I hate porsche
Author
Discussion

julian64

Original Poster:

14,325 posts

285 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
But I have to admit I can't get the cayman out of my head.

I was recently at a thruxton experience day with caymans single seaters and Lambo 670's.

Everything was as expected. The Lambo was impressive, single seaters were fun.

However I can't get the cayman out of my head. Driving it round the track was quite a revelation. Going into a bend with a fixed steering wheel and having so much control just by using the throttle.

Little bit more throttle drifting all four wheels predictably toward the outside, little less throttle and the car progressively takes a tighter line, and on thruxon you could make those changes all in the same corner, every corner, all day long.

I don't think I've ever driven a car that had handling that neutral, or that composed. I'm used to fighting a car round the corner, or at the very least waiting for the car to get snatchy on the edge and the inevitable moment when I'll have to catch it. I know cars that stick to the road like glue, but when they let go they are difficult to catch.

I don't remember the last 911 I got into having that ability.

But I hate porsches. I really do, engine in the wrong place, bug ugly, no soul.

So I have a real dilema here. I want the car, but not the porsche.

Agoogy

7,274 posts

279 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
julian64 said:
But I hate porsches. I really do, engine in the wrong place, bug ugly, no soul.

Cayman's engine in the wrong place? not really
bug ugly? subjective, but I think it's quite well resolved, especially up against the rest of the family.
no soul? - did the car connect with you? did it get under your skin? sounds like it did...would it let you down on a cold wet night on a lonley road, or would it more likely be a reliable addition, that you can count on...a 'friend' if you will.
If I'm wrong it's about time someone defined what 'soul' is around here...

juansolo

3,012 posts

309 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
julian64 said:
But I have to admit I can't get the cayman out of my head.

I was recently at a thruxton experience day with caymans single seaters and Lambo 670's.

Everything was as expected. The Lambo was impressive, single seaters were fun.

However I can't get the cayman out of my head. Driving it round the track was quite a revelation. Going into a bend with a fixed steering wheel and having so much control just by using the throttle.

Little bit more throttle drifting all four wheels predictably toward the outside, little less throttle and the car progressively takes a tighter line, and on thruxon you could make those changes all in the same corner, every corner, all day long.

I don't think I've ever driven a car that had handling that neutral, or that composed. I'm used to fighting a car round the corner, or at the very least waiting for the car to get snatchy on the edge and the inevitable moment when I'll have to catch it. I know cars that stick to the road like glue, but when they let go they are difficult to catch.

I don't remember the last 911 I got into having that ability.

But I hate porsches. I really do, engine in the wrong place, bug ugly, no soul.

So I have a real dilema here. I want the car, but not the porsche.
Essentially you have a problem with the badge, your percepion of it and what you think others will be of you for owning one... Simple answer to that; f**k 'em. Sure some people will think you're a cock. They're idiots. Then again read some posts in this forum and it's not all entirely unjustified, but I'd never let that stop me buying a good car that I liked.

As for the rest, the engine is in the middle, where it belongs. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder and I actually think the Cayman is one of the best proportioned porkers currently on sale (spyder aside). As for no soul. That's utterly subjective. The engine has character. In some cases (the DFI's) that just needs a the sports exhaust to make it a bit more vocal. Mine is the baby of the range and it never fails to make me feel good driving it.

Also if you want something that drives, rides and handles even better, have a go in an Evora. It's let down in a lot of other areas, but if that's what you like about the Cayman and you still can't bring yourself to buy a porker, give it a go instead.

Edited by juansolo on Monday 12th September 14:44

julian64

Original Poster:

14,325 posts

285 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
Evora, really, better handling than that!

juansolo

3,012 posts

309 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Evora, really, better handling than that!
Yup, IMO of course. Though my problem with the Evora is in other areas, that may or may not have been taken care of on the new cars (substandard build quality, dreadful gearchange, questions over reliability). But you cannot question how it drives, they're bloody brilliant. I wouldn't have swapped the Cayman for the one I drove. But maybe if they've sorted out the issues, I might go that way next.

In fact I wrote a review at the time.

Edited by juansolo on Monday 12th September 14:51

RedSpiseeBalls

441 posts

190 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
julian64.... now buy one, but de-badge it if you dont like the crest ! :-)

996GT2

2,649 posts

241 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
julian64 said:
I want the car, but not the porsche.
I've read some st on here, but this just about takes the top spot.


Scelto

619 posts

188 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
996GT2 said:
I've read some st on here, but this just about takes the top spot.
Amen.

PGN 500sl

3,048 posts

197 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
996GT2 said:
julian64 said:
I want the car, but not the porsche.
I've read some st on here, but this just about takes the top spot.
Agreed. Spectacularly daft thing to write.

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
996GT2 said:
. . . I've read some st on here . . . .
yeah - usually before your first attempt at editing it!

wink

SEE YA

3,522 posts

276 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
996GT2 said:
I've read some st on here, but this just about takes the top spot.
+1

julian64

Original Poster:

14,325 posts

285 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
SEE YA said:
996GT2 said:
I've read some st on here, but this just about takes the top spot.
+1
Think you're going to have to take the praise at face value. Don't want to start a thread in the Porsche forum about why I don't like porsche. Just consider me as the least likely to ever heap praise on the Porsche badge and leave it at that.

The thread title wasn't the best I'll admit, but it does show that even porsche haters have to admire the one thing the Porsche seems to do very well indeed.

STiG911

1,210 posts

198 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Think you're going to have to take the praise at face value. Don't want to start a thread in the Porsche forum about why I don't like porsche. Just consider me as the least likely to ever heap praise on the Porsche badge and leave it at that.

The thread title wasn't the best I'll admit, but it does show that even porsche haters have to admire the one thing the Porsche seems to do very well indeed.
Not much better IMO.

996GT2

2,649 posts

241 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
julian64 said:
the one thing the Porsche seems to do very well indeed.
Agreed, it's Porsche's best kept secret that their best handling car is one of the cheapest. Goes even better in orange winksmile


nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
Personally I could not care less about the brand so I genuinely don't understand what "hating" Porsche means. They happen to produce the best handling road chassis that I've ever driven (the Boxster/Cayman chassis) this side of much more exotic or track focused stuff and make most other "performance" chassis feel like they handle like boats.
I buy a car for what it does for ME and not at all for whatever some shallow idiots may think of me because the best tool for the job that I have found happens to be Porsche. If next time round the best tool happens to be an Alfa, a Skoda, a Facel Vega (unlikely) or a Lotus, then I'll switch for the same reasons.

julian64

Original Poster:

14,325 posts

285 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
STiG911 said:
julian64 said:
Think you're going to have to take the praise at face value. Don't want to start a thread in the Porsche forum about why I don't like porsche. Just consider me as the least likely to ever heap praise on the Porsche badge and leave it at that.

The thread title wasn't the best I'll admit, but it does show that even porsche haters have to admire the one thing the Porsche seems to do very well indeed.
Not much better IMO.
Gutted.

GT Glee

705 posts

206 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Think you're going to have to take the praise at face value. Don't want to start a thread in the Porsche forum about why I don't like porsche. Just consider me as the least likely to ever heap praise on the Porsche badge and leave it at that.

The thread title wasn't the best I'll admit, but it does show that even porsche haters have to admire the one thing the Porsche seems to do very well indeed.
I'm afraid you're not going to get anything better on a forum of Porsche enthusiasts (primarily 911) who hold the polar opposite view on all measures you describe. Bit of a daft post IMO.

STiG911

1,210 posts

198 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
Imagine if it was a negative post in the Ferrari forum, the lynch mob would be banging his door down by now...

GT Glee

705 posts

206 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
STiG911 said:
Imagine if it was a negative post in the Ferrari forum, the lynch mob would be banging his door down by now...
I see he hates Ducati too so definitely would be down for a good lynching..

julian64

Original Poster:

14,325 posts

285 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
GT Glee said:
STiG911 said:
Imagine if it was a negative post in the Ferrari forum, the lynch mob would be banging his door down by now...
I see he hates Ducati too so definitely would be down for a good lynching..
I didn't come on here to make a negative view. I came on here to compliment the handling of quite a spectacularly car. I heaped even more praise on the car by saying that I had to admit how good it was despite not being a fan of the marque.

I guess I was hoping for some confirmation that the cayman was a diamond in the porsche range handling wise, and does not reflect the standard of porsche handling throughout. If not I have some rethinking to do.

Picking on the fact I don't like the marque and deciding to concentrate on that kind of misses the point doesn't it?