328i E36 starting problem
Discussion
I have a problem with Mrs 230TE's 328i coupe (1996). It starts fine from cold and runs beautifully without a hint of any problems. But if you switch off the engine once it has warmed up, it won't restart. Spins over on the starter but not so much as a hiccup. Let it cool down for 20 minutes and it will fire up instantly and run perfectly until the next time.
I'm thinking faulty crank position sensor, just wondering if there are any other known faults on 328s which cause exactly these symptoms before I go out and spend £40 on a new sensor. All suggestions gratefully received.
I'm thinking faulty crank position sensor, just wondering if there are any other known faults on 328s which cause exactly these symptoms before I go out and spend £40 on a new sensor. All suggestions gratefully received.
Frances The Mute said:
How long is the car running for/what distance have you covered before you switch off and restart?
Anything from a 3 mile round trip upwards. I'm pretty sure it is fuel system rather than ignition that is shutting down, as when I first crank it there is a brief cough as it ignites whatever unburned fuel is left in the cylinders. I can hear the fuel pump so that rules out pump relay.They can have a habit of overfuelling from the cold start which renders them useless if you restart soon after switching off etc.
I had this once after moving the car off the drive. Still, after three miles, I wouldn't expect this to be an issue.
The crank sensor could well be the cuplrit. A quick diag check should confirm this for you.
I had this once after moving the car off the drive. Still, after three miles, I wouldn't expect this to be an issue.
The crank sensor could well be the cuplrit. A quick diag check should confirm this for you.
Update... I bought a new replacement crank sensor at a 'bargain' price on Ebay, fitted it (swine of a job if you don't take the inlet manifold off) and after that it wouldn't start at all.
My friendly local mechanic lent me his portable diagnostic box (worth about three times as much as the car), I plugged it in and up came fault code 83 - crank sensor. So I now have an OEM sensor on order. I also managed to pull the fault codes for the ABS system, so two new ABS sensors also on the way, which should put the ABS light out.
Moral: £20 crank sensors are about £20 too expensive.
My friendly local mechanic lent me his portable diagnostic box (worth about three times as much as the car), I plugged it in and up came fault code 83 - crank sensor. So I now have an OEM sensor on order. I also managed to pull the fault codes for the ABS system, so two new ABS sensors also on the way, which should put the ABS light out.
Moral: £20 crank sensors are about £20 too expensive.
TheEnd said:
The crank sensor code could be set from plugging in the non working sensor.
Were the two ABS sensors the front wheels?
I didn't clear the codes before changing the crank sensor, and code 83 is the only one I have. So I'm working on the assumption that the old sensor was on the way out (the insulation round the lead had broken up) causing the initial hot starting issue, and that the new one is just duff. If I replace the sensor and find it still doesn't start when hot, there will be a very cheap, tidy 328i coupe up for sale next week. Were the two ABS sensors the front wheels?
The ABS sensors were nearside front and nearside rear. I have already checked the connectors and they look fine, no dirt or corrosion inside.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


