Gas stove Vs Wood burning stove
Gas stove Vs Wood burning stove
Author
Discussion

markbs

Original Poster:

362 posts

274 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
Insipired by the other threads on woodburning stoves, I decided to get one installed. Picked out a Charnwood C Four and called a local reputable company who can sort out the stove / install / some minor building work. However, he's installed lots of wood burning stoves and said I should really think about a Gas stove instead as I'm doing it for the look (real flames!) and heat output (4.9kw for the size of our lounge - 13m X 24m). We have a chimney (139cm wide on the outside wall) so it'll fit most stoves.

Has anyone got a Gas stove? Can anyone recommend a good one that looks like the C Four? Must chuck out lots of heat and look like the real deal.

The think thats made me wobble is that he said the woodburner is a "hobby" and will need a fair amount of faff. Is it worth the effort?

illmonkey

19,842 posts

229 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
I have a wood burner and it is not hard to do at all. We've spend all of 5 minutes emptying the ash in a whole year. (You're meant to keep the ash built up)

Get what you want, not what he makes more money fitting. Wood is great to burn, get used to the stove and its 100% adjustable, you can make a log last 5 minutes or an hour.

Sleepers

317 posts

196 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
I removed an LPG gas stove and replaced it with a Stovax multifuel stove.

The Stovax is much hotter, cosy and nice to look at where as the gas version was dull and boring even though it's new price was c£1000!

It's also a lot more fun and interesting...

No contest...

markbs

Original Poster:

362 posts

274 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies guys.

To answer the questions...

1. Am I rural? Not really, but I've got a decent sized garden that has a spot that could take logs? How big would a ton of logs be? The size of a mini? Smaller?
2. The costs of the wood burner or gas burner are going to be around £1K and they'll match any internet price so I don't think they are being biased
3. Cost of the gas / logs not too important - I'm assuming gas is cheaper, but it's not part of the decision process.

Realistically, I know gas is going to be simpler due to not having to chop wood, store wood, bring wood into the house, clean out the stove, wait for it to come up to temp etc. Whereas the Gas is all instant. I guess I'm not sure how good the gas will look - the output is supposed to be the same for both...

illmonkey

19,842 posts

229 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
Find out how much wood is locally. I paid £100 for 3meters cubed, it took up about... 3 cubic meters hehe

It depends on how you start the fire, but mine is up to a good temp within 10 or so minutes.


Sleepers

317 posts

196 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
markbs said:
Thanks for the replies guys.

To answer the questions...

1. Am I rural? Not really, but I've got a decent sized garden that has a spot that could take logs? How big would a ton of logs be? The size of a mini? Smaller?
2. The costs of the wood burner or gas burner are going to be around £1K and they'll match any internet price so I don't think they are being biased
3. Cost of the gas / logs not too important - I'm assuming gas is cheaper, but it's not part of the decision process.

Realistically, I know gas is going to be simpler due to not having to chop wood, store wood, bring wood into the house, clean out the stove, wait for it to come up to temp etc. Whereas the Gas is all instant. I guess I'm not sure how good the gas will look - the output is supposed to be the same for both...
The gas stove did not heat up any quicker as it's a relatively small flame to warm up 100kgs of steel/cast iron...


ghamer

626 posts

186 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
Have got 2 woodburners to be honest they,re a pain in the ass sometimes contrary to what people say the ash does need cleaning out daily,the whole fire reqs two major cleanouts per year.They produce lots of dust in the rooms.They,re messy to look at after the ash spills all over the hearth and nearby floors.Logs are also a large pain in the ass.You need a plentiful supply,somewhere to store and the right seasoned wood,which is why we use a combo of wood and coal.All this said,we would,nt be without them because in the deepest darkest winter when they,re in full flow we love them and they are wonderful to come home from work get them lit and enjoy.I guess its a personal choice as I,m a gas fitter and could,ve easily fit gas fires but boy,I,m glad I did,nt!

robwilk

818 posts

211 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
Going against the grain here but I fitted a wood burner and it was dusty, and it used wood at an alarming rate I thought it looked great but the missus was not happy as I work away and she had to clean up all over as it puffed dust out everytime you opened the door and she hated having to get the wood, it used more than we could store next to it.
I changed it out for a harmony gas fire http://www.euroheat.co.uk/HarmonyGasConventional.p... and it looks great no mess and the missus is happy so a thumbs up from me.
Had I worked at home I would have probably kept the wood burner.
One thing to look for if you get gas is the output , ours has a large output ( seems they dont make it any more) but it heats up the room very quickly and the flames die down due to the thermostat. so if you want flames make sure its not over sized.

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
We love our wood burner. I was advised by the installer to only use a max of about 3" dia logs. Wood likes to burn quickly, and it can't if they're too big. If I do put big ones on, I get more ash left behind.