Discussion
I've heard a couple of stories today that seem a bit...odd.
Chap I know took his 996c4 to an OPC with a failing wheel bearing.
Service advisor told him that when one wheel bearing needs replaced, the bearing on the other side needs done too. Somewhat confused, the chap asked to speak to a technician who said it wasn't true.
And, a few weeks later:
His car needed 3 hours "investigative" labour to diagnose a warning light. When he spoke to the technician to query, he was told that the propblem had been fixed in 10 minutes of the car being looked at.
He's not very impressed, unsurprisingly. Could there be any truth to the first example? I'm no mechanic but can't imagine why on earth you would have to change the opposite bearing at the same time.
Is this kind of behaviour generally commonplace?
Chap I know took his 996c4 to an OPC with a failing wheel bearing.
Service advisor told him that when one wheel bearing needs replaced, the bearing on the other side needs done too. Somewhat confused, the chap asked to speak to a technician who said it wasn't true.
And, a few weeks later:
His car needed 3 hours "investigative" labour to diagnose a warning light. When he spoke to the technician to query, he was told that the propblem had been fixed in 10 minutes of the car being looked at.
He's not very impressed, unsurprisingly. Could there be any truth to the first example? I'm no mechanic but can't imagine why on earth you would have to change the opposite bearing at the same time.
Is this kind of behaviour generally commonplace?
The Porsche Service Centre at West Byfleet were blummin marvellous to me last week. I've been using Guildford for the last 3 years, and whilst I don't have any particular problems with that OPC in general, they're not always the most helpful and endearing dealership I know. Last Thursday, I was due to drive to Bath and as I left my house and proceeded through Byfleet, my coolant light came on. Instant panic, naturally. Luckily, I happened to literally be outside the West Byfleet Porsche centre and I pulled in. Car was up on a ramp within 15 minutes, and the fault diagnosed and temporarily rectified so I could continue my journey. Went back last week to have it replaced. Excellent service.
There is no reason that I can think of to replace both bearings at the same time. Not even sure that any of the work is shared.
The only thing I can think of is that it might be assumed that they have both had the same life, so the other one should follow.
I think that the service advisor may not be quite as technically advanced as he thinks. You sure you weren't talking to the cleaner?
WRT the diagnostic time, its very difficult to predict how long it would take to diagnose an electrical fault, so I guess 3hrs was a worst case scenario. Having taken 10 mins to diagnose, should, I assume mean that far less should have been charged.
What I can't understand is how your friend is managing to get to talk to the technician?
The only thing I can think of is that it might be assumed that they have both had the same life, so the other one should follow.
I think that the service advisor may not be quite as technically advanced as he thinks. You sure you weren't talking to the cleaner?
WRT the diagnostic time, its very difficult to predict how long it would take to diagnose an electrical fault, so I guess 3hrs was a worst case scenario. Having taken 10 mins to diagnose, should, I assume mean that far less should have been charged.
What I can't understand is how your friend is managing to get to talk to the technician?
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


