Discussion
An objective question:
Historically, I'm only familiar with doing my sums for used cars.
I've not bought a brand new car before, and I'm tempted with the new 991.
Where I lack an answer to myself is this:
Current or early 997S is btwn £35k, and £65.
Decently spec'd 991 possibly approx £87k.
Should I buy the new 991 on the basis that eg depreciation after first 12/18 months very low, or on the basis of asking myself the question: is one car twice the item than the other car?
Cheers.
Historically, I'm only familiar with doing my sums for used cars.
I've not bought a brand new car before, and I'm tempted with the new 991.
Where I lack an answer to myself is this:
Current or early 997S is btwn £35k, and £65.
Decently spec'd 991 possibly approx £87k.
Should I buy the new 991 on the basis that eg depreciation after first 12/18 months very low, or on the basis of asking myself the question: is one car twice the item than the other car?
Cheers.
I don't think you can predict the depreciation to be honest. I'd expect the first few years would be at least the cost of the options you buy.
If you can afford the loss and are happy with the outlay, then go for a 991. I imagine there will be a waiting list too, so if your not one of the first you might take more of a hit as they become commonplace.
If you want to minimise depreciation, buy one of the older ones. If you want a newer car, buy a newer one.
Its really about how much you are comfortable with spending. In terms of percentage, the newer car will probably depreciate much less than a 997, but in terms of financial value, it will cost more.
I'm no expert though and thats just a guess. If Porsche produce the car in greater numbers than the 997, then expect depreciation in line with its predecessor.

If you can afford the loss and are happy with the outlay, then go for a 991. I imagine there will be a waiting list too, so if your not one of the first you might take more of a hit as they become commonplace.
If you want to minimise depreciation, buy one of the older ones. If you want a newer car, buy a newer one.
Its really about how much you are comfortable with spending. In terms of percentage, the newer car will probably depreciate much less than a 997, but in terms of financial value, it will cost more.
I'm no expert though and thats just a guess. If Porsche produce the car in greater numbers than the 997, then expect depreciation in line with its predecessor.

Thats some way to pop your 'new car' cherry my friend - £87,000 is, in 95% of the populations book, serious money.
I would avoid buying a new car unless you are keeping it for 10 years, which imho is the point at which the financials look good.
Lets say that 991 is worth £20,000 in 10 years - you have spent £6,700 a year in depreciation over that period.
If you bought a 997 for, say, £50,000 now (lets say it's a 4 year old 'S' from an OPC), then keeping it until that car is 10 years old, and worth £20,000, would have cost you £5,000 a year in depreciation.
If you keep cars for a long time, the losses are palatable - if you tend to flip cars after 2-3 years, buy used.
I would avoid buying a new car unless you are keeping it for 10 years, which imho is the point at which the financials look good.
Lets say that 991 is worth £20,000 in 10 years - you have spent £6,700 a year in depreciation over that period.
If you bought a 997 for, say, £50,000 now (lets say it's a 4 year old 'S' from an OPC), then keeping it until that car is 10 years old, and worth £20,000, would have cost you £5,000 a year in depreciation.
If you keep cars for a long time, the losses are palatable - if you tend to flip cars after 2-3 years, buy used.
A brand new 991 will depreciate massively. In real monetary terms, far in excess of a used 997. Basically the older the car, the less loss in depreciation as the curve flattens out. The question to ask yourself is are you prepared to pay all that extra money for a shiny new car? Will you be upset when the man at the OPC offers you £40K for it in 3 or 4 years time? Personally I don't consider myself wealthy enough to be content losing that sort of money on a car. Others might consider it peanuts.
The level of cost of ownership is totally up to you and how much you can afford to spend, but what I am fairly sure of is that the 991 will depreciate as fast as a 997. It might hold OK for the first 6 months or so, whilst its the 'in thing' but the footballers will soon move on.
Will the 991 be twice the car the 997 is? I hope so, but I doubt it.
MTR
Will the 991 be twice the car the 997 is? I hope so, but I doubt it.
MTR
You will take a pounding in the first 3-4yrs but that is standard on all but very limited edition runs.
If you can afford it go for it. But me personally I don't think I'll ever buy a brand new car
1) £££
2) I won't keep a car long enough to make it worth while
3) I save a chunk getting a car that is 3-4yrs old but I will ultimately lose a chunk as well
Good luck on your search!
Koing
If you can afford it go for it. But me personally I don't think I'll ever buy a brand new car
1) £££
2) I won't keep a car long enough to make it worth while
3) I save a chunk getting a car that is 3-4yrs old but I will ultimately lose a chunk as well
Good luck on your search!
Koing
Thank you for the replies.
It seems to boil down to classic heart vs mind, and I'm inclined to lean towards the used route at present.
Your replies seem to support the used option; what's the opinion and thinking of those of you who do buy new please? Is it a case of " I like it, and it costs what it costs"......?
It seems to boil down to classic heart vs mind, and I'm inclined to lean towards the used route at present.
Your replies seem to support the used option; what's the opinion and thinking of those of you who do buy new please? Is it a case of " I like it, and it costs what it costs"......?
For £87k, you can get into a 997.1 GT2 or a 997.2 GT3. I think either will be a better car than a 'cooking' 991 and either should depreciate less.
Edited to add: The other option is to buy a used 991 with almost no miles in a few months time. I did this with my 997S.2 early last year. List was £84k, I paid £69k for it from Bolton OPC when the car was only 3 1/2 months old and only had 740 miles on it! As close to new as you can get, and a hell of a lot less costly! As the Yanks would say, go figure....
Edited to add: The other option is to buy a used 991 with almost no miles in a few months time. I did this with my 997S.2 early last year. List was £84k, I paid £69k for it from Bolton OPC when the car was only 3 1/2 months old and only had 740 miles on it! As close to new as you can get, and a hell of a lot less costly! As the Yanks would say, go figure....

Edited by Ian_UK1 on Friday 2nd September 13:47
Worth bearing in mind that it's not a "bad" decision to do what you're thinking of doing. If people didn't buy the cars brand new then they wouldn't turn up on forecourts for the rest of us to buy 2-3 years down the line.
Ultimately bearing the depreciation is the only way you're going to get into the new car at all, so it's you'll be in the same boat as everyone else buying one new.
Ultimately bearing the depreciation is the only way you're going to get into the new car at all, so it's you'll be in the same boat as everyone else buying one new.
Maybe I am being a bit harsh but surely this should be an easy question?! Either you want to spend the money or you don't and no-one but you can answer that. If you want a shiny new car with the latest tech then go 991.
It will depreciate. You will lose money. Either you are happy with losing the money to have the latest toy or you are not.
I look for bang for my buck (from a driving point of view) and for me a 991 is not 20 times more fun than a used Integra. You pays your money and you takes your choice etc.
It will depreciate. You will lose money. Either you are happy with losing the money to have the latest toy or you are not.
I look for bang for my buck (from a driving point of view) and for me a 991 is not 20 times more fun than a used Integra. You pays your money and you takes your choice etc.
AtomMan said:
I look for bang for my buck (from a driving point of view)
That's what I do too. For me £25K is about the point where I see rapidly diminishing returns i.e. I wouldn't enjoy driving a new 991 anywhere near enough to justify the £90K spend. But I'm more than happy to drop £25K into a slowly depreciating 996 C4S. All depends on your disposable income of course. If I was a billionaire I wouldn't worry about initial cost and depreciation in the slightest.911fan said:
This has helped me.
I think I'm up for a 997s ( I have 2 children under 5 so unsure if gt2/3 will be suitable?) my prev 06 997s manual was great.
If anyone is looking to sell, I fancy a grey one with Sports Chrono.
Given you need 4-seats, pop down to your local dealer and test drive a GTS - if you're not surprised by how brilliant it is, I'd check your pulse. If you do like it, get your dealer to sharpen their pencil and find you one, with the right options, for a nice price. There aren't many left in the system but people will be willing to do deals.I think I'm up for a 997s ( I have 2 children under 5 so unsure if gt2/3 will be suitable?) my prev 06 997s manual was great.
If anyone is looking to sell, I fancy a grey one with Sports Chrono.
I went shopping for a pre-owned C2S and end up purchasing a GTS after driving them both back to back. The difference was astonishing and with the little touches added to the GT, it really does look both very contemporary and a nice compromise between the GT3 and the widebody 911
911fan said:
This has helped me.
I think I'm up for a 997s ( I have 2 children under 5 so unsure if gt2/3 will be suitable?) my prev 06 997s manual was great.
If anyone is looking to sell, I fancy a grey one with Sports Chrono.
No rear seats in a GT2/3 but you can get them retro fitted in a 997.1 GT3 from what I've read.I think I'm up for a 997s ( I have 2 children under 5 so unsure if gt2/3 will be suitable?) my prev 06 997s manual was great.
If anyone is looking to sell, I fancy a grey one with Sports Chrono.
Koing
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


