Joomla or Wordpress - help me decide
Joomla or Wordpress - help me decide
Author
Discussion

Bikerjon

Original Poster:

2,211 posts

192 months

Monday 5th September 2011
quotequote all
As someone who used to know very little about creating websites I've spent some time over the last year trying out the various website creation tools and learning about SEO and analytics. I'm now ready to put all this into practice and build a proper website. I've been looking at Joomla and Wordpress and still a bit undecided about which to go with. I've downloaded a virtual machine of both so I can do some testing and I seem to prefer using Joomla but theres no denying that Wordpress has more themes and plugins and I've also heard it can be better on the SEO side (not sure if that's true or not?)

The website is for my own small business which serves a local area. It doesn't need to be amazing but seeing as it's an IT related business it needs to be of a reasonable standard and I'm also very keen to do as much as I can with SEO. Theres a chance I may be doing a few websites for other people too so it would be good to stick with a product that's likely to fit other peoples needs as well. Any opinions on which product I should go for?

andy-xr

13,204 posts

235 months

Monday 5th September 2011
quotequote all
Wordpress

Slinky

15,704 posts

280 months

Monday 5th September 2011
quotequote all
andy-xr said:
Wordpress
I'll even things up...

Joomla..

I've been using it for a while now, have built a good number of sites with it.. As a CMS the later iterations (1.6 specifically) has a far more configurable ACL, but that is only really a requirement if you have a diverse set of content creators that have varied permissions requirements..

There are plenty of plugins to allow all sorts of integration and functionality, have a look at http://extensions.joomla.org/ to get an idea of what's available..

andy-xr

13,204 posts

235 months

Monday 5th September 2011
quotequote all
Slinky said:
I'll even things up...
Me too

Slinky said:
Joomla..
Never used it

hehe

Bikerjon

Original Poster:

2,211 posts

192 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
Thanks but that makes it a draw 1-1!

Any other Joomla and Wordpress experts with a view on this? I suppose either product is a good choice.


Thesaint01708

935 posts

188 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
Joomla if you have time and more than an average understanding
Wordpress if you are a beginner or want something quick and easy to maintain.

They will both give you 'roughly' the same results, with Joomla a little bit more configurable.

I have the choice of both on my server (built in script library) and i have been running several sites, all with wordpress without a hitch since 2007

edit to say i do have experience of both, and prefer Wordpress smile

Edited by Thesaint01708 on Wednesday 7th September 11:29

Lefty

21,598 posts

233 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
Wordpress is ace if you're an IT muppet like me.


andy-xr

13,204 posts

235 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
If you want an example of a fresh WP install from someone who's never done it before, have a look at my site (it's still a work in progress as time is limited and the files aren't optimised)

http://www.howiseetheworld.co.uk

It's hosted at 1and1 on a dirt cheap package using the wordpress install from wordpress.org (don't use the hosts version - themes mess up)

It took me 5 minutes to do - create a database on the hosting, download Filezilla, download Wordpress, copy to the root directory then install from there, then add the theme and content.

I messed up the first install, then forgot to unzip the files on the second. Third time's a charm and it was up and running inside of 15 mins

Bikerjon

Original Poster:

2,211 posts

192 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
I'm swaying towards Wordpress then.

I'll be needing a good theme to get most of the arty legwork done - I've seen Themeforest and they certainly have a huge selection to choose from - may need to set aside a few hours for that! Anywhere else I should check out for themes?

RJames

753 posts

221 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
Wordpress certainly.

Also Themeforest is a good shout, i have just become a template author on there. There is a few others around, you could look at Woothemes, WPBundle, Obox to name a few of the better template sites.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
I had a Joomla website, was OK, needed more techie skills to keep it going and change things.

When it came time to update to a new version it was a nightmare.

Installed wordpress and had my site up and running, with plug ins and all I wanted working great, in about 4 hours, that was mostly shifting and reformatting content.

Joomla seems a much more complex CMS, if you have a lot of contributors , a lot of information, sections, articles , security levels etc, seems worth the effort.

If you want an easy blog with teh whizzy, wordpress is it.

Xaero

4,063 posts

246 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
Wordpress. Although I've never tried Joomla, I've never felt a need. Thousands of themes available.

I would recommend the thesis theme: here as its customisable and free for the first 30 days if you don't get on with it. Run all my sites on it, the forum is excellent for quickly geting questions answers on changing the design to more custom ideas.

Bikerjon

Original Poster:

2,211 posts

192 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
Thanks all, will check out those other sites and the Thesis theme.

otolith

69,745 posts

235 months

Thursday 20th December 2018
quotequote all
A couple of years ago, there was a suggestion from a web design company we were using that we adopt Wordpress as a CMS. I put my foot down - we didn't need it, and I didn't trust it. We took the designs we bought and implemented them ourselves.


A little while ago I was gratified to notice that our main competitor's website had been hacked via a Wordpress vulnerability - and made sure to mention that this sort of thing was the reason I killed it.

Derek Smith

50,024 posts

279 months

Thursday 20th December 2018
quotequote all
A few years ago, I was trying to work out which was better. I had a chat with the bloke who runs my hosting company. Their site was Joomla based and I thought he'd give me positives one way as I'd already chatted to a couple of people with WP sites.

My host said he wasn't really the one to ask as they were changing the site to Wordpress.

Joomla's good. I ran a site on localhost for a while, as I did for WP. If anyone is in doubt the answer is to run both types of software on localhost and see which one grabs you. For me it was WP, but it wasn't a clear-cut decision. With the change to the easier-to-use blocks on WP, I assume there might be a few users crossing to Joomla for its more enthusiast stance.

On the point of hacking, about 30% of websites are WP based. This is both its strength and weakness. The software is an obvious target for hackers. However, there are lots of sites in the frame and if you regularly, not to say immediately, update your site as soon as a fix is supplied, the odds for being hacked are certainly no worse than for any other type of site. The problem with hacking safeguards is that they are like fences: they only keep out those who don't really want to get in. The latest update to WP, not a vulnerability fix but a Gutenberg change, includes an automatic updater. A sensible option I think.


HantsRat

2,411 posts

139 months

Thursday 20th December 2018
quotequote all
otolith said:
A couple of years ago, there was a suggestion from a web design company we were using that we adopt Wordpress as a CMS. I put my foot down - we didn't need it, and I didn't trust it. We took the designs we bought and implemented them ourselves.


A little while ago I was gratified to notice that our main competitor's website had been hacked via a Wordpress vulnerability - and made sure to mention that this sort of thing was the reason I killed it.
To be fair this would be a host issue rather than the design company. It sounds like they didn't patch their web servers and patch vulnerabilities. Wordpress is far superior to Joomla. Just ensure it's installed and setup correctly.

Bikerjon

Original Poster:

2,211 posts

192 months

Thursday 20th December 2018
quotequote all
Nice thread resurrection! It reminds me how I knew very little about all this 7 years ago and now I'm completely comfortable with Wordpress (even though the vulnerability side of things is still annoying). Never did explore Joomla that much as I decided it was too much for my needs.

HantsRat

2,411 posts

139 months

Thursday 20th December 2018
quotequote all
Bikerjon said:
Nice thread resurrection! It reminds me how I knew very little about all this 7 years ago and now I'm completely comfortable with Wordpress (even though the vulnerability side of things is still annoying). Never did explore Joomla that much as I decided it was too much for my needs.
What vulnerability things do you struggle with? Give me a PM if you want and I can run a quick health/scan on your site.

Bikerjon

Original Poster:

2,211 posts

192 months

Thursday 20th December 2018
quotequote all
HantsRat said:
What vulnerability things do you struggle with? Give me a PM if you want and I can run a quick health/scan on your site.
Oh it's OK I run Wordfence and have learned the value of a decent host/Cloudflare etc. It just gets annoying with the sheer number of WP updates, Theme updates, Plugin updates and their dependencies on each other etc. There's always that twitchy moment when you click update but can never be truly sure if everything's going to look/work right when it comes back! I now run local test sites for anything important - like I say, I've come a long way with this since I posted the question 7 years ago!

Derek Smith

50,024 posts

279 months

Thursday 20th December 2018
quotequote all
Bikerjon said:
Nice thread resurrection! It reminds me how I knew very little about all this 7 years ago and now I'm completely comfortable with Wordpress (even though the vulnerability side of things is still annoying). Never did explore Joomla that much as I decided it was too much for my needs.
What do you think of Gutenberg?