Mini Cooper S or Civic Type R (EP3)
Mini Cooper S or Civic Type R (EP3)
Author
Discussion

underdosed

Original Poster:

112 posts

180 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Hi Everyone,

Just joined up here (even though I spend most of my day lurking!) and am looking to buy one of the above, whats everyones thoughts on the two?

underdosed

Original Poster:

112 posts

180 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
anyone?

80sboy

452 posts

188 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Mini Cooper S John Cooper Works...

Type R is fun for 5 minutes, then it becomes a pain in the back side.

stargazer30

1,722 posts

197 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Both good cars but you'd need to tell us more about what you want out of them. EP3 CTR will be cheaper, whats your budget? Do you need the space of the CTR vs the lack of it in a Mini etc...


r1ch

2,956 posts

227 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Depends on your gender.

angusfaldo

2,831 posts

305 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
I don't like either of them.

But I'm guessing you're looking for something a little more objective? Don't make us do the work - what do you really want to know?

Torquey

1,961 posts

259 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
r1ch said:
Depends on your gender.
laugh

rich_b

694 posts

277 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
I have experience of driving the older supercharged MCS, presumably the one you are looking at if comparing to EP3.

Plus points for the mini are great handling, nice supercharger whine and LSD (an option but a very good one)

Minus points are not quite enough power for me (perhaps a smaller SC pulley would help), ~30mpg average fuel economy from a 1.6 and crashy ride due to the run flats/hard suspension.

RVVUNM

1,913 posts

240 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
I just got shot of a Cooper S for a Type R (ep3) and I wouldn't go back. The mini was slow,heavy,cramped and very thirsty, on the other hand the EP3 is alive,eager,spacious and better on fuel and it goes mentle at 6000rpm.

R300will

3,799 posts

182 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
clio 197/182 depending on budget? naff interiors but brilliant hot hatch.

underdosed

Original Poster:

112 posts

180 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Budget is about £6000, always wanted a type R but for some reason have taken a liking to the Cooper S recently so just wondered what people thought. Not bothered about boot space etc as no kids or anything. Just want something quick & fun.

80sboy

452 posts

188 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Have you thought about a Fiat 500 Abarth?

I don't know how it drives, but they look pretty cool and sound awesome.

It's a girls car though.

underdosed

Original Poster:

112 posts

180 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Maybe, but insurance at 25 with an accident last year is £700-£800 for either the Mini or Type R and I imagine a Z4 is a lot more, and I'm not a massive fan of BMW's in general!

toon10

7,154 posts

188 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
I'd have the Honda as I love high revving engines and I don't work in the hair adjustment industry ;-)

underdosed

Original Poster:

112 posts

180 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Yeah did think about an S2000, call me gay or whatever but heard there a little inclined to go sideways and I've never owned a rearwheel drive car. Oh and the insurance is another £300.

Baryonyx

18,295 posts

190 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
A classic Japanese hot hatch versus a quick car for the girls to go shopping in? I'd go for the Honda, this is an easy one.

Rouleur

7,430 posts

220 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Best thing to do is wait for member 300bhp/ton to offer his advice, you'll love him!

underdosed

Original Poster:

112 posts

180 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
Rouleur said:
Best thing to do is wait for member 300bhp/ton to offer his advice, you'll love him!
Dunno if this is a good thing or a bad thing?!

80sboy

452 posts

188 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
underdosed said:
Maybe, but insurance at 25 with an accident last year is £700-£800 for either the Mini or Type R and I imagine a Z4 is a lot more, and I'm not a massive fan of BMW's in general!
I bought my Z4 3.0i at 23 and paid about £900 for fully comp insurance. Went down to about £770 at 25.

It really was a great car, so smooth, quick, plenty of toys, well built, and pretty economical!

I got about 29/30mpg average, on a long run with a full boot and my girlfriend I got a calculated 37.5mpg.

Sold it now. I miss it!

This car is in a completely different league in my opinion.

Another one you could go for is a 350z. Not as refined, cheaper interior, and a little hard work, but it's still a great buy. Not as economical as the Z4 either.

Chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Tuesday 22nd November 2011
quotequote all
underdosed said:
Yeah did think about an S2000, call me gay or whatever but heard there a little inclined to go sideways and I've never owned a rearwheel drive car. Oh and the insurance is another £300.
If £300 extra insurance is an issue then perhaps you should look for something cheaper than a Cooper S or CTR.