Looking to buy a Cayman S
Looking to buy a Cayman S
Author
Discussion

train01

Original Poster:

82 posts

226 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
My budget is about £20K

There are quite a few cars around at that price.

What should I be going for accessory wise?

Should I be looking at lowest mileage or higher spec or newer cars?

What colours are to be avioded?

18" or 19" or PASM?

Indy or Private?

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
What kind of options would you like on your car? That's as good a place as any to start. smile

If you are thinking about what are the desirable options for resale, I wanted the following when I bought mine:

Black or Midnight Blue paint
Full Leather (including the dash and doors, not just the seats which they all have)
19" Wheels


Nice to haves, that mine doesn't have, would be:

PASM
PSE

I don't much care for anything else and I don't really believe that it needs anything else!

train01

Original Poster:

82 posts

226 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
PSE, is this not std?

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
No, PSE is not standard.

train01

Original Poster:

82 posts

226 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Sorry, I have just twigged PSE = Sports Exhaust and yes thats not std frown

I was thinking of PSM

nickfrog

25,481 posts

248 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
I would deffo try and avoid 19' wheels as they offer no more grip (and potentially affect traction) by reducing the sidewall's capacity to absorb bumps, but ruin the ride plus they add to the unsprung weight, not to mention higher cost of tyres etc...

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
19s are desirable come resale though, and they do look better... Personally I had a Box on 19s and now my Cayman on 19s, though the Cayman has PASM which makes, to my mind, quite a difference to ride.

PCM isn't as good as a tom-tom, but is also seem as desirable come resale. Similarly Bose is popular even though it's crap. I alsonhave sports seats and a short-shift, both of which I'd want again. Litronics supposedly very much better than the standard, slightly weak, units too.

As to colour - avoid silver these days I reckon; black and grey are popular and look good, but I have white and, if you can live with the attention, it's the colour to have.

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Wheels are a personal preference but I wouldn't consider any 987 variant without 19s, the arches are just way too big for any other wheel size.

Regards colour... White was THE colour to have back in 2008. Now its a bit too common for my tastes.

train01

Original Poster:

82 posts

226 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
From what I can glean Sat Nav and Bose is important, so are 19" wheels even though most will say the car rides better on 18"

Sport seats are a must and parking sensors and cruise are nice to have.

Sports Chrono sounds nice but PASM is probably not worth it unless you do track days or want any duff fillings dislodged

Trev450

6,774 posts

203 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
The satnav is a good selling point but as far as being a good system is concerned it get left behind by many after market ones. The Bose is also not worth the money imo. You are better off going for the sound system plus. I shall no doubt get flamed for my last comment, but ff you are intent on having 19's, then you really do need pasm to make the ride more compliant.

My list of must have's was: full leather, sports seats, PSE, 19's, PASM and sport chrono.

alcatraz236

197 posts

183 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
I would buy the colour and the options that you want, everybody is different. I sought out a car with 18's and PASM since I felt this offered the best handling / ride balance. Having said that, most people seem to prefer 19's for looks (although I actually feel they look a little too big). I wasn't fussed about any of the other options - didn't want sat nav since I can just buy a separate more up-to-date unit for a fraction of the price, didn't want parking sensors since I can just turn my head around, didn't want heated / electric seats since I think they are just unnecessary and add weight, etc, etc.

dasherdiablo1

4,512 posts

252 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
Glad someone else has posted this topic! I too am considering a Cayman S or Boxster S but am waiting for a bargain.

Money is burning a hole in my pocket!

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
As said buy the colour and options you want.

Prior to buying my Cayman S I test drove a PASM and non-PASM car both with 19" SportDesign wheels back to back and there wasn't enough of a difference there to make it a deal-breaker for me. Whether it will for you will entirely depend on a) what you're used to and b) what you are expecting. The base car handles great in its own right.

Options are really to taste though and depend entirely on what you want and to a lesser extent how much you care about resale. For me Bi-xenons and PCM were essential just because I expected to see those things on a car of that value. Same with full leather really.

There are valid arguments for and against most of the options to be honest and ultimately when buying used when the car has a lot of tickable options you're likely to have to make a sacrifice somewhere, or risk waiting months for the exact spec to come up.

Paul O

3,186 posts

214 months

Thursday 1st September 2011
quotequote all
Just buy why you want, not what you think someone else might want in a few years time when you sell.

If you quite fancy an orange one, then get an orange one. If you never use satnav, then don't be put off it your otherwise perfect find doesn't have it.

I went for bright red. Absolutely loved that car. Good luck with your search and enjoy the car when you get one!

juansolo

3,012 posts

309 months

Thursday 1st September 2011
quotequote all
17's are the way forward for ride. Get the gen2 wheels and they look like gen1 18's. Better IMO as they're not as chunky (or as stupidly heavy, the gen2 17's are the lightest wheels Porsche make), and I actually like some tyre wall on my tyres...

PASM if you go any bigger on a gen1 (gen2's have better ride).

PSE isn't essential when you can get a Carnewal GT exhaust swap for 400 euros.

Satnav isn't essential when you can get a superior tomtom for less than £100

Bose is st. Premium audio is probably the best compromise, but still pretty dire to be fair. Don't buy one for it's stereo...

Short shift is horrid when cold and really not neccessary.

Sports chrono is completely unneccessary unless you have Porsche Klicken Flappen. All it does is change the throttle map and make it more sensitive. All the other things it does (turn PSE on and stiffen PASM) can be operated seperately anyhow. Not to mention the wart is ugly.

Rear wiper is handy if you want to see behind you, but people find them ugly...

Essentially because of all this 'must have's for resale' rubbish, you can pick yourself a bloody good and perfectly good standard car, without all the useless tat on it, for very sensible money. Screw what the next person might want, get what YOU want on the car.

I'd also recommend having a go in the standard car, it has an lot going for it. All the S does different is go a little faster and have a little more torque. It essentually makes it easier to go quicker. The 2.7/2.9 needs more effort on the part of the driver to go quick and IMO can be more satisfying and usable as a result. Cheaper all round too so you'll likely get a newer, less used car for your money.

Edited by juansolo on Thursday 1st September 09:04

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Thursday 1st September 2011
quotequote all
I'd agree with all that except the comment on Bose - the standard unit, not Bose, in my missus' diesel A3 is waaaaay better than the Bose in the Porker. It's got plenty of bass, but that's about all you can say for it IMHO. Well, that and the fact that it's much better than the standard unit.

juansolo

3,012 posts

309 months

Thursday 1st September 2011
quotequote all
DELETED: Comment made by a member who's account has been deleted.
Exactly, it's what everyone 'expects' from a driver focused car. So we accept substandard ride on sports cars which is bullst and lazy on the part of the manaufacturer. After all they go to the bother of making a RHD version. A set of UK tuned shocks/springs/arbs is hardly going to break them...

Edited by juansolo on Thursday 1st September 12:00

cidersurfer

74 posts

246 months

Thursday 1st September 2011
quotequote all
I've just gone through the exact same process as the OP and have to echo the sentiments of most to buy what is important to you. I decided what was important to me and went shopping. There are quite a few about.
It took about 6 weeks of looking and driving, quite a pleasant experience as I was able to tie it in with some work travel, in the end I had to make a small compromise and don't have cruise control but I'll see how things go and maybe I'll retro fit it.
One week of ownership and over 700miles already!

jackliebling

509 posts

204 months

Thursday 1st September 2011
quotequote all
I am a professional musician and I can categorically tell you that the BOSE is absolutely rubbish. The sound has bass, very piercingly harsh treble and absolutely no body or warmth. I never listen to music in it. I borrowed a cayman from my OPC without BOSE and it was infinitely better, I think it had the standard system in it. Just woofers and tweeters, it sounded like real music, not synthetically mucked around. Actually, I would say that the sound that the BOSE system produces is totally bizarre! It totally rips the goodness out of a recording.

I would downgrade my car if it were possible without destroying the value. Oh well...

faster_stueys

67 posts

212 months

Thursday 1st September 2011
quotequote all
Would agree that the Bose is lame, I actually think that in such a small space less speakers is more.

Based on my old cayman s I would go for the following options:
PSE - loved it
Sports chrono - great with pse and I much preferred the sport throttle mapping for heel & toe-ing
Sports shift - essential I thought, think it's cheap to retro fit
Sports seats - self explanatory
Sports steering wheel - much nicer
PCM -

Nice to have-
19's - think the car drives better on 18's when I compared a demo but it looks a lot better on 19 s
PASM - I liked PASM for the sheer adaptability it gave the car, Id like to have again but not essential
Full leather - makes the interior a much nicer place to be