I am going to get lynched for this act of heresy.
I am going to get lynched for this act of heresy.
Author
Discussion

Traveller

Original Poster:

4,271 posts

238 months

Monday 14th November 2011
quotequote all
I am certain to be lynched, drawn and quartered, defenestrated and castrated for recommending an article by George Moonbat in the "think of the children" Guardian smile. I thought it would at the very least provoke a lively debate in any case. I find some of his points he agree with Nassim Taleb, about good fortune playing a much more important part role in success than ability.

Click on here to be taken to the dark side

Harry Flashman

21,052 posts

263 months

Monday 14th November 2011
quotequote all
He's right. We city folk are nasty. In my last psych evaluation, I was told that I was borderline sociopathic. Which was something of a surprise, let me tell you, as I have always prided myself on being nice to other people where possible.

Don't believe everything you read. We'd all like to believe that successful/motivated people are all amoral psychopaths - but that gross generalisation that Monbiot seems to be making is just that: a gross generalisation.

Do I think that wealth is too concentrated in the hands of a few? Absolutely. Do I have a solution? Not really. Am I going to pointlessly and jealously blams all corporations/private enterprise for the ills of the world? No - because I'm not Monbiot, with his blinkered view of the world, good and evil. Corporations are like anything else - there are good people in them, and bad people - and the latter aren't always the folk running things, no matter what these modish "psych tests" may tell you.

*leaves to kill a hooker and steal money from poor people*

Traveller

Original Poster:

4,271 posts

238 months

Monday 14th November 2011
quotequote all
Harry Flashman said:
He's right. We city folk are nasty. In my last psych evaluation, I was told that I was borderline sociopathic. Which was something of a surprise, let me tell you, as I have always prided myself on being nice to other people where possible.

Don't believe :Deverything you read. We'd all like to believe that successful/motivated people are all amoral psychopaths - but that gross generalisation that Monbiot seems to be making is just that: a gross generalisation.

Do I think that wealth is too concentrated in the hands of a few? Absolutely. Do I have a solution? Not really. Am I going to pointlessly and jealously blams all corporations/private enterprise for the ills of the world? No - because I'm not Monbiot, with his blinkered view of the world, good and evil. Corporations are like anything else - there are good people in them, and bad people - and the latter aren't always the folk running things, no matter what these modish "psych tests" may tell you.

*leaves to kill a hooker and steal money from poor people*
I must agree that the defining characteristics of a psychopath would make it the perfect psychological profile for climbing the corporate ladder or political greasy pole, I also agree with his point about luck being more important than talent, something that Taleb also strongly points out.

"leaves to kill a hooker and steal money from poor people" should be Goldman corporate motto or the motto for long distance truck drivers ?