Thoughts on PDK
Author
Discussion

HoHoHo

Original Poster:

15,406 posts

281 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
I've got a Boxster S for the day with PDK whilst mine is in for some work and in my drive back to work and to the local shops I'm really impressed so far. I think based on my 45 minutes so far I would definitely look for a car with PDK when I change next.

Gear change is smooth in full auto, great when using manually and it suits the car.....with a caveat....

Who on earth designed the stupid buttons on the steering wheel confused, they are absolutely bloody awful. I guess the levers on the back of the 'newer' steering wheel will finish it off and help the experience.

I've had a 535D with paddles which was a pretty slick gearbox, and this is every bit as good (obviously better as it's a porka!)

The PCM 3 is also a step up from the PCM 2 in my 07 C2S!

Comments from owners on a day to day basis appreciated!

Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
Paddle Shift is 'must have' - retro-speccable, I believe.

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
I really like mine and I think its as involving as a manual, depending on how you drive it and how you choose to change gear - there is a technique to it to do it smoothly.

The paddles "make" the car without question.

IsItACatInAHat

73 posts

196 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
I *loved* the PDK in the Boxster S loan car I had last year from my OPC. The only downside was a very slight delay between putting your foot down and anything happening when starting from rest. Apart from that, I was convinced I'd have to have it.

Then I tried a boggo brand new 911 last month (w/ Sport Chrono and PDK) and it just didn't suit it as well, I came away from that thinking that I really preferred a manual. The Boxster still felt chuckable and fun even with PDK, but the 911 just didn't come across as a sports car with it. Both had paddles, I used them almost exclusively apart from a bit of pottering around town.

My £0.02 though, your mileage may vary!

betternotbigger

1,059 posts

206 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
I have PDK paddles, Sports Chrono+ and Sports PASM on my GTS and my goodness is it bonkers fast and every inch a sports car. The extra horses (only 5 less than a 997.1 GT3?) and the stiffened suspension make a hell of a difference to the feel whether you're trundling around town or letting rip on the twisties.

I know it's not a GT3 but it is an absolute animal when you give it the beans. You can fire it at a hairpin in 4th gear, brake late with a tug, tug and you're in 2nd with a rev-matched snarl of the exhaust, then launch out the apex with the rev counter spinning clockwise, a metallic snort from the pipes, tug, and you're in third... a blood-curling scream from behind your shoulder, tug, fourth in an instant... a bellowing growl, tug, and fifth gear despatches you into the distance.... f@ck me this car is something else.

And it's the combination of the PDK with the suspension that makes it special (note I didn't say better, I like manual Porsches just as much). It just feels so focused with your hands locked in position and all the sensations channeling through the wheel into your fingers. Mmmm... cloud9

Edited by betternotbigger on Wednesday 21st September 18:10

Carl_Docklands

15,831 posts

293 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all

I am in the minority who never used paddles before so, the buttons are a great system for me, I can move up and down gear very instinctively and maintain a tight grip on the wheel as i am turning.

It took me about 6 months for me to bond with the system but, no looking back now.

craigjm

21,702 posts

231 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
PDK is probably the best gearbox you can buy full stop but to get the best from it needs sports chrono plus.

I have a cayman s with it and its brilliant in all modes and is like a different car depending on what you select. the buttons on the wheel are a good idea when you get used to them as you can use either to go both up or down which makes it easier changing when wheel isn't straight. Paddles are required for most though but then you can't have a multifunction wheel

Manks

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
Carl_Docklands said:
I am in the minority who never used paddles before so, the buttons are a great system for me, I can move up and down gear very instinctively and maintain a tight grip on the wheel as i am turning.

It took me about 6 months for me to bond with the system but, no looking back now.
I have used buttons and paddles and preferred the buttons, frankly, they are really easy to use and tidy. I suspect the "must have paddles" argument has been driven as much by the motoring press as anything else.

craigjm

21,702 posts

231 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
I think the must have paddles argument is based on people being used to them and one going up and one down. As the switches are just that you could wire them in the same pattern no problem.

GT3ZZZ

1,007 posts

201 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
Done a few thousand miles in my Turbo S and have barely used the paddles. The map in sport mode is perfect for fast road use, both up and down the box its hard to fault it.

craigjm

21,702 posts

231 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
yeah i hardly use my paddles either. Sports plus mode is mental too but great fun on the right road

Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
I've been driving 997 C2S pdk for a month now, and really rate it(the gearbox). The speed of the shift allows it to take on cars with more power, I think that I would be able to take on a stock manual 996 turbo especially from standstill.

Normal mode makes it feel like the old tiptronic, though tiptronic is smoother in traffic and parking scenerios. Sport is best for normal driving and sport + for when on it. I'm comfortable with the buttons as I am used to tiptronic.

As a daily drive hard to think what could beat it on the road. A manual car is more engaging true but doubt would be quicker in equivalent car.

Edited by Callughan on Thursday 22 September 00:16

DS240

5,784 posts

249 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
Test drove boxster spyder with pdk and hated it. Ruined the whole car I thought.

The manual version is a different, better drive. IMO.

My latest plan is I don't want to buy another car until I can afford a Ferrari 458, in many many years time. So better get used to the idea of these gearboxes.

Got a feeling they make a whole more sense in something so fast and powerful.

wtdoom

3,742 posts

239 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
458 box also very refined .

MB 1

525 posts

216 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
I used to be an absolute purist when it came to gearboxes, but I think with the power a lot of cars have now, a manual box doesn't suit.

The best of the bunch is the GTR imo - amazing.

The car that convinced me though, was the new Carerra GTS. Very nice system, and the launch control was a nice touch! If I didn't have a GT3, I think any other Porker I ave would be the new PDK. The older version was utter turd IMO, and counter intuitive.

Other ones I didn't think were so good, were the F430 and V8 Vantage. These aren't dual clutch jobs though.

Edited by MB 1 on Thursday 22 September 03:01

HoHoHo

Original Poster:

15,406 posts

281 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
All sounds very positive, cheers.

Got back into my C2S and it was still wonderful but I was mightly impressed with the PDK box to the point where I started looking on various websites for a PDK 997 with a suitable spec.........

I must resist....

I must resist....

wink

freedman

6,019 posts

238 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
I wouldnt have it withouut paddles, competely counter intuitive, to me at least

HoHoHo

Original Poster:

15,406 posts

281 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
freedman said:
I wouldnt have it withouut paddles, competely counter intuitive, to me at least
Totally agree from my experience with my 535D the paddles always seemed to work pretty well)

If (and when) I change, the wheel with paddles is under a grand to have fitted, so if the right spec car was about, the paddles is a problem that can be solved.

Scelto

619 posts

188 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
freedman said:
I wouldnt have it withouut paddles, competely counter intuitive, to me at least
There a stick as well. You push it forwards to change up, and backwards to change down.

I find that perfectly intuitive.

Except when I try to shift up and realise that I'm in auto mode, slipping the box into neutral with lots of head-turning from everyone around... I actually saw somebody duck once - gotta love PSE wink

FWIW, I find paddles better than buttons, but not so much better that I'm willing to cough up for a retro-fit.

As for what it's like to live with... well, we've done that a few times even since I've been here, but suffice to say that I wouldn't buy one without now.

Manks

28,176 posts

253 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
freedman said:
I wouldnt have it withouut paddles, competely counter intuitive, to me at least
Have you driven a PDK car with buttons and another with paddles?

Using steering wheel mounted gearchange is counter-intuitive when you're used to a stick shift. But you get used to it. The buttons are different from paddles and you get used to them.

The advantage I felt with the buttons was that both sides do the same thing (useful when you end up with the wheel upside down), physical movement is minimal and it's difficult to knock them accidentally. I drive a car with paddle shift every day and sometimes I knock the car into command shift mode by clipping a paddle, which is annoying.

I suspect that if Porsche had stuck with buttons the hullabaloo would have died down and people would by now be saying how good they are. But journalists tutted and insisted they'd got it wrong and people who base their opinions on what journos write, I suspect in many cases without ever having driven a PDK car, condemned the buttons as being counter-intuitive.