Porsche 996 Turbo - 4S
Porsche 996 Turbo - 4S
Author
Discussion

Wozy68

Original Poster:

5,436 posts

201 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
996 prices are just damn weird.

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3085531.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3147018.htm

Why? Ok one is more expensive to service than the other, but the Turbo engine is supposed to be the safe option for reliability.

Both models seem a bit of a bargain at the moment, I will be in the market for either next year and at these prices I'm erring through fun factor for the turbo. ....... or am I wrong?

_gez_

1,013 posts

225 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
Not that it is that relevant but there is 3 years age difference between them. The turbo looks good value if there are no immediate big bills required (suspension, brakes, etc).

Also note that many people have reported cheaper insurance on a turbo!

Sunnysidebb

1,385 posts

198 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
Its obvious, IMHO ( small print) the Turbo owner got screwed with the trade in. The garage doesn't give a st so long as they make a profit and sell quickly. If the turbo is £23k what did the dealer give the last owner for it.

(this reply is the expressed opinion of me and in no way is a statement of fact. phew.....)

6C4GTS

5,186 posts

209 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
4S does not appear to have PSE therfore removing the only advantage (looks are personal taste) over the turbo - buy the turbo!

cardigankid

8,880 posts

243 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
The C4S is 2004, in a good colour, but doesn't have switchable sports exhaust. The Turbo is a 2001, in a good colour, but doesn't have sports seats, without which, frankly, I wouldn't buy a 911. QED, nothing weird about it. On this occasion, on balance, I would take the C4S and add a 'zorst.

Sunnysidebb

1,385 posts

198 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
cardigankid said:
The C4S is 2004, in a good colour, but doesn't have switchable sports exhaust. The Turbo is a 2001, in a good colour, but doesn't have sports seats, without which, frankly, I wouldn't buy a 911. QED, nothing weird about it. On this occasion, on balance, I would take the C4S and add a 'zorst.
Interesting, would you really choose the 4s over the turbo just because the turbo hasn't got sports seats.
Have you ever driven a Turbo? I have a turbo but have driven the 4s and well, no comparison. It seems less responsive then a C2. As to the 4s being newer its only relative there both getting on a bit compared to a new car. That difference in age wont guarantee a more reliable ride.imo.

Just for topical discussion, would you like to expand as to why the 4s would get your vote?



Edited by Sunnysidebb on Saturday 17th September 20:29

StuB

6,695 posts

270 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
Having driven a good few miles, 1 VMax (191 mph) & 3 trackdays in my modded 996tt this year (acquired Dec 10), I can't see how a n/a car can be compared, unless you don't intend to explore the potential.

If you drive at say 75% max, then why bother with a turbo? Surely a c4s covers all the bases for a majority.

StuB

6,695 posts

270 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
Having driven a good few miles, 1 VMax (191 mph) & 3 trackdays in my modded 996tt this year (acquired Dec 10), I can't see how a n/a car can be compared, unless you don't intend to explore the potential.

If you drive at say 75% max, then why bother with a turbo? Surely a c4s covers all the bases for a majority.

Sunnysidebb

1,385 posts

198 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
StuB said:
Having driven a good few miles, 1 VMax (191 mph) & 3 trackdays in my modded 996tt this year (acquired Dec 10), I can't see how a n/a car can be compared, unless you don't intend to explore the potential.

If you drive at say 75% max, then why bother with a turbo? Surely a c4s covers all the bases for a majority.
I don't even think you have to drive at 75% . I once heard Jackie Stewart ( who I had great respect for) say he cant understand why anyone would want to have a very powerful and fast car on the road. Well its all very well and good for him, who has experienced the thrill of power and acceleration. But for us mere mortals, we are never going to be privalaged enought to have that experience. So my car is at Kens atm and I hope it will come out with as near to 700 bhp as possible. It doesn't mean I am going to drive at 200+ mph. What I want is to be able to drive the car and feel that gut lifting wrench to the stomach when I drop a gear and over take a truck or something similar and keep as safe as possible. With my new PSS10's I could do a few track days as well.
Its not about percentages of how fast you drive but the experience in having the iconic 911 Turbo if only for a small window in you life.

6C4GTS

5,186 posts

209 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
Sunnysidebb said:
StuB said:
Having driven a good few miles, 1 VMax (191 mph) & 3 trackdays in my modded 996tt this year (acquired Dec 10), I can't see how a n/a car can be compared, unless you don't intend to explore the potential.

If you drive at say 75% max, then why bother with a turbo? Surely a c4s covers all the bases for a majority.
I don't even think you have to drive at 75% . I once heard Jackie Stewart ( who I had great respect for) say he cant understand why anyone would want to have a very powerful and fast car on the road. Well its all very well and good for him, who has experienced the thrill of power and acceleration. But for us mere mortals, we are never going to be privalaged enought to have that experience. So my car is at Kens atm and I hope it will come out with as near to 700 bhp as possible. It doesn't mean I am going to drive at 200+ mph. What I want is to be able to drive the car and feel that gut lifting wrench to the stomach when I drop a gear and over take a truck or something similar and keep as safe as possible. With my new PSS10's I could do a few track days as well.
Its not about percentages of how fast you drive but the experience in having the iconic 911 Turbo if only for a small window in you life.
Frank with your background in Fast Fords it seems strange to use a tip as a starting point for what seems like a very potent project. Was there a reason why you went for the tip box?

Moosh

1,122 posts

252 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
Sunnysidebb said:
feel that gut lifting wrench to the stomach when I drop a gear and over take a truck or something similar and keep as safe as possible.
+1 thumbup



Edited by Moosh on Saturday 17th September 22:13

willmac

2,096 posts

195 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all
Both good cars and great value at the moment.

Unless you need the turbo acceleration adrenalin rush, a C4S fitted with PSE will in most cases will certainly sound better, and with this means you don't have to be doing crazy speeds to hear the Flat 6 doing it's thing.

Insurance surprisingly cheap on 996 Turbos for what it is capable of. Main reason for that I reckon is that they are such an easy car to drive, your granny could probably do warp speeds safely.

Sunnysidebb

1,385 posts

198 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all
6C4GTS said:
Sunnysidebb said:
StuB said:
Having driven a good few miles, 1 VMax (191 mph) & 3 trackdays in my modded 996tt this year (acquired Dec 10), I can't see how a n/a car can be compared, unless you don't intend to explore the potential.

If you drive at say 75% max, then why bother with a turbo? Surely a c4s covers all the bases for a majority.
I don't even think you have to drive at 75% . I once heard Jackie Stewart ( who I had great respect for) say he cant understand why anyone would want to have a very powerful and fast car on the road. Well its all very well and good for him, who has experienced the thrill of power and acceleration. But for us mere mortals, we are never going to be privalaged enought to have that experience. So my car is at Kens atm and I hope it will come out with as near to 700 bhp as possible. It doesn't mean I am going to drive at 200+ mph. What I want is to be able to drive the car and feel that gut lifting wrench to the stomach when I drop a gear and over take a truck or something similar and keep as safe as possible. With my new PSS10's I could do a few track days as well.
Its not about percentages of how fast you drive but the experience in having the iconic 911 Turbo if only for a small window in you life.
Frank with your background in Fast Fords it seems strange to use a tip as a starting point for what seems like a very potent project. Was there a reason why you went for the tip box?
The honest answer is the whole purchase was a bit disorganised.
I had a Turbo Cayenne with the S power upgrade than a stage 2 upgrade on that . It was near 600 bhp and a monster. However it had nothing but electrical problems. I had the car in for 11 warranty repairs in 12 months so I spat my dummy and took it back to the OPC in a rage spouting I didn't want the piece of $hit any more. I would have got a better value for the car if I put it against another car. There was a 911 Turbo in at the time and I bought it on the spot so to speak. As it happens it was a Tip. The Cayanne had been a Tip so I suppose I had got used to them.
Since then I have been through the phase of regretting buying a Tip car. As you say , my background has predominantly been Manual. However after 5 years of ownership I have grown to like ( not love) but like my Tip. It does have advantages when driving. I akin it to a GPA WRC car with sequential gear change. OK not quite but you do keep your hands on the wheel when the bumps in the road are launching you from side to side.( Closed Scottish estate roads. LOL). Ken has it now and its got a MKB Box and tCU upgrade so should be some machine.
Don't get me wrong, I still miss a Manual change from time to time, but my 911 still brings a big smile to my face. Especially when I read how many miles Manual Cars dont do on a Clutch.lol



Edited by Sunnysidebb on Sunday 18th September 08:19


Edited by Sunnysidebb on Sunday 18th September 08:49

clive993

94 posts

219 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all
Never driven a 4s so can't comment. I bought a X50 Turbo then added a sports exhuast and re map. I dont drive it at anything like its full potential, in fact I dont think you can on the roads.

However every now and then when the chance comes, experiencing not far short of savage acceleration is a total hoot ! Knowing its there when you want it is almost as good as experiencing it. Had i gone for the 4s I would always be thiking 'what if' regards the Turbo.

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all

The C4S is a good car, and good vfm at the moment, but the turbo does everything the C4S does and so much more. I think the turbo looks the better of the two, and With a sports exhaust the turbo can sound almost as good.
Then you add in the performance increase and the more reliable engine and it really is no comparison to my mind.

(Did anyone have a poster of a 'Porsche C4S' on their wall as a child?!? biggrin )

ukgatecrasher

50 posts

220 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all
clive993 said:
However every now and then when the chance comes, experiencing not far short of savage acceleration is a total hoot ! Knowing its there when you want it is almost as good as experiencing it. Had i gone for the 4s I would always be thiking 'what if' regards the Turbo.
I would have most defiantly regretted not going for the turbo if I had gone C4S, maybe not immediately but definatly 6 months down the line when the novelty had worn off.

Captain Barnacle

20 posts

182 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all
Had a 4s for a year, before I traded in for a turbo! Still got the Turbo and love it!

Don't get me wrong the 4s was a lovely car, but at the back of my mind was this could be better, and it is!

Just for overtaking ability alone!

I would save a bit longer and get a newer turbo if possible!


maxpaul

451 posts

235 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all
Hi
Yust bought a 2003 turbo with the manual box after going down the Boxster route for a year.
Previous car was a C4S also 2003 and for my return to the 911 fold it just had to be the Turbo.
Not just the power, and I do miss the PSE sound on the 4S but in the back of my mind I would always be thinking of the engine going pop! Its also a box that needed to be ticked and would have always thought what if had I made a return to wher I had been before.

rimkah

1,057 posts

197 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all
If keeping stock and driving in town C4S the responsiveness and pse sounds are made for it.

If modding and for autobahn then turbo

S1MMA

2,451 posts

250 months

Sunday 18th September 2011
quotequote all
My personal view:

996 C4S is a tarts car. Why? Because it's the slowest heaviest N/A non cab 996. People buy them because they look like a turbo (minus the gash rear wing and vents all over the shop - I disagree with this but there are plenty out there that agree with this statement), they like the red strip connecting the brake lights at the back, and they used to be a fair bit cheaper than a Turbo to buy whilst being well specced.

If you want a N/A drivers 911 and don't want to stretch to GT3 money, it has to be a 996 C2. Same power as C4S, lighter, RWD so more power to the wheels. May not look the part, but will go the part.

If you want the specific C4S looks, that's the only real reason to buy one IMO. Now they are similar to turbo money, I would take a turbo over the lardy C4S with C2 power. C4S cab must have the worst BHP/Tonne in the whole 996 range, at least they gave the 997 S/C4S more power...

When I was looking for my first Porsche, it was between a 996 C4S and a Cayman S. One drive of the Cayman S and I knew immediately which car to get. It wasn't the 911.