I know people like "Old School" stuff, but....
I know people like "Old School" stuff, but....
Author
Discussion

Kermit power

Original Poster:

29,622 posts

242 months

Wednesday 5th October 2011
quotequote all
What the hell is the attraction of the F W Evans 90th Anniversary Special???

At £1,645, it seems incredibly expensive for what you get, even if you do like that sort of thing? Also, why would you choose those odd little bar end shifter things rather than having them in with the brakes?

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 5th October 2011
quotequote all
what a joke, its not even a quality steel, just regular 531. You could get 853 for the price and not suffer the shame... hell a Dawes Super Galaxay is twice the bike and would proably come in cheaper.

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 5th October 2011
quotequote all
I must admit to looking at this a few days ago for a birthday treat, but it will be for my 50th which explains a lot!. I like the fact that it is classic with no new fangled carbon or muppetry in sight. Built to last a lifetime, which admittedly is shorter at my agesmileThe Ultra Galaxy is a little more expensive.
I am leaning towards the Moulton now, a beautiful machine in my eyes, also with bar-end shifters!:-
http://www.evanscycles.com/products/moulton/tour-s...

Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 5th October 12:00

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

219 months

Wednesday 5th October 2011
quotequote all
Cycling Active rated it as a top touring bike built in the hand-made tradition with no corners cut and beautiful attention to detail like leather grippers on the bottle cages.

Not the sort of thing I'd spend £1,600 on, but I can see the appeal, and if you value rock-solid quality instead of pinching a few grams here and there, it makes a lot of sense.

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 5th October 2011
quotequote all
at least get something that has some credentials, maybe a Dave Yates frame or the "new" Holdsworth if you are really going to treat yourself.

http://www.cyclingweekly.co.uk/tech/bikes/129082/1...

IMHO there is nothing prestigious about the Evans bike, just gas pipes welded together with a HTT and some old oddities thrown on it. I mean, I'm a Shimano/SRAM man myself, but even I would have expected it to be decked out with Campag....

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 5th October 2011
quotequote all
pablo said:
at least get something that has some credentials, maybe a Dave Yates frame or the "new" Holdsworth if you are really going to treat yourself.

http://www.cyclingweekly.co.uk/tech/bikes/129082/1...

IMHO there is nothing prestigious about the Evans bike, just gas pipes welded together with a HTT and some old oddities thrown on it. I mean, I'm a Shimano/SRAM man myself, but even I would have expected it to be decked out with Campag....
I dont like the Orange paintwork or the carbon forks. But Its early days, still looking around at the moment. I'm drawn towards the Moulton to satisfy some strange urge!

Kermit power

Original Poster:

29,622 posts

242 months

Wednesday 5th October 2011
quotequote all
pablo said:
I'm a Shimano/SRAM man myself, but even I would have expected it to be decked out with Campag....
Even more so when you read the comment from the guy who bought one which says they've downgraded (without dropping the price) from a 9 speed cassette and 105 rear mech to an 8 speed and cheapo Deore MTB mech because the shifters can only cope with 8 speed cassettes!

The more I look at it, the more I wonder if they'll manage to shift all 90?

Saddle bum

4,211 posts

248 months

Thursday 6th October 2011
quotequote all
On a wider issue. As much as I like looking at 1980s and 90s Colnagos, etc. I could not bear the thought of actually riding one on a regular basis. Technology has improved cycling no end, Scandium, Carbon, etc. have made our cycling lives better and that is what i enjoy using.

Rocksteadyeddie

7,971 posts

256 months

Thursday 6th October 2011
quotequote all
My mountain bike is a Dave Yates 853 and is a wonderful thing (at least I think it is as it has been stuck in the garage festooned with a child seat for as long as I can remember).

Re the Evans MAMIL special - since when has a triple been traditional (or even acceptable)?

HowMuchLonger

3,041 posts

222 months

Thursday 6th October 2011
quotequote all
Rocksteadyeddie said:
My mountain bike is a Dave Yates 853...
I always wanted a Chas Roberts mtb...it was the Dogs Bo.ll.ox.

anonymous-user

83 months

Thursday 6th October 2011
quotequote all
The Evans or Dawes Galaxy will still be in regular use years after the latest Carbon bikes are in the bicycle graveyard! Not everyone wants marginal/negligable weight savings & prefer the comfort & longevity of a steel framed bike. Maybe triple's are not traditional, but they have their uses, very good on the steeper hills around my way. Horses for courses & all that...

Kermit power

Original Poster:

29,622 posts

242 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
swerni said:
The only thing I would consider for a tourer is steel

I'm getting a one hand built.


I want it to be unique and last longer than I do.
Why not Titanium, out of interest?

IroningMan

10,598 posts

275 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Why would a grown man want a touring bike, out of interest?

anonymous-user

83 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
IroningMan said:
Why would a grown man want a touring bike, out of interest?
Comfort, longevity, not wanting the latest gadget or passing fad, to name but a few!
In real life it will only be marginally slower than the latest Chinese carbon monstrosity wink but will last a lifetime.

Uriel

3,244 posts

280 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
How does steel last longer than carbon?

IroningMan

10,598 posts

275 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
At current rates of use my Chinese carbon monstrosity will easily last a lifetime, too...

Kermit power

Original Poster:

29,622 posts

242 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Jimboka said:
IroningMan said:
Why would a grown man want a touring bike, out of interest?
Comfort, longevity, not wanting the latest gadget or passing fad, to name but a few!
In real life it will only be marginally slower than the latest Chinese carbon monstrosity wink but will last a lifetime.
Hence my question of "why not Titanium"? Most Titanium frames seem to come with a lifetime warranty, have a great reputation for comfort, and seem to be very much focused towards the tourer/Audax niche.

Rocksteadyeddie

7,971 posts

256 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Kermit power said:
Jimboka said:
IroningMan said:
Why would a grown man want a touring bike, out of interest?
Comfort, longevity, not wanting the latest gadget or passing fad, to name but a few!
In real life it will only be marginally slower than the latest Chinese carbon monstrosity wink but will last a lifetime.
Hence my question of "why not Titanium"? Most Titanium frames seem to come with a lifetime warranty, have a great reputation for comfort, and seem to be very much focused towards the tourer/Audax niche.
yes I used to have a Litespeed. Lovely thing it was too.

Kermit power

Original Poster:

29,622 posts

242 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
swerni said:
Kermit power said:
swerni said:
The only thing I would consider for a tourer is steel

I'm getting a one hand built.


I want it to be unique and last longer than I do.
Why not Titanium, out of interest?
Why would I want titanium?
I don't know why you would want titanium, but I get the (possibly mistaken) impression that most titanium-framed bikes are tourers, hence my asking why you wouldn't consider it as a material for a tourer.

paranoid airbag

2,679 posts

188 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
pablo said:
at least get something that has some credentials, maybe a Dave Yates frame or the "new" Holdsworth if you are really going to treat yourself.

http://www.cyclingweekly.co.uk/tech/bikes/129082/1...

IMHO there is nothing prestigious about the Evans bike, just gas pipes welded together with a HTT and some old oddities thrown on it. I mean, I'm a Shimano/SRAM man myself, but even I would have expected it to be decked out with Campag....
I used to walk past the holdsworth in primo cycles... by god it's beautiful.