997.1RS vs. 360CS
997.1RS vs. 360CS

Poll: 997.1RS vs. 360CS

Total Members Polled: 61

White 997.1GT3 RS: 48%
360 Challenge Stradale: 52%
Author
Discussion

911Thrasher

Original Poster:

2,573 posts

230 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
sniffing around for a 360CS...am i a fool?

note: had a 360M before - F430 is no option, no compromise

Edited by 911Thrasher on Thursday 8th September 22:43

SlowlnFastOut

431 posts

240 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Keep the RS, unlike the CS it can pull off the surf board on roof look!

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
911Thrasher said:
sniffing around for a 360CS...am i a fool?

note: had a 360M before
You are no fool sir. Both are near the top of my dream tree.

MTR

911Thrasher

Original Poster:

2,573 posts

230 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
SlowlnFastOut said:
Keep the RS, unlike the CS it can pull off the surf board on roof look!
ahahahah very true, it is a convenient car smile
But i'm back to work, finish the 6month gardening leave, so wont be using it so much anymore (especially because we also have the '88 300SL Bobby Ewing merc too). And hence, a pure weekend low mileage toy is plenty enough

jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
911Thrasher said:
am i a fool?
Keep what you've got. Learn to drive it. Keep away from the classifieds. Be happy and concentrate more on driving and less on the act of spending money/getting a new toy/materialism. I mean this in the best possible way, seriously, it was only yesterday that you ditched your 993tt and then ditched the 360. It strikes me that something is lacking somewhere for yuo to have to go through cars at this kind of pace. It can take months, even years to really 'get' certain motors.

911Thrasher

Original Poster:

2,573 posts

230 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
jackal said:
Keep what you've got. Learn to drive it. Keep away from the classifieds. Be happy and concentrate more on driving and less on the act of spending money/getting a new toy/materialism. I mean this in the best possible way, seriously, it was only yesterday that you ditched your 993tt and then ditched the 360. It strikes me that something is lacking somewhere for yuo to have to go through cars at this kind of pace. It can take months, even years to really 'get' certain motors.
Yeah since I ditched the 993tt I haven't fallen fully in love - it was the biggest mistake, I would buy it back and the current owner knows wink

And I did drive them quite a bit: 10kmiles with the ferrari and 13kmiles in RS

Edited by 911Thrasher on Thursday 8th September 23:09

jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
911Thrasher said:
Yeah since I ditched the 993tt I haven't fallen fully in love - it was the biggest mistake, I would buy it back and the current owner knows wink
get a 93RS .... miles better drive than a turbo

(i'd personally have a manual 430 over a CS as well)

cragswinter

21,429 posts

227 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
360cs is special, more so than the gt3 in my book.

low mileage weekend toy? no contest strad all the way

vxdave

158 posts

275 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Get a strad. It's in a different league. No comparision whatsover to a standard 360 which IMO isn't all that great (have owned both). I only sold my strad because I could no longer afford to have that much cash tied up in a car.

Edited by vxdave on Thursday 8th September 23:42

fastastic

1,516 posts

236 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
I would suggest that if you buy the Ferrari, you could probably run it for 6 months to a year and on resale get enough for a 997.2RS

TonyB66

243 posts

201 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
Keep the RS - Great looking car. I always got the sense that you enjoyed your 360 (especially the exhaust note) but not the bills when you had to fix the bodywork when it was to low and you scraped something. Ferrari's are more of a money pit, that's not going to change.

speedyellowrs

468 posts

238 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
993RS.... wink

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
yes

Candellara

1,890 posts

213 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
911Thrasher said:
ahahahah very true, it is a convenient car smile
But i'm back to work, finish the 6month gardening leave, so wont be using it so much anymore (especially because we also have the '88 300SL Bobby Ewing merc too). And hence, a pure weekend low mileage toy is plenty enough
Like peas in a pod m8. Also have a 300SL 107 - and love it.

360CS vs 997GT3.

Done both and would never go back to the Ferrari i'm afraid. The CS is a truly awesome car with the exhaust valves open. Remove the intoxicating sound of the exhaust - and it's not as good as the Porsche IMO

The Ferrari certainly "feels" special - that is the "myth of Ferrari". Unfortunately, remove the loud exhaust note and factor the potentially / HUGE cost of ownership - and yes, it's a myth. Some simple maths for you.

360CS purchase price £97,500 - preprep costs for the last owner (car was SOR but only 5,000 miles) at Ferrari dealer - £17,000 to include 6250 service, ball joints, rear tyres, brake pads and new plenum chamber. I kept the car for just over one year and covered 2500 to 3000 miles in that time. Service / Warranty renewal £3600 and the car also required a £3500 rear exhaust box.

Factoring what i sold the car for (and i got good money) running cost per mile (excluding fuel, insurance and tax and the 17k preprep costs) £8.64 per mile. Sorry, but that's not enjoyment for me and these cars are soooooo mileage sensitive in terms of deprectaion.

Porsche RS so far over 1500 miles. Nearly one year of ownership and she's had her big 4 year service at OPC £1200. Yep, £1200 that's it so £0.80 per mile (which obviously excludes depreciation which is the biggest cost)

997RS prices are actually really firming up. Keep it and stick an Akropovic exhaust ssytem on it if you really need the "sound" IMO


drpep

1,761 posts

199 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
In terms of residuals, you're probably better off with the CS if you're not planning on much driving in it. Costly beast to run but very special. As for the RS, well it's epic but if you're like me, when you get the itch, it doesn't go until you make the change.

I reckon I'll be in the GT3 for a year or so. I'll be doing some travelling in a years time so doesn't make sense to leave it cooped up in storage.

In reality though, I reckon some air-cooled pork would be more entertaining than the 360 CS. I recall you saying the 360 felt fragile...?

CGT1

33 posts

183 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
ive owned both and both are fantastic cars in there own right....................... but for me .....PORSCHE .

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
White - NO.

Wanta996Gotta

5,622 posts

238 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
Candellara said:
Like peas in a pod m8. Also have a 300SL 107 - and love it.

360CS vs 997GT3.

Done both and would never go back to the Ferrari i'm afraid. The CS is a truly awesome car with the exhaust valves open. Remove the intoxicating sound of the exhaust - and it's not as good as the Porsche IMO

The Ferrari certainly "feels" special - that is the "myth of Ferrari". Unfortunately, remove the loud exhaust note and factor the potentially / HUGE cost of ownership - and yes, it's a myth. Some simple maths for you.

360CS purchase price £97,500 - preprep costs for the last owner (car was SOR but only 5,000 miles) at Ferrari dealer - £17,000 to include 6250 service, ball joints, rear tyres, brake pads and new plenum chamber. I kept the car for just over one year and covered 2500 to 3000 miles in that time. Service / Warranty renewal £3600 and the car also required a £3500 rear exhaust box.

Factoring what i sold the car for (and i got good money) running cost per mile (excluding fuel, insurance and tax and the 17k preprep costs) £8.64 per mile. Sorry, but that's not enjoyment for me and these cars are soooooo mileage sensitive in terms of deprectaion.

Porsche RS so far over 1500 miles. Nearly one year of ownership and she's had her big 4 year service at OPC £1200. Yep, £1200 that's it so £0.80 per mile (which obviously excludes depreciation which is the biggest cost)

997RS prices are actually really firming up. Keep it and stick an Akropovic exhaust ssytem on it if you really need the "sound" IMO
Great post and shows the fragility and costs of owning a Ferrari. To the OP, i have an old EVO magaize or was it CAR that put the 360CS against the then equivalent Porsche which was a 996 GT3RS at the time and the 996 whooped its ass in every department apart from Soul?????????

Performance figures where nowhere as quick as the Porsche either.

Candellara

1,890 posts

213 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
In terms of performance, the CS "feels" very fast, but much of that is created by the exhaust note etc. In terms of raw speed - the CS certainly wasn't as agile as the GT3 on an A or B road and as such, the GT3 was certainly a quicker car in a real world environment.

Around a track, the GT3 is better (IMO -but very subjective), much better traction and much surer footed. On long straights, i've found that the GT3 is around F430 performance.

Don't get me wrong, i'd have another 360CS in a heartbeat. I'd place it on the marble floor in my glass walled garage (i wish), look at it and drive it a few hundred miles a year. If i wanted a car to enjoy using - no contest.

Chr1sch

2,592 posts

224 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
cragswinter said:
360cs is special, more so than the gt3 in my book.

low mileage weekend toy? no contest strad all the way
Totally agree