Cayman S vs SLK 55 AMG
Cayman S vs SLK 55 AMG
Author
Discussion

ebaneezer goode

Original Poster:

3 posts

182 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
Hi folks,

I'm thinking in trading in my Z4 Coupe for one of the above cars. They are both the same price. I prefer the looks of the Cayman but love the sound of the Merc's engine. The only problem with the Cayman is that its Tiptronic and a not manual. I dont mind it being Tiptronic as I had a Tiptronic Boxter S but could this effect it if I try to sell it in the future as you dont see many Tiptronic Caymans about. Going to test drive both of them on Saturday if they are both still for sale. What I would like to know is -

1)Has anyone driven both of these cars and which one did they prefer ?
2)Should I keep the Z4 and wait until the dealer gets a manual cayman in ?. They have one in at the moment but its too expensive.


jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
cant you sell yur z4 privately or trade it in at one of the many thousands of other dealers across the country ?

sounds like a very bizarre way to constrict your whole motoring life

Phooey

13,910 posts

200 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
ebaneezer goode said:
2)Should I keep the Z4 and wait until the dealer gets a manual cayman in ?
yes

I'm a big fan of auto's, but on something as sorted as the Cayman, it seems a shame to lose that driver interaction, which makes it such a great car.

craigjm

21,710 posts

231 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
They are a bit chalk and cheese. I have a Cayman S PDK now and love it. The SLK though, whilst fast is nowhere no as involving and isn't as practical and tiny inside. It is like driving a shoe (albeit a very fast one)

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
SLK = BIG GIRLS CAR!
Cayman = a real man's car

hope that sorts that out for ya!

khushy

Blue62

10,587 posts

183 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
6 years or so ago I traded my 997 C2S for a nearly new SL55, it was a hoot in a straight line but not so great in the handling department, a very different car to the Porsche. On the plus side it goes like a train, the roof was fun and it was comfortable. However, if it's driving thrills I would avoid, especially as they drink juice (13-17mpg) and they're not bomb proof, the supercharger causes a few problems - caveat emptor.

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
SLK is an auto I presume? Tip gearboxes and auto gearboxes hold no appeal for me at all - I'd wait for a manual personally. I've driven a Spyder PDK on track and loved it, but had a DSG box in my Scirocco and whilst it's good, I'd not go back from a short-shift kit Cayman S.

Blue62

10,587 posts

183 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
DELETED: Comment made by a member who's account has been deleted.
OOOOOPS, sorry I misread the title, thought it was the SL, not the SLK. Never driven an SLK so won't comment further, other than to ask if ownership requires the acquisition of a salon?

christer

2,804 posts

282 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
I had an SLK55AMG for 3 months last year. It is quite small but doesn't feel it when driving. Sure, great noise and decently fast but no match I would have thought for the Cayman driving dynamics (I haven't actually driven one). It is a fairly good cruiser but wasn't really for me as I am quite a big guy and always felt I looked a bit ridiculous in it biggrin I would definitely go manual on the Cayman, the box in the Merc is smooth but ultimately "cumbersome" when trying to push on. A good car for some though!

Let us know how you get on - and I echo the comments of thers who think you are limiting yourself by only considering one dealer......:O

christer

2,804 posts

282 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
I had an SLK55AMG for 3 months last year. It is quite small but doesn't feel it when driving. Sure, great noise and decently fast but no match I would have thought for the Cayman driving dynamics (I haven't actually driven one). It is a fairly good cruiser but wasn't really for me as I am quite a big guy and always felt I looked a bit ridiculous in it biggrin I would definitely go manual on the Cayman, the box in the Merc is smooth but ultimately "cumbersome" when trying to push on. A good car for some though!

Let us know how you get on - and I echo the comments of thers who think you are limiting yourself by only considering one dealer......:O

ebaneezer goode

Original Poster:

3 posts

182 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for your replys especially from Rob2005 who's driven both cars.

The reason I'm limiting myself to one dealer is that I live in Northern Ireland and we only have 1 OPC and 1 small independent who only has a 2.7 cayman for sale. I'll test drive the Tiptonic Cayman S and if I dont like it I may consider visiting an OPC in Scotland or the North of England.
I dont think I'll bother with the SLK with it being described as like driving a shoe ( probably a ladies shoe), camp and a big girls car as I was thinking that with it being an AMG it might make it less feminine though I'll probably still go and test drive it.

craigjm

21,710 posts

231 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
can you stretch to a gen2 Cayman S? the PDK gearbox is brilliant compared to the very average tiptronic. The gen 2 PDK with sports chrono plus is the one to go for but then I would say that biggrin

Peter Cee

90 posts

212 months

Thursday 15th September 2011
quotequote all
I had an SLK55 for a couple of years. Not an unmanly car at all. In black it looked the dogs bks and when you looked in the engine bay it was a gorgeous sight. Fantastic noise from the V8 like NASCAR distilled. Very quick (quicker than the 911 which I bought after it)with loads of grunt. Fantastic open air cruiser and super quiet and civilised with the top on, great for european touring. Quite capable handling and very good brakes but from a steering point of view a bit 'play station' with minimal feel. The gearbox was OK but had a bit of a mind of its own when pressing on over twisty country roads (no way as good as the current PDK box which is perfect in sports or sports plus mode)

I missed the feel and delicacy of a porsche so ended up replacing it with a 997 Targa 4S (couldn't bear to pay £75k for something with a canvas roof). Any porsche is a completely different animal than an SLK.

Eventually ditched the Targa as it wasn't really an open top car and ended up with a Boxster S PDK which is just as fast as the 997 but handles much better and with PDK and sport chrono is perfect for me.

To answer the original posters question : Get a Cayman S - or Boxster S if you want the wind in your hair.