What can I do to calm my nerves regarding a C4S purchase?
Discussion
Horror stories about engines blowing up etc. People driving these upto 100k and nowt going wrong etc....
Having spoken to Baz at hartech a long time ago he did calm my nerves, although they have a dedicated section for these engines now. However I am unsure whether to follow a purchase of a C4S through due to potential problems...
Say I buy the car. Is there anything I can do to prevent the engine failing?
I know in the US they have modified bearings etc to help prevent it occurring. Do Hartech do a similar thing?
Bear in mind I'll probably be putting 6k miles a year on the car over weekends...
Would a retrofit kit even assuage my worries...?
Heart over peace of mind?
feck knows
Having spoken to Baz at hartech a long time ago he did calm my nerves, although they have a dedicated section for these engines now. However I am unsure whether to follow a purchase of a C4S through due to potential problems...
Say I buy the car. Is there anything I can do to prevent the engine failing?
I know in the US they have modified bearings etc to help prevent it occurring. Do Hartech do a similar thing?
Bear in mind I'll probably be putting 6k miles a year on the car over weekends...
Would a retrofit kit even assuage my worries...?
Heart over peace of mind?
feck knows

Edited by Tyson1980 on Monday 19th September 22:28
Greg66 said:
Hartech will reline the cylinders, won't they? Get that done as a preventative measure.
Or buy a warranty.
Or get a turbo.
In my experience all warranties are not worth the money they are printed on. What's different with Porsche?Or buy a warranty.
Or get a turbo.
Turbo is a major consideration. Prices are pretty much inline with c4s give or take I suppose... Sports seats and sports exhaust a must. Spec is critical..
Tyson1980 said:
In my experience all warranties are not worth the money they are printed on. What's different with Porsche?
Turbo is a major consideration. Prices are pretty much inline with c4s give or take I suppose... Sports seats and sports exhaust a must. Spec is critical..
Don't think you can get PSE on the turbo. You'd have to look at a third party option. Turbo is a major consideration. Prices are pretty much inline with c4s give or take I suppose... Sports seats and sports exhaust a must. Spec is critical..
Wills2 said:
Just buy it from an OPC as it will come with a 2 year Porsche warranty, you can then extend it after that period, if the engine goes pop it will be covered.
That will work but the extra cost of the purchase price/warranty renewal will probably = the cost of a Hartech rebuild.You dont get anything for nothing with Porsche. And to be fair, why should you?
FWIW I wouldnt buy a non Mezger 911 but if I did, it would go on a maintenance plan which is a more robust and economic solution than a warranty.
MTR
Edited by mollytherocker on Monday 19th September 23:58
I think most of the problems were with 3.4 engines, not the 3.6? I did hear about 3.6 engines going wrong too, but not as common.
I had an '02 C4S and had no issues with it whatsoever. I sold it with 40k odd miles, can't remember exactly as it was around 18 months ago.
If you are going to buy the car and worry about it, then don't buy it, you'll never be able to relax and enjoy it. If the worry of a rebuild is at the back of your mind, you'll constantly be listening for weird noises, wondering if you noticed an extra wisp of smoke on start up, the exhaust note changing blah blah blah!
Either that or just go for the Turbo. Stronger engine and almost the same money these days!!
I had an '02 C4S and had no issues with it whatsoever. I sold it with 40k odd miles, can't remember exactly as it was around 18 months ago.
If you are going to buy the car and worry about it, then don't buy it, you'll never be able to relax and enjoy it. If the worry of a rebuild is at the back of your mind, you'll constantly be listening for weird noises, wondering if you noticed an extra wisp of smoke on start up, the exhaust note changing blah blah blah!
Either that or just go for the Turbo. Stronger engine and almost the same money these days!!
Tyson1980 said:
In my experience all warranties are not worth the money they are printed on. What's different with Porsche?
Turbo is a major consideration. Prices are pretty much inline with c4s give or take I suppose... Sports seats and sports exhaust a must. Spec is critical..
Honestly? Critical?Turbo is a major consideration. Prices are pretty much inline with c4s give or take I suppose... Sports seats and sports exhaust a must. Spec is critical..
Tyson1980 said:
In my experience all warranties are not worth the money they are printed on. What's different with Porsche?
At risk of stating the bleeding obvious, the Porsche warranty will pay for an engine rebuild if your worst fears are realised... I can't think of any better way to calm your nerves.Again what is the actual number of 996/997 engine going pop?
1 in 5,000? 1 in 10,000?
Don't think twice, buy the best one you can afford and stop worrying!
Or buy from OPC and pay a little more for the piece of mind.
Or keep dreaming and asking yourself how ypour life would have been with a Porsche.
This subject's been covered over and over here! Next dreamer please...
Note: I'd like to thank PHead and Hartech for creating the paranoia around a subject which doesn't deserve any - every car maker will suffer from a very few engine going pop, but no one will advertise it.
1 in 5,000? 1 in 10,000?
Don't think twice, buy the best one you can afford and stop worrying!
Or buy from OPC and pay a little more for the piece of mind.
Or keep dreaming and asking yourself how ypour life would have been with a Porsche.
This subject's been covered over and over here! Next dreamer please...
Note: I'd like to thank PHead and Hartech for creating the paranoia around a subject which doesn't deserve any - every car maker will suffer from a very few engine going pop, but no one will advertise it.
Edited by 911Thrasher on Tuesday 20th September 07:33
Look at this thread here
Couple of points:
We are a small community and the figures will by no means be 100% accurate.......but
They will show a trend, a trend based on experience of people who visit this site who are far more likely to have come into contact in one way or another with cars that fail or have problems. Currently the figures show a 10% failure rate, my money would however be on a significantly lower rate if we could be made aware of all failures.
Evren if it were 10%, I'd not lose any sleep over it.
There are thousands of other Porsche drivers who don't visit the likes of PH and have a perfectly good, servicable car that they enjoy, all day, every day.
There is currently no Class Action against Porsche with reference to a major engine problem (something the Americans think about everytime their Rice Crispies get soggy at breakfast time, and they buy them as well you know
)
You can buy a warranty from a number of reputable sources which gives you complete peace of mind so you can stop worrying about big bills
Cars break and fail - all cars can can break and Porsche is no exception.
If you intend to run a car and have deeper concerns about running costs (which may be in the back of your mind, warranty, servicing, depreciation etc), then perhaps a Porsche isn't for you, go and buy a Ford, the forum is here
Either do it, or don't, but don't waste time worrying about something that is highly likely not to affect you.
Couple of points:
We are a small community and the figures will by no means be 100% accurate.......but
They will show a trend, a trend based on experience of people who visit this site who are far more likely to have come into contact in one way or another with cars that fail or have problems. Currently the figures show a 10% failure rate, my money would however be on a significantly lower rate if we could be made aware of all failures.
Evren if it were 10%, I'd not lose any sleep over it.There are thousands of other Porsche drivers who don't visit the likes of PH and have a perfectly good, servicable car that they enjoy, all day, every day.
There is currently no Class Action against Porsche with reference to a major engine problem (something the Americans think about everytime their Rice Crispies get soggy at breakfast time, and they buy them as well you know
)You can buy a warranty from a number of reputable sources which gives you complete peace of mind so you can stop worrying about big bills
Cars break and fail - all cars can can break and Porsche is no exception.
If you intend to run a car and have deeper concerns about running costs (which may be in the back of your mind, warranty, servicing, depreciation etc), then perhaps a Porsche isn't for you, go and buy a Ford, the forum is here
Either do it, or don't, but don't waste time worrying about something that is highly likely not to affect you.
911Thrasher said:
Note: I'd like to thank PHead and Hartech for creating the paranoia around a subject which doesn't deserve any - every car maker will suffer from a very few engine going pop, but no one will advertise it.
dont bite the hand that feeds. its the people that post not those guys is it? for one i value the community here and accept that human nature is what it is and sometimes things get blown out of context. on hartech i think baz's experience and insight is very much welcomed here. if you dont like what you read move on because im not sure your view is in the majorityEdited by 911Thrasher on Tuesday 20th September 07:33
HoHoHo said:
Look at this thread here
Couple of points:
We are a small community and the figures will by no means be 100% accurate.......but
They will show a trend, a trend based on experience of people who visit this site who are far more likely to have come into contact in one way or another with cars that fail or have problems. Currently the figures show a 10% failure rate, my money would however be on a significantly lower rate if we could be made aware of all failures.
Evren if it were 10%, I'd not lose any sleep over it.
There are thousands of other Porsche drivers who don't visit the likes of PH and have a perfectly good, servicable car that they enjoy, all day, every day.
There is currently no Class Action against Porsche with reference to a major engine problem (something the Americans think about everytime their Rice Crispies get soggy at breakfast time, and they buy them as well you know
)
You can buy a warranty from a number of reputable sources which gives you complete peace of mind so you can stop worrying about big bills
Cars break and fail - all cars can can break and Porsche is no exception.
If you intend to run a car and have deeper concerns about running costs (which may be in the back of your mind, warranty, servicing, depreciation etc), then perhaps a Porsche isn't for you, go and buy a Ford, the forum is here
Either do it, or don't, but don't waste time worrying about something that is highly likely not to affect you.
Thanks for the top advice. Looking at that thread seems refreshing..Couple of points:
We are a small community and the figures will by no means be 100% accurate.......but
They will show a trend, a trend based on experience of people who visit this site who are far more likely to have come into contact in one way or another with cars that fail or have problems. Currently the figures show a 10% failure rate, my money would however be on a significantly lower rate if we could be made aware of all failures.
Evren if it were 10%, I'd not lose any sleep over it.There are thousands of other Porsche drivers who don't visit the likes of PH and have a perfectly good, servicable car that they enjoy, all day, every day.
There is currently no Class Action against Porsche with reference to a major engine problem (something the Americans think about everytime their Rice Crispies get soggy at breakfast time, and they buy them as well you know
)You can buy a warranty from a number of reputable sources which gives you complete peace of mind so you can stop worrying about big bills
Cars break and fail - all cars can can break and Porsche is no exception.
If you intend to run a car and have deeper concerns about running costs (which may be in the back of your mind, warranty, servicing, depreciation etc), then perhaps a Porsche isn't for you, go and buy a Ford, the forum is here
Either do it, or don't, but don't waste time worrying about something that is highly likely not to affect you.
Wills2 said:
Just buy it from an OPC as it will come with a 2 year Porsche warranty, you can then extend it after that period, if the engine goes pop it will be covered.
If we're talking about a 996 C4S (I don't think the OP ever stated this?) then there are very few still in the OPC network and the few that crop up are ridiculously expensive - like £30K+ expensive.Best bet would be to buy one privately with an extended Porsche warranty (not many of these around either) or go on the Hartech maintenance plan. If you buy from a dealer make sure they are a well respected Porsche specialist.
Another alternative to buying from an OPC, is to buy from a Dealer like Paragon in Sussex or 911-Sport in Lincolnshire; these guys offer their own comprehensive warranty which as I understand, offers pretty much the same cover as an OPC one.
I've used Paragon in the past and found them excellent although a bit expensive; no personal experience of 911-Sport.
A few years ago, I had the same predicament, and went from a 997 to a 996 turbo, although I now have a 993; both the turbo & 993 are brilliant cars, but if you go for a turbo, make sure usual jobs like rads etc. have been done.
Good Luck.
I've used Paragon in the past and found them excellent although a bit expensive; no personal experience of 911-Sport.
A few years ago, I had the same predicament, and went from a 997 to a 996 turbo, although I now have a 993; both the turbo & 993 are brilliant cars, but if you go for a turbo, make sure usual jobs like rads etc. have been done.
Good Luck.
Never buy a car based on what you read on forums about faults. People on forums are a very small minority of car buyers and people tend to join some of these places to get help with problems and therefore the impact of the problems are amplified. Its like looking up somewhere you are going on holiday on sites like Tripadvisor. Someone will have had a horror story and you will focus on that. People don't tend to post online that they are ecstatic happy and gushing with their cars on a regular basis. How many, I love my car threads do you see vs I have a problem?
911Thrasher said:
Again what is the actual number of 996/997 engine going pop?
1 in 5,000? 1 in 10,000?
Don't think twice, buy the best one you can afford and stop worrying!
Or buy from OPC and pay a little more for the piece of mind.
Or keep dreaming and asking yourself how ypour life would have been with a Porsche.
This subject's been covered over and over here! Next dreamer please...
Note: I'd like to thank PHead and Hartech for creating the paranoia around a subject which doesn't deserve any - every car maker will suffer from a very few engine going pop, but no one will advertise it.
+11 in 5,000? 1 in 10,000?
Don't think twice, buy the best one you can afford and stop worrying!
Or buy from OPC and pay a little more for the piece of mind.
Or keep dreaming and asking yourself how ypour life would have been with a Porsche.
This subject's been covered over and over here! Next dreamer please...
Note: I'd like to thank PHead and Hartech for creating the paranoia around a subject which doesn't deserve any - every car maker will suffer from a very few engine going pop, but no one will advertise it.
Edited by 911Thrasher on Tuesday 20th September 07:33
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


