Opinion on early 997 C2 purchase
Discussion
Hello,
Am very tempted by the following car on the PH adverts and was wondering if anyone has any comments on the age/mileage/spec.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3144807.htm
It seems well priced all considered. Not so keen on the colour combination (particularly the interior) and am obviously slightly concerned about running a 997 out of warranty.
Any questions I should ask the owner?
Based in London so buying a car all the way up in Edinburgh may be tricky, any good specialists that way which I could use for an inspection?
I am returning to 911 ownership from an S2000, this would be a weekend /Euro car circa 5k mi per year, would possibly be keeping it 3 or 4 years.
Thanks for any comments.
I'd be asking if its had any oil changes between services, because its my oppinion that 20k between oil changes is just too long.
I change the oil on mine twice between OPS services, so every 6.5k mine gets fresh oil and filter.
The car looks clean, maybe ask the owner to get a 111 point inspection and if it passes ask them to put a warranty on it for you and you pay the additional for the warranty.
I change the oil on mine twice between OPS services, so every 6.5k mine gets fresh oil and filter.

The car looks clean, maybe ask the owner to get a 111 point inspection and if it passes ask them to put a warranty on it for you and you pay the additional for the warranty.
just a question but are you looking at it because it's (subjectively) cheap? you don't like the colour combo & you're worried about having a 997 without a warrenty, it hardly sounds like the start of motoring bliss?!
perhaps speak to baz at hartech, most of the big worries about bore scoring seems to concern the 3.8 S model not the 3.6 carrera.
IMS will still be a concern but this can be erradicated by hartech if it's a major concern.
you can also just put a warrenty on it (after 90 days) or get the current owner to put one on it as part of the deal if it passed the 111 check.
for what it's worth i love the 3.6 carrera's & i'd rather have well specced one than a 3.8 but that's just me.
you may wish to consider the mileage though. if you keep it 3 years & do 15k it's going to be right near 100k miles & you just know you'll have to give it away (say less than £15k in 3 years maybe?). not a massive drop in the grand scheme of things but if you're buying on price alone to begin with it probably should be worth considering.
if that's the case i think you'd be much better off saving for another 6 months & buying a 50k miler in a colour combo you actually liked.
perhaps speak to baz at hartech, most of the big worries about bore scoring seems to concern the 3.8 S model not the 3.6 carrera.
IMS will still be a concern but this can be erradicated by hartech if it's a major concern.
you can also just put a warrenty on it (after 90 days) or get the current owner to put one on it as part of the deal if it passed the 111 check.
for what it's worth i love the 3.6 carrera's & i'd rather have well specced one than a 3.8 but that's just me.
you may wish to consider the mileage though. if you keep it 3 years & do 15k it's going to be right near 100k miles & you just know you'll have to give it away (say less than £15k in 3 years maybe?). not a massive drop in the grand scheme of things but if you're buying on price alone to begin with it probably should be worth considering.
if that's the case i think you'd be much better off saving for another 6 months & buying a 50k miler in a colour combo you actually liked.
Thank you for your posts Gibbo and Cragswinter, both very useful thoughts. Had thought the same on the 111 point inspection and warranty
.Indeed, I am tempted as, at 22.5k, it is the cheapest 997 on sale and, after looking at 996s and 987 Boxtsers I decided that what I really want is a 997.
In general, from reading around, I am ok with the C2 as opposed to the C2S and anectodal evidence seems to show less 3.6s with engine issues anyways. This particular example is well specced enough to make it tempting, it has most of the key options for me (Xenons, PASM, heated seats, BOSE). I would have preferred no sunroof for more headroom, sports exhaust and cruise, both of the latter can be eventually added though, just need to check a local OPC car to see how much space the sunroof steals as I am 6ft5 and on the 996s its tight (not to mention on my old 964).
In terms of external colour, I prefer Seal Grey, Cobalt Blue and Atlas Grey, but the Midhight blue comes above Basalt Black and Silver for me. The interior is my only major concern, but then again I recall that they are darker than on 996s?
Now the mileage, in 3 years it would have 87k miles, so not too terrible? This is possibly the biggest consideration though and alse the reason why its been slow to sell I guess.
My final thought is that, having kept an eye on the market, most of the cheaper 997s are either in my no no colours (Basalt Black and Silver) or don't have one of Xenons, BOSE or heated seats.
So bid him 20 grand as a take it or leave it.
It's high mileage now, it'll be higher when you sell it & it's not your perfect spec.
Me, I wouldn't worry about the warrenty, cruise & exhaust. Cruise is a cheap fix, get a gundo hack for the exhaust & don't bother with the warrenty. Hartech's of no use to you down in London for their maintenance plan but you could easy drop it off on the way back down for the IMS fix & be done with it. Not sure if warrenty-wise covers IMS failure? Iirc the parts for cruise are circa 200 quid & even an opc will fit it for 600.
It's high mileage now, it'll be higher when you sell it & it's not your perfect spec.
Me, I wouldn't worry about the warrenty, cruise & exhaust. Cruise is a cheap fix, get a gundo hack for the exhaust & don't bother with the warrenty. Hartech's of no use to you down in London for their maintenance plan but you could easy drop it off on the way back down for the IMS fix & be done with it. Not sure if warrenty-wise covers IMS failure? Iirc the parts for cruise are circa 200 quid & even an opc will fit it for 600.
Looks good, but I'd get it inspected first. What condition are the tyres in? Has the clutch ever been changed? Could be a few grand right there if not. IMS should be okay at that mileage, I believe they usually let go earlier. The bearing seals will have loosened up by now, allowing oil to keep them lubed.
Morning,
Not sure how far you've got, but you should get yourself into this car! As other posters have alluded to, the IMS issues at this mileage are not really a concern as the bearing will be getting good lubrication now the the seal will be worn enough to allow it.
The car has been listed very well, and the guy clearly knows his car and that money spending on the correct maintenance (Drop links, tyres etc)
As to your height, I wouldn't worry - the full electric seats (as here) offer a slightly wider range of adjustment than standard and will go that bit lower for you, so you should be okay fitting in even with the sunroof.
Good luck!
PS. as Dazco said, Blue looks great in real life, like a lot of other Porsche colours!
Not sure how far you've got, but you should get yourself into this car! As other posters have alluded to, the IMS issues at this mileage are not really a concern as the bearing will be getting good lubrication now the the seal will be worn enough to allow it.
The car has been listed very well, and the guy clearly knows his car and that money spending on the correct maintenance (Drop links, tyres etc)
As to your height, I wouldn't worry - the full electric seats (as here) offer a slightly wider range of adjustment than standard and will go that bit lower for you, so you should be okay fitting in even with the sunroof.
Good luck!
PS. as Dazco said, Blue looks great in real life, like a lot of other Porsche colours!
Guys, thanks for your replies again.
In the end I think I will probably leave this one. As much as its a decent spec and is super well priced I think that when I come to resell the high milage will be a major issue.
I will likely hold out a couple more months and save up untill I can afford a lower mileage car in my preferred colour combination and spec (2S).
Doesn't help that the car is in Edinburgh and that I am in London so not easy to view. Mind you, the vendor has been great on emails and has given all the relevant detail etc and the car checks out well. Its still on its original clutch though...
In the end I think I will probably leave this one. As much as its a decent spec and is super well priced I think that when I come to resell the high milage will be a major issue.
I will likely hold out a couple more months and save up untill I can afford a lower mileage car in my preferred colour combination and spec (2S).
Doesn't help that the car is in Edinburgh and that I am in London so not easy to view. Mind you, the vendor has been great on emails and has given all the relevant detail etc and the car checks out well. Its still on its original clutch though...
RiccardoG said:
Guys, thanks for your replies again.
In the end I think I will probably leave this one. As much as its a decent spec and is super well priced I think that when I come to resell the high milage will be a major issue.
I will likely hold out a couple more months and save up untill I can afford a lower mileage car in my preferred colour combination and spec (2S).
Doesn't help that the car is in Edinburgh and that I am in London so not easy to view. Mind you, the vendor has been great on emails and has given all the relevant detail etc and the car checks out well. Its still on its original clutch though...
Definitely need to factor in £1K for a new clutch then, but at that mileage it confirms it must have had an easy motorway life.In the end I think I will probably leave this one. As much as its a decent spec and is super well priced I think that when I come to resell the high milage will be a major issue.
I will likely hold out a couple more months and save up untill I can afford a lower mileage car in my preferred colour combination and spec (2S).
Doesn't help that the car is in Edinburgh and that I am in London so not easy to view. Mind you, the vendor has been great on emails and has given all the relevant detail etc and the car checks out well. Its still on its original clutch though...
RiccardoG said:
In the end I think I will probably leave this one. As much as its a decent spec and is super well priced I think that when I come to resell the high milage will be a major issue.
With respect I think your goals are somewhat at odds. If price is your primary driver (you've already said that the colour combination is not one you'd choose, and concerns about warranty) then ultimately you're going to have to take a corresponding hit relative to the market upon resale.
The reason this specific car is attractive to you, by your own admission, is that it is "the cheapest 997 on sale". The reason for this is obvious - the mileage.
I think it's a bit of a false economy to buy a car like this and assume it's a bargain because it's cheaper than other 997s. I don't really see anything in the ad that would suggest it's a bargain - it is simply priced in accordance with its higher-than-most mileage.
Ultimately you'll "lose" the equivalent amount of money as compared to the market rate when you come to sell it yourself. As long as you are happy about that then there's no reason you shouldn't necessarily buy the car.
Durzel said:
With respect I think your goals are somewhat at odds.
If price is your primary driver (you've already said that the colour combination is not one you'd choose, and concerns about warranty) then ultimately you're going to have to take a corresponding hit relative to the market upon resale.
The reason this specific car is attractive to you, by your own admission, is that it is "the cheapest 997 on sale". The reason for this is obvious - the mileage.
I think it's a bit of a false economy to buy a car like this and assume it's a bargain because it's cheaper than other 997s. I don't really see anything in the ad that would suggest it's a bargain - it is simply priced in accordance with its higher-than-most mileage.
Ultimately you'll "lose" the equivalent amount of money as compared to the market rate when you come to sell it yourself. As long as you are happy about that then there's no reason you shouldn't necessarily buy the car.
Thanks for your feedback. I understand that, basically, you're saying "buy low, sell low", why not go for it.If price is your primary driver (you've already said that the colour combination is not one you'd choose, and concerns about warranty) then ultimately you're going to have to take a corresponding hit relative to the market upon resale.
The reason this specific car is attractive to you, by your own admission, is that it is "the cheapest 997 on sale". The reason for this is obvious - the mileage.
I think it's a bit of a false economy to buy a car like this and assume it's a bargain because it's cheaper than other 997s. I don't really see anything in the ad that would suggest it's a bargain - it is simply priced in accordance with its higher-than-most mileage.
Ultimately you'll "lose" the equivalent amount of money as compared to the market rate when you come to sell it yourself. As long as you are happy about that then there's no reason you shouldn't necessarily buy the car.
From my side that car is a way of getting into a 997 straight away spending less than with any of the other 997s advertised on PH. But in the ensuing train of thought that developed came the potential obstacle of disposing of it in 3 years time (say) when it will possibly be somewhere in the 90's mileage wise and therefore much harder to shift (high mileage water cooled 911 prices are much more mileage sensitive than oil cooled).
So, I thought that I might as well save up some more and get the 997 I really want (colour and options) with a few less miles. All my other, less special, cars are low milers so it was sort of odd that the most special of all would also be the most used one. And yes, I know mileage isn't everything etc etc.
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


