More Cayman S advice (sorry!)
More Cayman S advice (sorry!)
Author
Discussion

TeamOfCarras

Original Poster:

3 posts

183 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
Basically I really want one. Max budget only about £26k so looking at a gen 1 2006 or 2007.

Have been in contact with a couple of OPCs who are making a lot of the fact they rev check the engines, strip the cars down, 2yr warranty etc.

I'm more tempted to get a car with a good history & 1yr warranty from an independent with a good rep and (try) to save a little bit of money.

Do the OPCs really offer that much over and above the way cars are prepared by reputable independents, and what are peoples experiences of going through this decision themselves?

I've read the forums extensively looked at a few cars, but can't decide what to do.



rog007

5,832 posts

255 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
It's about your attitude to risk, as well as your financial position. Of course we all want a bargain, and buying cheaply might be your biggest priority. The question that remains is, do you have the financial resources to be able to react if the worst happens? If you do, then private or independent purchase with limited (by time I mean) or no warranty may be fine for you. If the purchase means you have reached the limit of your financial envelope and so have little in reserve to react to the unforeseen, then a 'lesser' (older/higher mileage/lower spec etc) car but at an OPC price point with the protection of a 2-year manufacturer's warranty may be best for you.

Having bought private myself but with an extended OPC warranty attached, I felt I got the best of both worlds. The car has cost me outside of warranty but has also cost Porsche within the warranty; it's all part of the ownership experience!

Good luck!

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
For that kind of money I would not buy without a OPC or Hartech warranty. Although the cost of an engine rebuild will be the same whether regardless of car value...

Ideal scenario is to buy privately with an inspection and then get on the Hartech scheme, depending where you are.

The OPCs don't strip down the car, they inspect them but their standard are OK but nothing to shout about compared to a reputable indy.

Their cosmetic level of prep is pretty poor I find (compared to a proper correction) but still better than most dealers (that's not difficult.

You should be able to pick up a 2.9 privately well within your budget(but it would have to be a 987), that is still under OPC warranty.

Koing

442 posts

204 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
I'd look for a private with OPC extended on it for at least 1yr if not 2yrs. I would get an inspection on it also. That is the way I'm going to go for my purchase.

Koing

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
great car - be patient and you will find a cracker for your budget - BUT no OPC strips a car down - unless its in for a rebuild!

They do a 111 point check etc

khushy

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
DELETED: Comment made by a member who's account has been deleted.
There are loads to choose from but not many that have any value when it comes to the important IMS failure, it's OPC or Hartech really.

I prefer to buy privately as you can meet the owner, assess how he drives etc etc, and you don't have to deal with a dealer !

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
We have a Cayman S for sale at the moment. It was originally being advertised by the owner privately (with poor photos etc) who then traded it in to a BMW dealer for whom we had underwritten it. Following our advertising of the car, an OPC got in touch about buying it from us as it fitted the requirements of a customer they had. Our price is about the same as it was up for privately, the OPC said they'd be asking about £4000 than us (including their 2 year warranty).

So, the same car (with recent OPC major service, brake discs & pads a few months ago etc) potentially available 3 different ways (not simultaneously though) at different price points - clearly each would have its merits for different buyers, but demonstrates that there's not a fundamental difference between the actual car available through different sources.

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
I went OPC in the end - Comparing RSJ prices to OPC prices I couldn't find a huge margin - roughly the cost of a 2 year Porsche warranty in fact, and since East London Porsche are a lot closer to me than RSJ, and had one in the right colour, it became a no-brainer.

I certainly wouldn't rule an Indie out, but I'd factor in the cost of an official warranty too - an expensive car to fix if it really lets go.

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
The OPC warranty is imo worth its weight in gold.

For starters, being something you can transfer on a private sale, having it adds considerable value to your car. The 111 point inspection they do - whilst not up to Peter Morgan standards - is validation from Porsche themselves that your car is a safe buy.

Many people won't consider buying one of these cars without a warranty and imo selling privately having an OPC warranty makes your car as safe as buying from a dealer (it is after all the same warranty OPCs apply).

I was unlucky in so much as the car I wanted with all the options I was after was for sale by an independant and I was too impatient to wait for a similarly specced one to come up for sale at an OPC. I bought it and was given the obligatory tokenistic 3 month warranty coverage, which I suspected and later confirmed had various limitations (e.g. claim amount limit, etc). For that 3 months I had to wait before I could put it in for inspection and OPC warranty were like walking on eggshells. Buying from an indy for me was actually a bit of a false economy when factoring in the cost of the extended warranty, I don't think I saved any money in the long run.

Having had a full clean bill of health and 2 year warranty applied I cannot overstress the peace of mind this has given, and it is one of the few things you can get for the car which should retain pretty much all of its value to any new owner.

Can't speak for Hartech warranties but the fact Porsche provide an extended warranty service themselves and will recover your car from anywhere is invaluable.

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
+1 to Durzel's comments - I couldn't find a reason NOT to buy a Cayman from an OPC in the end. Think this might not hold quite so true with other models, 996 for example as there are so few in the network, but on a Cayman you should seriously consider OPC. The cheaper 987 S cars on 06 plates are now around 28-26k aren't they?

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
+1 to Durzel's comments - I couldn't find a reason NOT to buy a Cayman from an OPC in the end. Think this might not hold quite so true with other models, 996 for example as there are so few in the network, but on a Cayman you should seriously consider OPC. The cheaper 987 S cars on 06 plates are now around 28-26k aren't they?
You've kind of answered your own question there (see my post above). Some people would prefer to save a few grand and take a small risk - horses for courses though as ever. smile

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
'tis true. I bought a house the day after the Cayman and knew there'd be no cash in the kitty to pay for an expensive repair if one were to crop up, so insured myself against that risk. I wouldn't rule out an Indy by any means, but I'd always want that warranty. Some people are prepared to take a chance, however - my Boxster S was utterly faultless for the 18 months I had it for example, and so paying extra for an OPC (especially one as crap as Hatfield) was a false economy.

CrazyTurboBeast

168 posts

185 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
I bought one in may on a private sale and so far so good. I did have a check over it but really at 13000 miles you'd be hard pushed to find anything wrong with it.
Its got a good spec and the only thing I'm worried about is the ceramic brakes, but thats no different if you bought from an OPC with or without warranty.

I was lucky though and part of the reson I bought the car was cos I liked the car and the guy selling it. You have to weigh in all these factors if you are taking any risk. The seller worked away a lot and really looked after the car. The local OPC know the car and know it as a good one, some guys I know also know the seller and back him (albeit this was after buying)

So what I'm saying is its not just the car but also the seller/previous owner you need to look at.

I'm not convinced the porsche warranty is worth it as it doesn't cover parts. Surely that is going to be the biggest cost?

So really it doesn't matter OPC, warranty, independant or private as long as you make sure you check the car, owner and history.

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
If I add up all the money I have saved over the years by carefully buying privately rather than OPC and choosing not to run a warranty plus the ability NOT to use OPC for servicing, battery, etc etc, I end up with a figure that will pay for 2 engine rebuilds. The only failure that would have been under warranty that I ever had over 50,000 miles was a water pump (£350). Touch wood.
But that's a very personal choice and depends on attitude to risk and financial circumstances.

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
CrazyTurboBeast said:
I'm not convinced the porsche warranty is worth it as it doesn't cover parts. Surely that is going to be the biggest cost?
It doesn't cover consumables, but it would cover part failures. I was told, for example, that an oil leak would be covered.

nickfrog said:
If I add up all the money I have saved over the years by carefully buying privately rather than OPC and choosing not to run a warranty plus the ability NOT to use OPC for servicing, battery, etc etc, I end up with a figure that will pay for 2 engine rebuilds.
You could say that about any insurance policy though. If you don't end up using it then it's just sunk money, but if you do then - certainly from the point of engine rebuilds - you've saved far more money than you would otherwise have to spend.

I agree that if you have a slush fund on standby for the worst case scenario then you might as well chance your luck, but if you haven't got a few thousand lying about for an engine rebuild then for most people the peace of mind would be worth the cost. Let's not forget that pretty much any Porsche bill is going to run into a few hundred, especially factoring in the labour cost and relative inaccessibility of the engine, and the warranty itself isn't that onerously expensive when you consider the period of time you're covered.

Edited by Durzel on Wednesday 14th September 12:41

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
I agree with you and that's why I only insure my house (very cheap in relation to the value of the house) and my car.

As for cost of repairs/parts, they are high if you use OPC and Porsche branded parts but OE part and indy labour is very affordable.

Still, OPC warranty is relatively cheap particularly as a proportion of a £25k car or more, but for a car worth half that maybe not.

UVB

557 posts

224 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
I prefer to buy privately as you can meet the owner, assess how he drives etc etc, and you don't have to deal with a dealer !
+1 for that; a very good point often overlooked by many. When I was looking for mine I found the cars at OPC's seemed more expensive than the price of the warranty could justify. Ultimately it came down to finding the right car at the right price and at that time OPC's didn't have any that I wanted. Personally I'm happy to buy privately and take the risk to get a better spec car. It's not like you see Porsche's littered by the roadside with IMS failures and I haven't had any issues over 4x986 and my current Cayman. I actually paid more for the car I have now on the basis that it would be worth a similar amount more when it came time to sell (ie compared to paying less for an older one) and I'd have a lot more toys inside it to play with through the course of ownership. In essence, this one scored very well on the value end of the equation and was easy to justify the relatively small increase in budget to pay for it.

Personally I'd be happy buying the right car from an OPC but only if it was the right price. If an OPC gave me the choice of their warranty or a suitcase with £3k of cash in it, I'd take the suitcase every time given how reliable the cars are nowadays (it would have been the other way around with my old 944 Turbo...).

I'd probably be more comfortable buying from a Porsche indy as they truly live and die on their reputation so have to be very picky about stock and pricing levels not to mention customer service. It seems like some of the Porsche indies are an excellent example of how a car dealer should be.

Private sales...I find it easy to tell if a car is a good one or not but this isn't for everyone. I'd certainly rather buy a car privately than buy one from a general dealer who has no specific Porsche experience.

mayes911

6,085 posts

216 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
i agree with the buying privately as you never know how a car in a dealers has been treated if you met the owner you find out how fanatical some of us are about our cars.you also dont know if the car came from auction or was a snatch back.i wont do a link to my advert on here but basically you can buy a one owner low mileage 2008/9 cayman s for the price of a higher mileage 2006/7 dealer car money thats the same with any car.plus having looked on some dealers forecourts the detailing done on the cars is terrible(lots of swirl marks etc)some people love putting their cars through the cheap car washes which says a lot about how they look after their cars.
the only time i would maybe buy from a dealer is if i had a trade in or they had a car with spec. i wanted but then i would haggle hard.
as someone has already said buy with an outstanding warranty or have the seller do the 111point opc check and put a warranty on it and then it is as good as any opc car but cheaper
good luck

Edited by mayes911 on Wednesday 14th September 14:55

cooldude00

114 posts

190 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
looks like i may be in the minority here but i did pick up a Gen I CS from an OPC a month ago and for me, it was for peace of mind v buying from an independent like RSJ.

Firstly the prices aren't that different between RSJ and OPC.

Also since picking it up, i've had to call out Porsche Assist once and the car's been back to replace the temp guage and rattles in the rear.

no doubts i was disappointed that the car even had to go back in the first place 1 week after purchase but hey, it pretty much has an iron-clad 2 year warranty so just chucked the car back to let them sort it out.

and... i got an 11-plate Gen II CS with 1000 miles on the clock as a courtesy car which i wasn't expecting... my 2p worth


SFO

5,191 posts

214 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
cooldude00 said:
looks like i may be in the minority here but i did pick up a Gen I CS from an OPC a month ago and for me, it was for peace of mind v buying from an independent like RSJ.

Firstly the prices aren't that different between RSJ and OPC.

Also since picking it up, i've had to call out Porsche Assist once and the car's been back to replace the temp guage and rattles in the rear.

no doubts i was disappointed that the car even had to go back in the first place 1 week after purchase but hey, it pretty much has an iron-clad 2 year warranty so just chucked the car back to let them sort it out.

and... i got an 11-plate Gen II CS with 1000 miles on the clock as a courtesy car which i wasn't expecting... my 2p worth
you would get the same thing with a private sale if the car had the Porsche warranty.