997 turbo alternatives
997 turbo alternatives
Author
Discussion

NickBB

Original Poster:

77 posts

183 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
I know i'm preeching to the converted here, but...

I have an intermittent itch to have a 997 turbo (early one), which at some point will have to be scratched...

Like most of us, i go thru what cars i could own/would like to own... but i always come back to porsche/911...

So for 50k ish, what is the best alternative to a 997tt...

Aston... -ve more common than they used to be, running costs, not as sharp as a 911. Less reliable than a 911. +ve sound and look good.

Ferrari... -ve as above (may have to prostitute the kids to pay for runing costs). Not great for the tescos run. +ve less common than pork, looks, sound and performance.

Merc C63... not as good as an M3 to drive. And being under 50 rules it out argue

Sububishi... great performance for the money, but too lary for me

GTR... early ones have 6mth servicing...a PITA, too techy for me. (i read a thred on PH about a chap in a grt who nudged into the car in front. small dent on bumper, but set-off pedestrian safety systems etc.. anyway, cost 11k to fix!!). But tempting nonetheless just for sheer ability and performance.

RS4... dull (ive had an avant)

R8... out of price range, and anyway too twee for me. (and would have to be the V10 to compete on performance)

Probably the most "sensible" car is the M3 (ive had 2)... performance, handling, comfort, reliable etc... BUT.... ive had 5 911's, and when i look on the drive, i love em... but if it was an M3.. i look on the drive and just see a BMW 3 series....

I always seem to come back to a 911... you get performance, relatively low running costs (that's been my expereince), reliable, every-day car, great looks (not the best sound, tho of course its subjective) and despite the high production numbers these day, they are still a very special car.

Any other alternatives to the above??








Diesel130

1,549 posts

243 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
7.1 GT3 ?

NickBB

Original Poster:

77 posts

183 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
yes, considered that. I guess i put it in the general 911 catagory. My next car will almost certingly be a 997tt or 997 gt3. Was just going thru porsche alternatives i guess.

NickBB

Original Poster:

77 posts

183 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
Diesel130 said:
7.1 GT3 ?
now u got me...

this looks cool...


http://pistonheads.co.uk/sales/3217161.htm

Antarctic Mat

206 posts

233 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
Nick

I'm almost 2 weeks into a 997tt just get one bought! I looked at Maserati GranTurismo, superb noise but a bit soft, definitely on the cruiser end of the scale. Can't fault the looks though!

http://pistonheads.co.uk/sales/3226386.htm

I also looked at XFR but just a bit too much of a barge. The XKR is interesting.

http://pistonheads.co.uk/sales/3131383.htm

Ultimately though, the sheer power of the 997tt and the real drivability made it a no brainer for me.

I'm sure you'll enjoy whatever you get.

Cheers

Mat


NickBB

Original Poster:

77 posts

183 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
I'm sure you're right! It's only a matter of time. Must say i prefer the looks of the tt to the gt3, and obviously aside from that they are quite different cars. Just read the review on PH of the new Evora. But i cant help but think "kit car" ! I know what i'm going to end up with (in black!), i just feel like i should try something a bit different.. but nothing ticks all the boxes like a 911.. It has to be something i can use on long (holiday) trips, as well as blasting round the lanes and pottering about...

ps. agree about the maser

mm450exc

571 posts

209 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
There is no alternative. smile

mrdemon

21,146 posts

296 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
I looked at early 997 Turbo's but at 60k they were old and had a few miles on.
I bought a TTRS which is faster(with a tweek) and with 3 years warranty.
Main point is it's cheap as chips to run and faster than all the cars you have listed ;-)

Martian O

2,734 posts

193 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
An Audi TT, albeit an RS, as an alternative to a 997 Turbo? laugh

UVB

557 posts

224 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
Gallardos are getting close to that budget I think?

Wadeski

9,060 posts

244 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
Have a chat with the GTR owners on here about running costs, a few scare stories out there.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
mrdemon said:
I bought a TTRS which is faster(with a tweek) and with 3 years warranty.
Well that must be one hell of a tweak!

Peely

902 posts

250 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
mrdemon said:
I bought a TTRS which is faster(with a tweek) and with 3 years warranty.
Seriously ......... did you drive a 997 Turbo ?! confused

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
mrdemon said:
I looked at early 997 Turbo's but at 60k they were old and had a few miles on.
I bought a TTRS which is faster(with a tweek) and with 3 years warranty.
Main point is it's cheap as chips to run and faster than all the cars you have listed ;-)
Sounds like a Friday wind-up just to give everyone something to do this afternoonsmile

Crimp a Length!

5,697 posts

254 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
mrdemon said:
I bought a TTRS which is faster(with a tweek) and with 3 years warranty.
Well that must be one hell of a tweak!
hippy

Must be drugs or something.

Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
If looking for auto try and find a powerkit C4S PDK with sports chrono and PSE, better yet MrDemons Cayman was a bit of a beast if you can find it;)

NickBB

Original Poster:

77 posts

183 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
UVB said:
Gallardos are getting close to that budget I think?
True, but running costs and every-day driving might be an issue. Maybe an alternative if only used for weekends and roadtrips.

I once had a 996tt with serious tweaks, and i must admit i really miss the mind-bending speed of that thing, and the way it was delivered.

There's always the non-depreciation route... A late Honda NSX but nothing like the performance, tho u do get rarity.





Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
NickBB said:
UVB said:
Gallardos are getting close to that budget I think?
True, but running costs and every-day driving might be an issue. Maybe an alternative if only used for weekends and roadtrips.

I once had a 996tt with serious tweaks, and i must admit i really miss the mind-bending speed of that thing, and the way it was delivered.

There's always the non-depreciation route... A late Honda NSX but nothing like the performance, tho u do get rarity.
Gallardos are holding their values well and are generally reliable tho still no warranty available.

Koing

442 posts

204 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
GT3 imo.

Koing

Gibbo205

3,572 posts

238 months

Friday 16th September 2011
quotequote all
Hi there

MrDemond is not telling tales, a stage 1 remap takes them to circa 400BHP and a stage 2 results in circa 440-450BHP and the stage 2 pack with remap cost circa 2.5-3k I think.

However not sure where you'd stand on warranty after remapping, doing exhaust and other bits to achieve 440-450BHP on a TTRS should something like the engine or gearbox let go, doubt they will as its a great engine and strong box.

But fact is a TT RS running such power rivals a BMW M5 V10 in a straight line upto about 140-150MPH, I think a TTRS Manual with circa 450BHP is around 8.5-9s to 100mph, you have to remember they are only circa 1450kg.


However I test drove a TTRS and even though it was better than I expected and had great tuning ability I did find it not the most exciting drive and it was not special, I found my EVO X more engaging and thats saying something, yes I could have done suspension tweaks to the TT to improve it there, but you can tweak any car end of the day, plus it was still a TT end of day, albeit a special one, but its not a Porsche.

I then got into some Pork, I've test driven 997.1 TT, 997.1 C4S, 997.1 C2S, 997.2 C2S, 996.1 GT3, Cayman S and Cayman R. For me the Pork really deliver in the feel of the drive and how they make you feel. I love my 997.1 C2S, its a superbly fun and engaging car to drive both on road and track. Yeah a TTRS can be made faster easily wheras the C2S cannot be, but the TTRS with its front engine layout, 4WD drive can never match the involvement and wild horse feeling of RWD with engine in the back and for me thats why I got a 997 C2S. The only other car I'd consider now is a 997 GT3, the 997 Turbo had epic power but as daft as it sounds I found the 997 C2S more engaging and a much nicer sound, for me the C2S was the closest out of the 911's to how a GT3 drives, bear in mind I do have PCCB's, Aerokit, X51 parts etc.

Also a tweaked TT RS is as quick and maybe a tad quicker than a 997 Turbo upto circa 3 figures, but tweak the 997 Turbo which is also very easy to do and the TT RS will be left. So when the playing field is equal and both cars are tweaked, the Turbo 997 or even 996 will be taking the lead and giving the drive a much more engaging drive. smile

Edited by Gibbo205 on Friday 16th September 14:15