,550 posts

270 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
RedSpiseeBalls said:
LOL.

But seriously, does the modest profit (£500 maybe) you mention sound like its worth the agro?

Obv I dont know ur financial situation but you've ordered a great Cayman

Give it to the OPC as you originally intended (for a price u were happy with at some stage) and pick up your new car.
You are quite right, and the money is incidental. TBH the main reason I don't really want to trade the car is because I know the OPC will send it to auction, and I wanted it to go to someone who really wanted a 968 cab and would appreciate it. I recognise that this is entirely foolish, sentimental and faintly ridiculous but I spent a lot of time and effort maintaining the car and it just seems such a shame. I guess thats why I am softinthehead.


Edited by softinthehead on Saturday 27th August 18:18

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Have you asked for a phone number? A chat with him should give you an instinct about his credibility - a fraudster will be emailing every man and his dog so it's fair to assume won't know much about niche market 1990's Porsches or be interested in them, so you'll rumble them in no time.

Cars can be a LOT dearer in Oz, so maybe the asking price is well worth it to him and he's keener to tie up a deal and not lose the car than trying to save a few hundred quid haggling.

It will indeed take a bit of time to sort out the shipping and indeed payment, so I'd suggest the following:
1) If he seems to check out OK then offer to store the car until paid for (to your complete satisfaction) and then allow his shippers to collect (it's easy to organise delivery to the shippers if needed).
2) Ask the OPC if they'll store the car for you (they have a Cayman shaped space now that a 968 will fit in smile ) as you've sold it overseas, but ask if they'd stand on their offer for 14 days or so.

That way you hedge your bets and could get the best of both worlds - get your cake and eat it if you will (it's a game of two halves at the end of the day, when all's said & done..... rolleyes )
/crapclichemode wink

I've sold cars to buyers from abroad (France, Portugal, Italy, Germany, Malta, Portugal, Thailand, Tenerife, Ireland) and it's always been kosher and not much hassle either. Some have collected personally, so having left a holding deposit pay the balance on collection, others have paid in full in advance and the car's then been collected/delivered. It takes less time than waiting for people to turn up, doing test drives etc etc.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
softinthehead said:
You are quite right, and the money is incidental. TBH the main reason I don't really want to trade the car is because I know the OPC will send it to auction, and I wanted it to go to someone who really wanted a 968 cab and would appreciate it. I recognise that this is entirely foolish, sentimental and faintly ridiculous but I spent a lot of time and effort maintaining the car and it just seems such a shame. I guess thats why I am softinthehead.
Have you tried to get any trade bids on it yourself? It's not the best time of year, but that's the same for the OPC offer so it's worth asking. Send me the details/photos and let me know how much I need to beat and I'll see what I can do if you like: marcus@autoperform.com

ewan221

1,219 posts

217 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
If my Boxster had sold the other night I would of been on phone to you about this car.

willmac

2,097 posts

195 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Could well be genuine. Have you checked Porsche prices in OZ ? They are unbelievably steep.
Get a feel for it with a phone call I would say and take it from there as already mentioned

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Gonna stick my neck out and say genuine, however further contact required. My scam radar is pretty twitchy too.

Steviebeee

601 posts

214 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Everyone nowadays is so 'on guard'. Quite rightly so.

The only problem then is, that genuine buyers can be 'fire walled'.

As already said, if the buyer is willing to provide a contact number you will be in a much better position to make up your own mind. Also, if the buyer is prepared to pay for the car, either by BACS or CHAPS, then whats the problem? He/she is WAY more exposed that you in those circumstances.

Selling cars myself, I've never had a hoax buyer from OZ! Hope this helps.

Stevie

Google [bot]

6,828 posts

212 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Whether it's a scam or not, you cannot import that car to Australia for road use unless you've owned and used it for a year. So it's either a scam, in which case ignore, or it genuine from someone who's not reaserched enough to know it's impossible, in which case ignore.

softinthehead

Original Poster:

1,550 posts

270 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Google [bot] said:
Whether it's a scam or not, you cannot import that car to Australia for road use unless you've owned and used it for a year. So it's either a scam, in which case ignore, or it genuine from someone who's not reaserched enough to know it's impossible, in which case ignore.
This is why PH is so valuable. Thank you, that is very instructive. and says all I need to know.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
Google [bot] said:
Whether it's a scam or not, you cannot import that car to Australia for road use unless you've owned and used it for a year. So it's either a scam, in which case ignore, or it genuine from someone who's not reaserched enough to know it's impossible, in which case ignore.
You'd need to check for sure but as I understand it there's nothing stopping someone importing a car to Australia BUT the tax is pretty high and it is this that can be avoided if it's been owned for over a year in the UK (or perhaps anywhere in the EU?).

Google [bot]

6,828 posts

212 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
thegoose said:
You'd need to check for sure but as I understand it there's nothing stopping someone importing a car to Australia BUT the tax is pretty high and it is this that can be avoided if it's been owned for over a year in the UK (or perhaps anywhere in the EU?).
I don't think so. Under the pre-'89 regs you can import cars but the 968 is too new. There is no import category I'm aware of that would allow it, and I've looked.

Even if I am wrong, or if it were a 1988 968 wink, you need pre-import approval which can take ages that I'm sure the OP doesn't want.

Ignore.

Google [bot]

6,828 posts

212 months

matc

4,738 posts

238 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
I sold my 360 spider to a guy in Oz, all done via e-mail, was probably the easiest sale I've ever dealt with. Definitely worth a follow up I'd say.

Plenty of cars get shipped straight out, so I'm not sure how they get around the rules posted above, but evidently they do. When I dropped my car at the docks it was a supercar heaven, pretty much every supercar ever made, sat there waiting to be exported....quite sad really!