Another "what car" thread - which large 4x4?

Another "what car" thread - which large 4x4?

Author
Discussion

Pinky and Perky

Original Poster:

1,198 posts

256 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
Sorry for posting another What car thread but would really like some opinion and possibly other options to my question.
The wife and I are looking for a big 4x4 for towing duties.
We would prefer a 4x4 due to their stability when towing large trailers and weights,
and for the extra grip on offer during winter months (we live in a very rural area where roads are not gritted).
So what will be towed, a trailer and track day car (Alfa 155), but also horsebox and horses (largest horse is in excess of 900kg so need a large load lugger).
Not bothered about petrol or diesel as mileage is quite low (7-10k per annum), budget 10-15k 7 seats would be preferable but not a deal breaker. Would be looking at getting a warranty to cover any unexpected costs, so preferably under 10 years of age and under 100k miles. so I'm currently looking at the following.

Standard suspects
BMW X5
LR Range Rover or Discovery 3
Porsche Cayenne
VW Toureg
Outsiders
Toyota Amazon (very few available by the looks of it)
Nissan Pathfinder (not keen due to them being the 4x4 of choice localy).
Wife prefers the Disco or Pathfinder option due to 7 seat availability.
Any comments on the above choices would be welcome and also any other options I've not considered.

Lefty

16,177 posts

203 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
Shogun?
Patrol?
Defender?

All rated for 3500kg I think.

ishaun

23 posts

254 months

Friday 23rd September 2011
quotequote all
Just to add that the Pathfinder is an excellent choice for your needs. Have owned many 4x4s over the years and the Pathfinder is certainly one of the best. Great for towing, 7 seats with still room for a pram and luggage in the boot, luxury, mine has sat nav and leather, extremely reliable, has never let me down (touch wood). The latest model Discovery is also excellent but much more money. When you get one, make sure you get decent tyres, have fitted mine with Cooper Discoverer ATR, which never missed a beat last winter, even in the snow.