Buying a used BMW 123d - advice please
Buying a used BMW 123d - advice please
Author
Discussion

toddler

Original Poster:

1,259 posts

267 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
I'm looking for a used 123d M Sport and I'm after some advice please.

I've found an 08 plate for £10,700 but it's got 64,000 miles on it which is about 20K more than average. It's got four stamps in the book from a BMW main dealer:

Service history

=========


Registered 23/03/08
Serviced 09/01/09 (17K miles)
Serviced 05/11/09 (34K miles)
Serviced 04/03/10 (41K miles)
Serviced 25/08/10 (51K miles)

Should I be concerned by the high mileage or are these BMW 2.0 litre twin-turbo diesels pretty bomb proof?

Cheers
toddler

ejenner

4,653 posts

212 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Dunno if this is the car with the mental air-filter wedged underneath the bulkhead taking about 40 minutes to change requiring removal of the strut brace, cabin filter, engine cover... if so.. then I don't know if this sways your interest. If it is that engine then bear in mind the cost to change this simple service item. If you think you'll only have to do it once during your ownership then probably ok. But that would put me off. Especially since these turbo diesels suck like a hover and soil their airfilters pretty successfully.

toddler

Original Poster:

1,259 posts

267 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
ejenner said:
Dunno if this is the car with the mental air-filter wedged underneath the bulkhead taking about 40 minutes to change requiring removal of the strut brace, cabin filter, engine cover... if so.. then I don't know if this sways your interest. If it is that engine then bear in mind the cost to change this simple service item. If you think you'll only have to do it once during your ownership then probably ok. But that would put me off. Especially since these turbo diesels suck like a hover and soil their airfilters pretty successfully.
Don't know about the air filter, but price includes next two services and MOTs so not too worried.

edo

16,699 posts

296 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
What sort of mileage are you going to do?

Personally I wouldnt buy a complex twin turbo diesel that didnt have some manufacturers warranty left that I could extend, or from a main dealer.

What is your budget, and are you looking at 3dr, 5dr or Coupe?

toddler

Original Poster:

1,259 posts

267 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
edo said:
What sort of mileage are you going to do?

Personally I wouldnt buy a complex twin turbo diesel that didnt have some manufacturers warranty left that I could extend, or from a main dealer.

What is your budget, and are you looking at 3dr, 5dr or Coupe?
Gonna do about 10K miles a year. Budget is £13K, looking for a 5 door hatchback.

It's at an Arnold Clark Vauxhall dealer and comes with their 2 years warranty but that doesn't fill me with confidence.

I was meant to be viewing a BMW used approved 58 plate 123d M Sport 5 door hatch with 25K miles tonight but they called me yesterday to say when it was PX'd it needed so much work doing that it would be going to auction. There don't seem to be many approved used 123ds but I'm in no rush so happy to wait.

edo

16,699 posts

296 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
toddler said:
edo said:
What sort of mileage are you going to do?

Personally I wouldnt buy a complex twin turbo diesel that didnt have some manufacturers warranty left that I could extend, or from a main dealer.

What is your budget, and are you looking at 3dr, 5dr or Coupe?
Gonna do about 10K miles a year. Budget is £13K, looking for a 5 door hatchback.

It's at an Arnold Clark Vauxhall dealer and comes with their 2 years warranty but that doesn't fill me with confidence.

I was meant to be viewing a BMW used approved 58 plate 123d M Sport 5 door hatch with 25K miles tonight but they called me yesterday to say when it was PX'd it needed so much work doing that it would be going to auction. There don't seem to be many approved used 123ds but I'm in no rush so happy to wait.
Fair play to the dealer on the second one if that is true.

Not wanting to put a spanner in the works, but only 10k a year, I'd be looking at a 130i!!!
Look here to compare the annual cost of fuel between a 40mpg 123d, and say 28mpg on a 130i...

http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-16...

I agree with your sceptical view of the warranty provided by Arnold Clarke. I'd be making the assumption it would have more holes in than Mr Gaddafi's residence at the moment.

Agree they are pretty thin on the ground at your budget. Try to get one with Nav too - helps resale.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2011...




davidjpowell

18,707 posts

215 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
64k is not high mileage.

I don't know where the doomsayers get this diesel is unreliable from. I've been running this evil for a few years on various cars and have just as many unpleasant bills from petrol cars as diesel, if not more.


frosted

3,549 posts

208 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
64k is not many miles , just wondering what's wrong with the 120d , iirc there's 30bhp between the 2

edo

16,699 posts

296 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
frosted said:
64k is not many miles , just wondering what's wrong with the 120d , iirc there's 30bhp between the 2
Although on paper the 120d is 177bhp V 200odd on the 123d, the nature of the 2 turbos makes real world performance quite noticeably better.

frosted

3,549 posts

208 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
Sirelly the heavier engine would have it's toll on the handling ? I would also go with the 123d, I was putting the 120d out there because
1. It's cheaper
2. It's cheaper to run, tax , mpg etc
3. You could get a decent map on it and easily see 210 bhp , however a warranty would be probably void

Actually I think I'm swayed by the 120d now

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
edo said:
Not wanting to put a spanner in the works, but only 10k a year, I'd be looking at a 130i!!!
^^ This.

There is a Grey 3-dr 130i on an '07 plate that been in the PH classifieds for months - it started at 14k (now 12k), but could negotiate and use the difference for insurance/fuel...

Grey 3-dr 130i w/xenons

edo

16,699 posts

296 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
FamilyDub said:
edo said:
Not wanting to put a spanner in the works, but only 10k a year, I'd be looking at a 130i!!!
^^ This.

There is a Grey 3-dr 130i on an '07 plate that been in the PH classifieds for months - it started at 14k (now 12k), but could negotiate and use the difference for insurance/fuel...

Grey 3-dr 130i w/xenons
I always chuckle at Lanmere's adverts - they always take dark indoor pictures - whoever takes them needs shooting!

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
edo said:
FamilyDub said:
edo said:
Not wanting to put a spanner in the works, but only 10k a year, I'd be looking at a 130i!!!
^^ This.

There is a Grey 3-dr 130i on an '07 plate that been in the PH classifieds for months - it started at 14k (now 12k), but could negotiate and use the difference for insurance/fuel...

Grey 3-dr 130i w/xenons
I always chuckle at Lanmere's adverts - they always take dark indoor pictures - whoever takes them needs shooting!
Agreed. They have a couple of nice M3's too, that they've photographed terribly! hehe

@ OP: I reckon that 130i has been in the classified since I did some obsessing about 130i's in March/April...

And it might have started at 15k - I can't remember.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
It's worth test driving a 130i. You also may be surprised at the mpg you can get out of them. Even my Z4 Coupé (which has a low ratio back axle) with the same N52 engine was getting 35-40mpg taking it easy and 30mpg in normal out of town driving. Plus, the BMW N52 is a masterpiece of an engine and lovely to drive smile Personally I actually prefer the diesels because of the damm throttle delay on petrol BMWs (absent on diesels), but judging by comments on PH, this is a personal thing that doesn't bother most people. Ergo, test drive a 130i and make your own mind up. It's worth doing before you commit your money.

Oh, and regarding the mileage, be aware of the difference between the truth and the perceived truth of Joe Average who will buy your car from you in a few years. I've always found that high mileage cars are mechanically fine (if not better than low mileage cars, which on average may have done more short journeys), but Joe Average thinks otherwise, especially approaching 100k. I see cars as an asset, so I've always gone for low mileage cars on this basis, and recouped some pretty good residuals as a result.

Chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all

Approved 130i SE manual
http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...


Approved 123d SE manual
http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

At 10k miles a year I'd find it hard to justify the extra outlay for the diesel, especially with the NA 6 being much less complex than the twin turbo lump.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
toddler said:
I was meant to be viewing a BMW used approved 58 plate 123d M Sport 5 door hatch with 25K miles tonight but they called me yesterday to say when it was PX'd it needed so much work doing that it would be going to auction.
If a 25k mile 58 plate 1 Series needed so much work that even a BMW dealer wouldnt take it on, I'd take that as a pretty good indicator that a cast iron warranty - ie the BMW warranty - is essential on these cars.

MagicalTrevor

6,481 posts

260 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
toddler said:
Gonna do about 10K miles a year. Budget is £13K, looking for a 5 door hatchback.

It's at an Arnold Clark Vauxhall dealer and comes with their 2 years warranty but that doesn't fill me with confidence.

I was meant to be viewing a BMW used approved 58 plate 123d M Sport 5 door hatch with 25K miles tonight but they called me yesterday to say when it was PX'd it needed so much work doing that it would be going to auction. There don't seem to be many approved used 123ds but I'm in no rush so happy to wait.
Bugger at the 5 door comment as I'm about to put my car up for sale. 120D M Sport, 3 door, 2009, 27k, still in warranty and fixed price servicing for the next 18 months.

You can remap a 120D to near 123D performance levels and then you'd have more choice of cars to buy?

frosted

3,549 posts

208 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
Chrisw666 said:
Approved 130i SE manual
http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...


Approved 123d SE manual
http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

At 10k miles a year I'd find it hard to justify the extra outlay for the diesel, especially with the NA 6 being much less complex than the twin turbo lump.
Yes but that initial outlay would be coming straight back in your pocket come resale time . It's satisfying knowing that you can get 600miles to a tank compared to err... A lot less on the petrol .

However , diesel does suck ( makes me feel old )

ghibbett

1,920 posts

216 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
As said above, 10k miles must surely = 130i.

I've actually just updated 'my garage' with details of my old 130i. Great car.

eztiger

836 posts

211 months

Wednesday 31st August 2011
quotequote all
Sounds like a pretty good price to be honest though this will depend on what options it has..

Wouldn't worry about the mileage and, as far as I'm aware, nothing really major to worry about on them.

Regarding the service history the 123d will be on a condition based service so if you can get detail of what those services actually were that would be useful, though off the top of my head the number carried out seems roughly correct for what would need done over the period.