Clutch Problems and Surprise Cost from Porsche
Clutch Problems and Surprise Cost from Porsche
Author
Discussion

Peter Loew

Original Poster:

56 posts

209 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Hi All,

I bought my 997 Carrera S from Porsche West London around 3 months ago. On Thursday last week the clutch wouldn't come up properly and the car had to be taken away. Now I speak to them and they want to charge me 2300 for a new clutch and fly wheel.

Wtf? It's wear and tear but I can tell you I've been sensible when driving and haven't even driven it that much.

Surely this is ridiculous? Can anybody advise?

P

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Speak to the dealer principal. They should really cut you a deal.

But it's not covered by the warranty.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Why does the fly wheel have to be replaced ?

How many miles since you picked the car up ?

SFO

5,191 posts

214 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
I would argue that the fault existed at the time of purchase (and therefore is their responsibility), especially if you haven't done too many miles since you bought it.

GreigM

6,740 posts

280 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Are they sure its not a hydaulics problem - if no slippage beforehand I'd suggest hydraulics, in which case you are being shafted for a clutch and flywheel you don't need.

In any case, £2300 is taking the piss....

Koing

442 posts

204 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
What is the mileage on the car?

Koing

chris_w

2,571 posts

290 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Does the 111 point check include wear on the clutch? Could be useful evidence of the condition of the car when sold if so.

Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
chris_w said:
Does the 111 point check include wear on the clutch? Could be useful evidence of the condition of the car when sold if so.
Yes but approved scheme only warrants that it does not replacing for next 3 months.

nickfrog

25,481 posts

248 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
SFO said:
I would argue that the fault existed at the time of purchase (and therefore is their responsibility), especially if you haven't done too many miles since you bought it.
I think it's a wear item so not really a fault nor a warranty item and while it takes 5 seconds to check how much friction material there is left on a brake pad, it's not that obvious for clutch friction material.

Having said that, it'd would be harsh for the OPC not to cover the cost.

nsm3

2,831 posts

227 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
I thought clutches were about £1,200?

Try some other OPC's for reference?

Peter Loew

Original Poster:

56 posts

209 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
It's a 2007 997 Gen 1. The mileage on the car is 24799, I put exactly 1499 miles on it since I bought it.

I've emailed the sales guy who did tell me to let him know if I have any problems.

I will point blank refuse to pay for this and if they insist then I will argue for a full refund or such. This is really putting me off Porsche right now.

P


rog007

5,832 posts

255 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
If it were me...This is a clear violation of the SoGA. A car purchased from a dealer of the type you purchased would by all reasonable assessment have longer than 1500 miles/3 months left in the clutch unless you were alerted at point of sale. Give dealer a chance to repair free charge. If they don't, demand full refund. Involve Trading Standards, Porsche and whoever financed vehicle. Good luck!

Nano2nd

3,426 posts

287 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
mine did exactly this, turned out to be a faulty slave cylinder, fixed under warranty smile got them to put in a clutch at the same time as it didn't cost me anything for the labour - circa £600 for clutch parts as i recall, god knows how much the slave cylinder and all that labour would of cost!

Martian O

2,734 posts

193 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Is West London the worst OPC in the country? I would love to see the OPC satisfaction stats.

ZeroH

2,922 posts

220 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Martian O said:
Is West London the worst OPC in the country? I would love to see the OPC satisfaction stats.
Was wondering the same thing !! They do seem to offer new standards in truly horrible service.

Yet people continue to buy from them.....

EVOeng

966 posts

201 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
SFO said:
I would argue that the fault existed at the time of purchase (and therefore is their responsibility), especially if you haven't done too many miles since you bought it.
As SFO said, you can argue that the fault existed at the time of purchase. I had a similar problem with Jaguar when I bought a used car. PM me if you would like some help in getting them to pay up.

alcatraz236

197 posts

183 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
given that you have covered such a short mileage and only had for 3 months you could surely argue that the fault must have existed at the point of sale (unless you drove it like a lunatic, which you didn't). Even if it is a wear and tear item it must have been on its last legs when they sold it to you. They must recognise this. I would refuse to pay for it. I actually had a similar issue on one of my cars, albeit not my porsche (i.e. clutch going couple of months into my ownership of an approved used car). It was covered by the warranty.

Peter Loew

Original Poster:

56 posts

209 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice everyone. I will await the response from the salesman and let you know what the outcome is.

DocSteve

731 posts

253 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
I had a similar situation with a BMW E60 M5. The clutch went after covering a similar mileage but the dealer agreed to pay for it in full (it was over 4k IIRC).

As you have done less than 1.5k miles since you bought the car it is clear that the clutch was very close to the end of its life at the time of sale. There is a prima facie SOGA case here. I would be very surprised if they do not go back on this if you push it firmly but politely.

Peter Loew

Original Poster:

56 posts

209 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
Right, I spoke to the sales guy who basically explained that they need to spend the labor to open up the car and see if it was a fault or not.

- If it is a fault they will charge it to warranty.

- If it isn't a fault I will have to pay the 2k+ as a total cost. If I decide not to pay it I will have to pay circa £600 for the labor.

So tomorrow I will find out exactly what's going on. They said they'd show me if it was my fault, but I would not know heads from tails in looking at a worn out clutch. From my point of view they could simply charge me despite it being my fault or not.

He said it was possible to wear out a new clutch within 50 miles of driving!

Does all this sound right to you guys?

P